American Idol IV

[Djaughe]

....Jessica was upset, but didn't cry.

One of previous shows Simon told her that he didn't think that she had that "it" look...thats gotta hurt!

 

[Gee!]

Was she even that good? I have watched every show, and to be honest I cant recall what she sang. Must not be too memorable of performances.

Ah well...bye bye Jessica

 

[Djaughe]

Was she even that good? ....

Well maddog always had his saying that 'beauty is a light switch away'.....

 

[Dback Jon]

Well maddog always had his saying that 'beauty is a light switch away'.....

 

[Gee!]

Well maddog always had his saying that 'beauty is a light switch away'.....

Thats gotta suck if every girl he dated said the exact same thing about him...

 

[Dback Jon]

We can only hope Anthony or Scott gets voted out tonight - both were painful to listen to.


And what exactly is Paula Abdul on?

 

[Gee!]

Paula has a crush on Constantine!

 

[Djaughe]

Egad who's idea was to pick 'musicals'??


Methinks savol is starting to slip and i'm sure this tidbit isn't gonna help much...

http://www.thesmokinggun.com/archive/0331051_american_idol_scott_1.html

 

[CaptTurbo]

Paula has a crush on Constantine!

How is this triple chinned guy still in it?

 

[Djaughe]

How is this triple chinned guy still in it?

I'm shocked too...

The dude has an uncanny ability to pick songs that seem to be hitting the mainstream audience...last night he did the 'my lovely valentine' song and probably has elevated himself to the top 3...

 

[Dback Jon]

Fan-ta-shia shinging tonight.....

 

[Pariah]

How is this triple chinned guy still in it?

Ha! I say the same thing to my wife.

Actually, he's gotten MUCH better since the first few weeks. He should have been voted out then, IMO. But, since he wasn't and is now seemingly pretty good, he might have a shot to go much further. The fickle hand of fate, I guess...

 

[FischerKing]

I'm shocked too...

The dude has an uncanny ability to pick songs that seem to be hitting the mainstream audience...last night he did the 'my lovely valentine' song and probably has elevated himself to the top 3...

i was totally when they announced that's the song he was going to sing. it's one of my favorites, but it's a very difficult song to sing with all the changes in it - then he started and i was - i couldn't believe he pulled it off and he did it extremely well.

don't like him but he deserves a :notworthy for his rendition at least.

shawn

 

[Gee!]

Nikko gets the boot!

 

[Djaughe]

Nikko gets the boot!

Savol dude was soooo lucky. Hopefully he'll break his streak of wimpy perfermances...

 

[Dback Jon]

Savol dude was soooo lucky. Hopefully he'll break his streak of wimpy perfermances...

It should have been him (or Anthony)

 

[marathon_mom]

It should have been him (or Anthony)

I think Nikko's great. Just goes to show how stupid & tone deaf Americans can be. And Anthony had on WAY to much mascara last night.


Fantasia rocked! "Just get ugly up there!" lmao

 

[Gee!]

I think Nikko's great.

 

[marathon_mom]

 

[Dback Jon]

Actually had good performances all around last night.

Predicted bottom three: Nadia, Anwar and Carrie.

 

[CaptTurbo]

Dont know the names but the chick who is usually country but sang a rock song is looking hotter each week and did great.

The triple chin guy singing Bohemia Rapsody? I mean cmon there is only 1 person in the world who can sing that and he is dead.

 

[Pariah]

My wife and I were totally opposite from the judges on almost every one of the preformances last night. We were underwhelmed by Bo; thought the blonde doing Pat Benetar was spectatcular and crossed the genre line with ease; thought the black girl who did "let's hear it fort the boy" was out of tune and a beat too slow; but Constantine doing "Bohemian Rhapsody" was brilliant.

When I heard he was doing Bohemian Rhapsody I thought exactly what SWD said, but he really pulled it off. Not bad for a guy who a month ago cound;t carry a tune. Where the hell did he come from. I thought for sure he would be one of the first to go, but after the last few preformances, I think it's going to be him and the blonde in the finals.

Bo really needs to step it up. I think he's a far better singer than Constantine, but his song choices have been suspect at best lately. Although, what's up with Simon implying that "Freebyrd" isn't a well-known song? It's a friggin Southern Rock anthem, fer chrissakes. The whole of the south will be voting for Bo this week because of Simon's comment, IMO.

 

[jf-08]

Dont know the names but the chick who is usually country but sang a rock song is looking hotter each week and did great.

She looked damn hot. Carrie Underwood.

The triple chin guy singing Bohemia Rapsody? I mean cmon there is only 1 person in the world who can sing that and he is dead.

I thought he did a pretty good job.

Anwar is getting too boring. Geez, all of his songs sound the same. I thought Bo wasn't earth shattering last night. Federov just doesn't have any charisma. Vonzell was pretty good. I still think Nadia is very good, but didn't like her choice of songs last night. Scott can't hit a low note. He has a tremendous voice on the mid and upper range, but just kills the low ones.

 

[Pariah]

Predicted bottom three: Nadia, Anwar and Carrie.

I'll say Scott, Anthony and Nadia.

Anthony goes home this week.

 

[Pariah]

Anwar is getting too boring. Geez, all of his songs sound the same.

Last night I said, "doesn't he do this song every week?"

It's funny that every week the judges tell him he's "technically the best singer in the competition." That's good, because as a music teacher you need that. As a preformer, you need to not be boring. I think the only thing that keeps him around for the next couple of weeks is because he flashed some sex appeal by showing some chest this week.