For me, that doesn't translate into great acting. He's a kook, but so is Mickey Rouke. Doesn't make them the next Marlon Brando. (Although I thought Rouke was brilliant in Sin City).AZZenny said:Yeah, he is. (IMHO)
One thing all of the named guys have in common, apart from the ability to be the role, is they are all extremely daring and creative, and have less concern for their 'box office appeal' than for the work they do. Depp probably pushes that risk farther than any of the others, to a point that he's less careful about the projects he signs on to,
I'll also admit that I'm slightly biased by the fact that Depp bugs me (way before his politics became headlines).