Best ever all-around Cardinal player

[Doc Cardinal]

I always liked John David Crow....but I'm an old fart.

 

[Duckjake]

Only going back as far as '88 here:
I too am going to ignore the technical criteria for this thread and say Larry Centers.
Dude was the heart and soul(much like Aneas was)and a beast.

In his 14 NFL seasons, Centers rushed for 2,188 yards, caught 827 passes for 6,797 yards, returned five punts for 30 yards, returned 33 kickoffs for 617 yards and scored 42 touchdowns (14 rushing/28 receiving).

Centers was a bright spot on some bad teams but...

Conrad also scored 42 TDs and added another 137 points kicking. Green had 69 TDs. Also Centers was never First Team All-Pro which was earned by both Conrad and Green.

 

[Buckybird]

Centers was a bright spot on some bad teams but...

Conrad also scored 42 TDs and added another 137 points kicking. Green had 69 TDs. Also Centers was never First Team All-Pro which was earned by both Conrad and Green.

Duck don't forget Jetstream was also ALL-MADDEN too, something I know Bobby Joe never sniffed!!! Madden called Roy the best player in the NFL in '84. Guess my boy wins.

 

[Duckjake]

Duck don't forget Jetstream was also ALL-MADDEN too, something I know Bobby Joe never sniffed!!! Madden called Roy the best player in the NFL in '84. Guess my boy wins.

There was no All-Madden team when Conrad played. Besides Madden is a bum. He left Larry Wilson off his all-millennium team.