I've only played about 4 or 5 games, but I have already seen some flaws that I don't like....
1. I threw a hard bullet pass over the middle and a DT on the defense reached up and gracefully grabbed it out of the air and intercepted it.
Your Manual lets you know when you throw a built pass it is lower and can be picked off easier.
2. No matter how high your QB's speed rating is, he is going to get sacked if he trys to out run a 350 lb DT behind the line of scrimmage
Are holding down the R button when you scramble or tapping the A button to run faster?
3. The "coaches pick" picks the same damn plays over and over and the playbook is not very deep
If you use the analoge control you can pick different packages to use with the same formation, you also can hit L and find another play they pick?
4. I don't like that drifting arrow on kick offs and punts, plus field goals are to automatic for the human player from 55 yards and closer
Then you will not like Madden either?
There is just something missing from this game that Madden always provided and I can't place my finger on it. Otherwise this is a challenging game, but I'm still going with EA Sports