2024 1st round pick #4 is Marvin Harrison Jr

[Russ Smith]

If the ESPN stats are correct, Marv now has 35 targets and only 17 catches. 2 catches 7 targets today.

4 TD's is obviously impressive for a rookie but it is pretty alarming, Kyler has 33 incompletions on the season and 18 of them are to MHJ!

 

[Proteus]

I think a lot more of his targets should be on throws other than back shoulder throws.

 

[BirdGangThing]

mhj needs some new routes - the book is out on this kid

 

[football karma]

I think he needs to be far more aggressive at the catch point

it makes me realize how spoiled i have been by Fitz.

 

[Cbus cardsfan]

mhj needs some new routes - the book is out on this kid

This is fascinatingly hilarious.
The book is out on him 5 games into his career?????
Look at HOF WR Larry Fitzgeralds rookie stats, 58 for 780 Marvin is gonna blow those out of the water.

 

[Vacard]

This is fascinatingly hilarious.
The book is out on him 5 games into his career?????
Look at HOF WR Larry Fitzgeralds rookie stats, 58 for 780 Marvin is gonna blow those out of the water.

He also played with Boldin that year too meaning he wasnt the no.1 receiver

Im not saying MHJ is a disappointment, but Kyler not even targeting him when he had a alot cushion is a concern.

 

[Russ Smith]

This is fascinatingly hilarious.
The book is out on him 5 games into his career?????
Look at HOF WR Larry Fitzgeralds rookie stats, 58 for 780 Marvin is gonna blow those out of the water.

He's not on a pace to do that. He'll have about the same catches at his current pace, more yards and more TD's. ANd Fitz had Anquan in his prime(just over half the year Anquan got hurt that year), and Fitz was playing with McCown at QB.

He's really good it's just surprising son of a HOFer grew up around the game I thought he'd be more polished than he is.

 

[BirdGangThing]

This is fascinatingly hilarious.
The book is out on him 5 games into his career?????
Look at HOF WR Larry Fitzgeralds rookie stats, 58 for 780 Marvin is gonna blow those out of the water.

defenses know his routes and when we're throwing to him - he's smothered and covered like waffle house hash browns and has to rely on pure talent in tight contested spaces - new routes that would also allow him more separation - crossing patterns to trip up crossing defenders - late developing routes so Kyler can look the safety off

but please continue to ramble on about larry freaking fitzgerald - even tho everything but the uniforms have changed since larry fitzgerald

im not knocking the kid either - im saying he runs in straight lines that ultimately lead to a safety - im saying defenses are giving him all star respect and it's probably partly why wilson is balling

 

[Cbus cardsfan]

Larry had 58 catches on 115 targets his rookie year. Just over a 50% success rate.
My point is, hes a rookie. Why are people trying to judge him after 5 games when he is the #1 option in the passing game and teams are game planning for him?

Murray has only thrown for over 210 yards in a game once this year.

He’s probably going to finish 3rd in OROY.

It’s the same as people bitching about Trey Benson. Benson is behind the main cog in the offense. He’s going to be limited and he’s a ROOKIE.

Other than Daniels, what rookie is tearing up the league?
Nabers had 1 good game. Oduzne has done very little. Same with Coleman.

 

[SoonerLou]

Larry had 58 catches on 115 targets his rookie year. Just over a 50% success rate.
My point is, hes a rookie. Why are people trying to judge him after 5 games when he is the #1 option in the passing game and teams are game planning for him?

Murray has only thrown for over 210 yards in a game once this year.

He’s probably going to finish 3rd in OROY.

It’s the same as people bitching about Trey Benson. Benson is behind the main cog in the offense. He’s going to be limited and he’s a ROOKIE.

Other than Daniels, what rookie is tearing up the league?
Nabers had 1 good game. Oduzne has done very little. Same with Coleman.

Nabers and Brian Thomas Jr have been really good.

While I hate to bring up Kliff, I think MHJ would have more consistent success if he was in Kliff's offense. Kliff knew to keep Hopkins involvedd/engaged. I don't think Petzing has "easy" plays to build up MHJ right now. Its all based on Kyler/MHJ needing really good chemistry.

 

[Cheesebeef]

Larry had 58 catches on 115 targets his rookie year. Just over a 50% success rate.
My point is, hes a rookie. Why are people trying to judge him after 5 games when he is the #1 option in the passing game and teams are game planning for him?

Murray has only thrown for over 210 yards in a game once this year.

He’s probably going to finish 3rd in OROY.

It’s the same as people bitching about Trey Benson. Benson is behind the main cog in the offense. He’s going to be limited and he’s a ROOKIE.

Other than Daniels, what rookie is tearing up the league?
Nabers had 1 good game. Oduzne has done very little. Same with Coleman.

Nabers has already had 2 100 yard games, a third with 78 yards and 2 TDs and a fourth with 66 yards. All as the number 1 option on his team.

The other rookie WR Thomas from LSU has had a 122 yard 1 TD, 94 yards and 86 and a TD, alongside two 47 yard games.

Are you really gonna be a guy who rightfully bashes Kyler Stans for never criticizing their guy and hyperbolizing his play and then turn around and do the same thing with your OSU player?

Marv has been a disappointment so far. Period. Trying to argue against that, especially by distorting or ignoring what other rookie WRs have done so far this year, is pretty foolish.

 

[Cbus cardsfan]

Nabers and Brian Thomas Jr have been really good.

While I hate to bring up Kliff, I think MHJ would have more consistent success if he was in Kliff's offense. Kliff knew to keep Hopkins involvedd/engaged. I don't think Petzing has "easy" plays to build up MHJ right now. Its all based on Kyler/MHJ needing really good chemistry.

Nabers has been better so far. Thomas has similar production.

But my point is, why the complaints about Harrison. Hes been fine.

I agree about Petzing. I’m not sure what his offense is yet. It seems his best offense is hoping Connor breaks tackles to get a 1st down.

 

[Gambler]

mhj needs some new routes - the book is out on this kid

The book is out on every receiver, yet they still perform.

 

[Cbus cardsfan]

Nabers has already had 2 100 yard games, a third with 78 yards and 2 TDs and a fourth with 66 yards. All as the number 1 option on his team.

The other rookie WR Thomas from LSU has had a 122 yard 1 TD, 94 yards and 86 and a TD, alongside two 47 yard games.

Are you really gonna be a guy who rightfully bashes Kyler Stans for never criticizing their guy and hyperbolizing his play and then turn around and do the same thing with your OSU player?

Marv has been a disappointment so far. Period. Trying to argue against that, especially by distorting or ignoring what other rookie WRs have done so far this year, is pretty foolish.

Nabers has had 52 targets to Marvins 28 also.

 

[Hoodhero]

K1 said it best "4th down, who am I going to". They will both get better playing wth each other. You don't win the game if he don't make the 4th down catch regardless of his stats up to that pt.