Diamondbacks +- game

[DiamondBacks5117]

I am not going to lie i got this game off another board but thought it would be cool to try.
This game is very simple. Each Diamondback player starts with 20 points. Every day you add 1 point to 1 player if the have a good performance, and minus 1 point to 1 player if they have a bad performance. You can only vote once after every game.
Remember you dont have to vote for the same player as other people but you can if you want.
I will start with an example from the last red sox game. Just reply by saying
Randy johnson +because he had a good performance
Chad Tracy - bad performance
I will edit every time someone replys:
Remember when you reply just say randy+ -chad then i will edit it.
This game is so at the end of the year we can see players +- ratings based on how the fans think they performed from game to game.
There are a lot of variations to this game so if you would like to add ideas feel free. i just thought it would be soemthing cool to pass the time and see how we think are players do from game to game.

Juan Cruz +20
Doug Davis +20
Edgar Gonzalez +20
Livan Hernandez +20
Randy johnson +21
brandyon Lyon +20
Micha Owings +20
Jailen Peguero +21
Tony Pena +20
Doug Slaten +20
Jose Valverde +20
Brandon Webb +20
Migule Montero +20
Chris Snyder +19
Alberto Callaspo +20
Tony Clark +20
Stephen Drew +20
Orlando Hudson +20
Conor Jackson +20
Mark Reynolds +20
Chad Tracy +19
Eric Byrnes +20
Scott Hairston +20
Carlos Quentin +20
Chris young +20

ideas? comments? you want to play? I am sure if i go or am not here to post the mods can edit this so the game can keep going on.

 

[jpjapes]

+ jailen peguero: best ERA on team
- chris snyder: montero is better

 

[DiamondBacks5117]

+ jailen peguero: best ERA on team
- chris snyder: montero is better

just to let you no you dont have to give a reason for your vote but you can if you want. you can just say +jailen -snyder.

 

[Nasser22]

It would be easier if everyone updated as they went and you looked over it.

+Byrnes
-Jackson

Juan Cruz +20
Doug Davis +20
Edgar Gonzalez +20
Livan Hernandez +20
Randy johnson +21
brandyon Lyon +20
Micha Owings +21
Jailen Peguero +20
Tony Pena +20
Doug Slaten +20
Jose Valverde +20
Brandon Webb +20
Migule Montero +20
Chris Snyder +19
Alberto Callaspo +20
Tony Clark +20
Stephen Drew +20
Orlando Hudson +20
Conor Jackson +19
Mark Reynolds +20
Chad Tracy +19
Eric Byrnes +21
Scott Hairston +20
Carlos Quentin +20
Chris young +20

 

[DiamondBacks5117]

It would be easier if everyone updated as they went and you looked over it.

+Byrnes
-Jackson

Juan Cruz +20
Doug Davis +20
Edgar Gonzalez +20
Livan Hernandez +20
Randy johnson +21
brandyon Lyon +20
Micha Owings +21
Jailen Peguero +20
Tony Pena +20
Doug Slaten +20
Jose Valverde +20
Brandon Webb +20
Migule Montero +20
Chris Snyder +19
Alberto Callaspo +20
Tony Clark +20
Stephen Drew +20
Orlando Hudson +20
Conor Jackson +19
Mark Reynolds +20
Chad Tracy +19
Eric Byrnes +21
Scott Hairston +20
Carlos Quentin +20
Chris young +20

great idea! so no one has to edit it every time. quote the previous list and edit your votes in yourself.

 

[DiamondBacks5117]

Juan Cruz +20
Doug Davis +20
Edgar Gonzalez +20
Livan Hernandez +20
Randy johnson +21
brandyon Lyon +20
Micha Owings +20
Jailen Peguero +21
Tony Pena +20
Doug Slaten +20
Jose Valverde +20
Brandon Webb +20
Migule Montero +20
Chris Snyder +19
Alberto Callaspo +20
Tony Clark +20
Stephen Drew +20
Orlando Hudson +20
Conor Jackson +19
Mark Reynolds +20
Chad Tracy +19
Eric Byrnes +21
Scott Hairston +20
Carlos Quentin +20
Chris young +20

so quote this list then edit your votes in. nassar put jpjs vote for owings by accident so i made an updated list. so the next person quote this list and edit your votes in. great idea nassar

 

[AZZenny]

It should be based on game performance, not general feelings about a player, right? So if Snyder had a bad game, fine. But to take a point 'because Montero is better' (although he is) screws the idea up.

 

[FArting]

Originally posted by Diamondbacks5117

Juan Cruz +20
Doug Davis +20
Edgar Gonzalez +20
Livan Hernandez +20
Randy johnson +21
brandyon Lyon +20
Micha Owings +20
Jailen Peguero +21
Tony Pena +20
Doug Slaten +20
Jose Valverde +21
Brandon Webb +20
Migule Montero +20
Chris Snyder +19
Alberto Callaspo +19
Tony Clark +20
Stephen Drew +20
Orlando Hudson +21
Conor Jackson +19
Mark Reynolds +20
Chad Tracy +19
Eric Byrnes +21
Scott Hairston +20
Carlos Quentin +20
Chris young +20

 

[nathan]

Don't alert arthurracoon to this thread.

This was done on the Cardinals board and did not work out well. If I were a moderator I would delete this thread. JMHO

 

[DiamondBacks5117]

It would be easier if you put who you vote fo at the top like nassar did with +byrnes and -jackson. I think suns31 voted for three people. jose+ -Alberto and +Hudson. You can only vote for two people one+ and one-. I will take away suns 31ns votes because Hudson didnt do that well last game and Alberto didnt even play. its based on game performance. You dont have to quote the persons previous list just copy and paste. Azz it is based on game performance. I can tell its not going to work because the list is already getting messed up.
if you want to keep going copy and paste the previous list. I can tell its probably not going to work so if it ended o well. i wont be to Disapointed the first two people seemed to get it though. here is an updated list.

 

[DiamondBacks5117]

Juan Cruz +20
Doug Davis +20
Edgar Gonzalez +20
Livan Hernandez +20
Randy johnson +21
brandyon Lyon +20
Micha Owings +20
Jailen Peguero +21
Tony Pena +20
Doug Slaten +20
Jose Valverde +20
Brandon Webb +20
Migule Montero +20
Chris Snyder +19
Alberto Callaspo +20
Tony Clark +20
Stephen Drew +20
Orlando Hudson +20
Conor Jackson +19
Mark Reynolds +20
Chad Tracy +19
Eric Byrnes +21
Scott Hairston +20
Carlos Quentin +20
Chris young +20

just took waay suns 31ns votes because there based on game performance and he voted for 3 people. if you want to vote again suns for last gamne based on game performance you can.

 

[coyoteshockeyfan]

Don't alert arthurracoon to this thread.

This was done on the Cardinals board and did not work out well. If I were a moderator I would delete this thread. JMHO

Yeah, I think I'm going to have to agree with this. If you guys want to start up a different game I'm ok with it, but this one is kind of a mess.