Fantasy Trade Proposal Help

[DaCards]

I cant trust anyone else, so I pose the question to you all.....

I give up: Peyton Manning
Reggie Bush
Wes Welker

I get: Tom Brady
Stephen Jackson



Whatcha think......


or I now he says maybe I get Hines Ward for Wes Welker.....which trade is better

 

[Pariah]

It seems pretty even, to me. Your call--I don't think any one could give you grief over it either way.

Personally, I'd probably do it. Jackson will be the workhorse, and Bush, while so potentially explosive, is sharing time in the backfield.

 

[Goober Man]

I cant trust anyone else, so I pose the question to you all.....

I give up: Peyton Manning
Reggie Bush
Wes Welker

I get: Tom Brady
Stephen Jackson



Whatcha think......


or I now he says maybe I get Hines Ward for Wes Welker.....which trade is better

keep Peyton and Reggie..the only way i would trade Peyton would be for LT and M.Harrison..

 

[Skkorpion]

I cant trust anyone else, so I pose the question to you all.....

I give up: Peyton Manning
Reggie Bush
Wes Welker

I get: Tom Brady
Stephen Jackson



Whatcha think......


or I now he says maybe I get Hines Ward for Wes Welker.....which trade is better

Don't do that trade! You'll regret it.

 

[Goober Man]

Don't do that trade! You'll regret it.

exactly! people with Peyton on their team useally win the championship!

 

[TheCardFan]

I cant trust anyone else, so I pose the question to you all.....

I give up: Peyton Manning
Reggie Bush
Wes Welker

I get: Tom Brady
Stephen Jackson



Whatcha think......


or I now he says maybe I get Hines Ward for Wes Welker.....which trade is better

No way...you are already set.

Edit: But it does matter what type of scoring system you use.

 

[DaCards]

Its the typical yahoo scoring setup. Nothing tricky or uncommon.

The guy Im dealing with, really wants Wes Welker. I took him as a sleeper in the 12th round and it was his sleeper and he really wants him....

thats why hes involved in all these trades

 

[Goober Man]

Its the typical yahoo scoring setup. Nothing tricky or uncommon.

The guy Im dealing with, really wants Wes Welker. I took him as a sleeper in the 12th round and it was his sleeper and he really wants him....

thats why hes involved in all these trades

then just Trade Wes Welker for Hines Ward..and keep Peyton and Reggie

 

[DaCards]

New trade proposal....


I denied the last, based on your input...

Now he wants to give me Pitts Def. and Jabar Gaffney for Wes Welker


WHatcha think?

 

[Goober Man]

New trade proposal....


I denied the last, based on your input...

Now he wants to give me Pitts Def. and Jabar Gaffney for Wes Welker


WHatcha think?

Jabar isn't worth it..its a FA in most FF leagues..if anything just trade Wes Welker for Hines Ward or Pits D

 

[Pariah]

The more I think about it the more I like that original offer.

Jackson WILL outscore Bush.
Brady could outscore Manning.

Welker probably doesn't figure into your starters, and you'll have upgraded your RB in a big way and gone sideways with your QB.

My advice: get that original deal back.

 

[DaCards]

I just countered with Wes Welker and Mike Furrey for PIT D. and Jerricho Cotchery

 

[DaCards]

Nevermind, he apparently was happy with Wes and Mike F. so now I have NE and Pitt Def. and a new decent #2 Receiver

THanks guys

 

[Goober Man]

I just countered with Wes Welker and Mike Furrey for PIT D. and Jerricho Cotchery

man..im just happy with the 2 trades i did before preseason..i traded Deuce McAllister and Jerricho Cotchery for Lee Evans and Ronnie Brown..another trade i did was Jake Delhomme and Carolina D for Tony Romo and Dallas D

now my team looks like this

QB Peyton Manning
WR Anquan Boldin
WR Terry Glenn
WR Lee Evans
HB Willis McGahee
HB Edgerrin James
TE Tony Gonzalez
K Neil Rackers
D Baltimore

Backups
QB Tony Romo
WR Bernard Berrian
HB Adrian Peterson
HB Ronnie Brown
TE Eric Johnson
D Dallas

only problem is..most of my players BYE week is on week 8

 

[DaCards]

Thats a sick lineup....how many teams in your league?

Mines not as good. 12 teams in the league.

