American Idol IV

[marathon_mom]

Corey's a slug. Slimeball. I hope she sues him.

 

[CardFan67]

Anthony
Scott
Carrie

I think these will be the bottom three... Constantine should be there instead of Carrie based on perfomance but there are too many teenie bopper girl voters out there... Oh and DBJ's...

 

[Dback Jon]

Anthony
Scott
Carrie

I think these will be the bottom three... Constantine should be there instead of Carrie based on perfomance but there are too many teenie bopper girl voters out there... Oh and DBJ's...

Scott was horrendous. Carrie mediocre

Vonzell and Bo were great!

 

[Pariah]

Bottom three:

Scott
Anthony
Vonzell

Anthony did a pretty good job last night, IMO. I was impressed, but I dont think it was good enough to over come weeks of suckiness.

Scott goes home.

 

[Pariah]

That was a rough theme for me this week. I'd never heard any of those songs.

 

[CardFan67]

That was a rough theme for me this week. I'd never heard any of those songs.

I liked the theme but I thought Constantine butchered that song...

 

[Pariah]

I liked the theme but I thought Constantine butchered that song...

You;re right--That's the one song I had heard, but he mangled it.

Constantine is in a tough spot. He's got this rocker image, but he sucks at rocking.

 

[Djaughe]

I think Paula's banging Constantine now.

....Constantine is in a tough spot. He's got this rocker image, but he sucks at rocking.

 

[MigratingOsprey]

yep ... he should stick to the david cassidy route .... constantine =/= rock

i think the bottom 3 will be scott, carrie & vonzell

anthony seems to have his fans for some unknown reason and actually did alright this week ... may be enough to get him through

scott has to be gone .. how can a man that large continually dodge bullets?

vonzell, in my opinion, is very good ... but many just don't like her

carrie I like, but she hasn't been strong recently and her sound seemed very muffled last night

 

[marathon_mom]

Scott was horrendous. Carrie mediocre

Vonzell and Bo were great!

Was surprised by Carrie's performance. She's usually better than that. Especially with a song she really knows.

It's Scott's turn to say bye-bye. He sang a very emotional song and put no emotion in it. Almost like he was distracted or something. I thought it sucked.

Bo...what can I say? Awesome.:notworthy
Vonzell...beautiful, great stage presence, works the audience. I hope Randy & Pauls were right. I'd like to see her continue.
Anthony...pulled off a toughy. Chicks dig him so he'll probably move forward.

I enjoyed the little stories about the hometowns & family stuff. Bo's Mom & Dad cracked me up.

 

[MadCardDisease]

Scott needs to go.

Constantine and Carrie will also be in the bottem three.

 

[Mike Olbinski]

Ya'll need to leave Carrie alone

Mike

 

[Town Drunk]

I'm watching it right now, and I'm just going to say that you'll be shocked who's in the bottom three

 

[marathon_mom]

Shocked is right. Savol NOT in the bottom 3??? What is the matter with the voters??? I mean, come on people! Get it together!!! Maybe the constant callers are all tone deaf. Not that Scott sucks, but he sure did Tuesday night. gggrrrrrrrrrr...Momma not a happy camper.

 

[Mike Olbinski]

The American Public sucks...

Mike

 

[marathon_mom]

The American Public sucks...

Mike

 

[Pariah]

Wow. I might have to agree with th public is it were soley based on Tuesday's preformance, but ...WOW. What a shame. Did you see the look on Scott's face?

And, by the way...Paula is definately banging Constantine. Did you see her talking to his mom during his preformance? I have a great TV that picks up sound most others can't. What she was saying was: "Don't worry, Mrs. M. I'll still come over for dinners on Friday night."

 

[freebyrd]

can't believe constantine got voted off, somebody on another board said there is a website called vote for the worst dot com or something like that where they power vote for scott savol whom i cannot stand in the least, so say hello to your big dumb fat gangster wanna be american idol
freebyrd

 

[CaptTurbo]

What shocked me is constantine getting this far. ugh he is awful. Just plain awful. But they all are on this show I think.

 

[Russ Smith]

can't believe constantine got voted off, somebody on another board said there is a website called vote for the worst dot com or something like that where they power vote for scott savol whom i cannot stand in the least, so say hello to your big dumb fat gangster wanna be american idol
freebyrd

That would explain a lot. Maybe thats the kind of thing to be discussed in the Dateline NBC expose of the show?

Even Scott knows he doesn't deserve to still be there. This is sort of like the OJ jury going for shock value.

 

[Dback Jon]

I was shocked as well - and who is voting for Savol?

I do know one of the websites I browse also sponsers a "Vote for the Worst", and Savol is the pick this year.

 

[kerouac9]

can't believe constantine got voted off, somebody on another board said there is a website called vote for the worst dot com or something like that where they power vote for scott savol whom i cannot stand in the least, so say hello to your big dumb fat gangster wanna be american idol
freebyrd

Sho' enough. Check the site out for yourself. It's worth it to see Scott's mug shot.

 

[kerouac9]

Also: how tight is it that they've covered this up: "Idol" Finalist Dodged Cocaine Rap

 

[MadCardDisease]

Also consider that Scott has all of Ohio voting for him. They have nothing better to do out there.

 

[Russ Smith]

Also consider that Scott has all of Ohio voting for him. They have nothing better to do out there.

Not true they're all watching LeBron lead the Cavs in the playoffs.... nevermind.

I think it would be pretty hysterical if Scott actually won on the strength of sites such as that one. I mean what could American Idol do, void the votes?

I've felt all along they should have a sliding scale that gives weight both to the judges opinions, and to the fan votes.