Guys play to an older age these days and his game is not based upon speed. Whatever you think he will lose in terms of athleticism, I don't believe it touches his productivity. You do a 4 year deal to spread the cap hit and have an ability to end it after 3 or extend him further at a lower number.
If we had a young pass rusher that we could count on, I get moving on, but we don't. Golden, Kennard and Jones. Gardeck doesn't count.
If we had young front 7 players who were dominant, I get it, but we don't.
If Wilson, Simmons, and Collins all work out, Chandler's deal is on it's last year or finished before you have to give any one of those guys a new deal. Watt, Phillips, Kennard, and Hicks are all off the books after next year and some of them may not make it that long.
You are essentially paying Hopkins, Budda, Hudson and Kyler, after next year. DJ is up for a new deal. Murphy will need a new deal. Pony up and keep your players unless we are tearing the whole thing down.
Imagine having this locked up through 2024.
QB - Murray
WR - Hopkins
LT - Humphries
C - Hudson
EDGE - CJones
ILB - Simmons
CB - Murphy
S - Baker
That isn't counting rookie deals for Collins and Wilson who look like they can be at least ok players. That is a core of players on a team that has struggled to draft quality players.