QB - Peyton Manning
WR - TJ Hous.
WR - Santana Moss
WR - Braylon Edwards
RB - Reggie Bush
RB - Ahman Green (big weakness)
TE - Chris Cooley
K - Robbie Gould
DEF - New England

Bench

QB - Chad Penn.
RB - Warrick Dunn
TE - Desmond Clark
WR - Jerricho Cotchery
DEF - Pitt and AZ (AZ was my pride pick)

 

[Goober Man]

Thats a sick lineup....how many teams in your league?

10 teams...standard Yahoo! scoring

 

[Chris_Sanders]

Terry Glenn is out indefinitely. If you are counting him as a starter you have already lost.

 

[Goober Man]

Terry Glenn is out indefinitely. If you are counting him as a starter you have already lost.

hes out in preseason..im sure he'll play when the regular season starts..and besides even if he is i have backups than can still score some points with Q and Evans..

 

[Chris_Sanders]

hes out in preseason..im sure he'll play when the regular season starts..and besides even if he is i have backups than can still score some points with Q and Evans..

You realize he just had his knee scoped on the 1st of August right? He is a 33 year old receiver with two knee surgeries in the off season. What's worse is that Crayton will likely take his starting spot when he is able to come back.

You can have him. I laugh at where he is being drafted.

 

[Skkorpion]

Thats a sick lineup....how many teams in your league?

Mines not as good. 12 teams in the league.

QB - Peyton Manning
WR - TJ Hous.
WR - Santana Moss
WR - Braylon Edwards
RB - Reggie Bush
RB - Ahman Green (big weakness)
TE - Chris Cooley
K - Robbie Gould
DEF - New England

Bench

QB - Chad Penn.
RB - Warrick Dunn
TE - Desmond Clark
WR - Jerricho Cotchery
DEF - Pitt and AZ (AZ was my pride pick)

1. Sorry, Dacard, Welker was the leading WR on his team last year and will thrive on his new team. You screwed up.

2. Your RBs are worse than horrible. Warrick Dunn has a bad back and can't be expected to last many games. Even if he does, Atlanta is the worst team in football and will hardly ever score.
Ahman Green? Isn't he with Houston? Enough said.

3. WR Santana Moss? The Skins QB situation is a mess.
Edwards? He plays for Cleveland. their QB situation is even worse.

4. Defense? Pitt really fell apart at the end of last year, if I recall, and under a new coach, may struggle. Arizona? You're braver than I am.

5. Really like all the rest.

Pariah is nutz. Brady outscore Manning?

 

[Chris_Sanders]

I wouldn't discount the Pittsburgh defense. Their schedule is filled with offensive cupcakes.

 

[Goober Man]

You realize he just had his knee scoped on the 1st of August right? He is a 33 year old receiver with two knee surgeries in the off season. What's worse is that Crayton will likely take his starting spot when he is able to come back.

You can have him. I laugh at where he is being drafted.

i did an autopick draft and i ended up getting him in the 8th round..i know hes getting up there in age but he still put up 1,000 yrds and 6 tds..if you think he'll be replaced then who should i pick up to replace him? some FA's worth mentioning in me league are Jerry Porter,Anthony Gonzalez,Marty Booker,Joe Horn and a few others..what one would you pick?

 

[Chris_Sanders]

i did an autopick draft and i ended up getting him in the 8th round..i know hes getting up there in age but he still put up 1,000 yrds and 6 tds..if you think he'll be replaced then who should i pick up to replace him? some FA's worth mentioning in me league are Jerry Porter,Anthony Gonzalez,Marty Booker,Joe Horn and a few others..what one would you pick?

I think with the grand theft you pulled on the Tony Romo trade you should now identify the Cowboy fan in your league and trade him Romo and Glenn for a lesser QB and an upgrade at WR.

Romo will likely be an impact fantasy QB, but he will just gather dust on your bench with Manning there. I can only assume you traded for him for future fantasy bait.

If there is no Dallas fan than I would pick up Crayton. He is almost certainly on your waiver wire and he gives you insurance should Glenn lose his spot. You have Tony G and just like Peyton he is going to play 16 out of 17 weeks barring injury.

 

[Chris_Sanders]

BTW Autopick drafts are the worst. I feel for you

 

[Goober Man]

BTW Autopick drafts are the worst. I feel for you

yeah sometimes they go bad..but also sometimes they go good if you set up your player rankings right..can you believe when i had my draft the pre set ranking of peyton was 12? after seeing that i automatically moved him up to #1