Mitch
Crawled Through 5 FB Fields
Much of what I am about to write is purely speculation---speculation spawned by inference---
None of us knows what really goes on inside the Cardinals' organization. In fact, sometimes it seems that even the Cardinals' beat reporters are completely in the dark as to what is going on within the organization, as they were with the Leinart situation.
That said...I am going to try to connect the dots as best I can.
The harrowing question I keep asking myself is, how could HC Ken Whisenhunt---seemingly the best and brightest HC the Cardinals have had since the days of Don Coryell---suddenly seem so obtuse and obstinate in his decision making?
My theory is that there is a rather closely-veiled but simmering power struggle going on between Whisenhunt and the front office---and it's been building for quite some time---perhaps even to the point where the ultra-frugal Bidwills might actually be considering eating KW's new contract in favor of bringing in a new head coach...
But---imagine the perceptions around the league if the Bidwills showed the temerity to fire the coach who brought the franchise out of the duldrums and just three years ago had the Cardinals within 2:37 of winning the Super Bowl.
It all goes back to the day Whiz was hired---under the condition that he agreed to keep DC Clancy Pendergast---and under the expectation that Whiz would groom Matt Leinart into a Pro Bowl QB.
Not only did KW insist on firing Pendergast two years later---in many respects the timing of the move---following the defensive meltdown in the Super Bowl---made Pendergast the scapegoat.
The Bidwills could not put a classy spin on those developments, despite their affinity for Pendergast and his family.
What hurts Whiz's part in all this is that his hiring of Bill Davis as DC has not been the answer to the team's continuing defensive meltdowns and woes. And Whiz is so loyal to his coaches---one wonders if he would ever relieve Davis of his duties.
On to Leinart...
We've all saw how the situation played out. Whiz holds three different press conferences in 5 years to announce Leinart as the clear starter---says Leinart is "the guy"---only whenever it becomes fish or cut bait time, Leinart finds himself demoted, or as was the case this year, he finds himself released on the last week of the pre-season.
The question is...who really scheduled those press conferences? Was it Whiz?...or really Rod Graves?...or Bill Bidwill? Michael Bidwill?
Then there was the one leak to the media this year that Whizenhunt and his coaches had pleaded to the FO to go and sign UFA QB Marc Bulger when Bulger became available after the draft.
Certainly the Bidwills---having trimmed a cool $30M from the team's total player salaries in 2009---had plenty of money to invest in other free agent acquisitions---yet---they apparently refused to sign Bulger---
Wow.
The Bidwills wanted what they had been hoping for the day they hired Whiz---they finally wanted Whiz to turn Matt Leinart into the QBOF.
Yet---when you look at Leinart's game---did Leinart ever seem like a match for Whiz's system?
Do you think Whiz ever thought Leinart was a match?
When Leinart threw a pass that was a tad late and high to Fitz in the first pre-season game (which was reminiscent of the pass in the last week of the season last year which resulted in Anquan Boldin's injury)---and Fitz limped off---Whiz had all the ammo he needed. If the star WR fears playing with the incumbent QB---the incumbent QB has to go. Plus...in general, apparently his teammates thought Leinart was "soft."
Cris Carter---spoke nationally of Fitz's concerns about Leinart---and while there was much debate over whether Carter had the inside dope on the situation or not---let's just say that Fitz, when given ample opportunity to diffuse the hearsay---did not speak in a voice that was loud enough for anyone to hear.
Whiz's plan would have been to have Marc Bulger be the starter---but instead Whiz was left with Derek Anderson (clearly a panic signing made by the urgings of recently hired DOPP [Director of Pro Personnel], T.J. McCreight---formerly of---yup you guessed it---the Cleveland Browns).
One simply cannot imagine Ken Whisenhunt wanting any part of Derek Anderson.
Thus Whiz was saddled with both Leinart and Anderson---
But Whiz was at least encouraged by the prospects of the two rookies that he had a hand in bringing in: John Skelton and Max Hall.
Hall, in fact, came into camp showing that he was already completely fluent with the playbook---something that Matt Leinart in his first year with Whiz struggled so much so with that Whiz appointed Kurt Warner as the hurry-up QB in order to lessen ML's role.
But--if you think about it---Whiz's handling of the QB situation this year and his stubbornness about keeping DA the starter and not wanting to rush the best young talent on the team in John Skelton---this combined with Whiz's consistently poor, unaggressive play calls---especially on 3rd downs and on electing to punt time and time again on 4ths and 1---Whiz was and has been sending a clear message to the FO---this has been Whiz's way of saying this is what happens when you handcuff the HC.
Bill Parcells---embroiled in a similar power struggle---left the Patriots saying, "If you want me to cook the meal, you think you ought to let me shop for the groceries."
This year's QB debacle is just another part of a series of FO mismanagements...
The embarrassing way in which the FO conducted the Kurt Warner negotiations---one could argue and even see that those negotiations took a lot out of Warner---they dispirited him quite significantly---perhaps more than people realize.
Warner's contract was for two years. He played it for one.
There was the situation with Anquan Boldin---the star WR who was supposedly promised a new contract by the FO---but in the process developed a disdain for Whisenhunt after Whiz meddled in the talks.
It would seem that of all the Cardinal players Whiz inherited, the two he did not want to piss off and alienate were Anquan Boldin and Adrian Wilson...both Pro Bowl caliber players who exemplified the toughness and comeptitiveness that had been so glaringly lacking from the past personnel in Arizona.
But---whatever was happening within the organization---the truth of the matter is, of all the Cardinals' top players who had the chance to leave Arizona in the past two years, only Adrian Wilson remains.
How can players from a team that came within a whisker of winning a Super Bowl be so quick to want to leave town?
Boldin tried to force his way out of town for three years---and the FO simply let Boldin's ire linger and linger.
Not good.
Then---say and think what you will about the way in which the FO handled the Dansby and Rolle situations---here were two guys who were adored by their teammates---heck, Dansby's best friend is Adrian Wilson---and yet why then wouldn't Dansby not want to re-sign with the Cardinals?
He never did want to re-sign with the Cardinals, did he?
Why?
The stigma...
It all comes down to the the stigma of perceptions that the Bidwills are cheap at the core---that the Bidwills do not know how to run a winning NFL franchise.
And for every happy Adrian Wilson and Darnell Dockett...there are the Calvin Paces, the Antonio Smiths, the Anquan Boldins, the Karlos Dansbys, the Antrel Rolles, the Edgerrin Jameses---
The players are the ones most aware of such perceptions...and players---who have plenty of time at their disposal---talk, text and tweet. What do you think the Cardinal defectors are saying about the organization?
Do we have to even speculate about that?
Sure we can argue that it's undeserved at this point---and should be a thing of the past---but, if this year is any further proof---we fans got screwed because our owners decided to trim $30M and, in doing so, left us vulnerable at several positions, especially at the most important of all: QB.
You would think that after three great years from Kurt Warner anyone working for the Cardinals would understand that.
The interesting thing now is---has Whiz made his point with the FO?
Will the FO give Whiz more say and take more of a back seat in terms of personnel? Especially in terms of the team's QBs?
Whiz's saving grace?
Aside from salvaging some sorely needed grains of respect through the encouraging play of QB John Skelton...
It's that Fitz says he loves playing for Whiz.
And if the Bidwills let Fitz get away---
The stigma may last forever.
None of us knows what really goes on inside the Cardinals' organization. In fact, sometimes it seems that even the Cardinals' beat reporters are completely in the dark as to what is going on within the organization, as they were with the Leinart situation.
That said...I am going to try to connect the dots as best I can.
The harrowing question I keep asking myself is, how could HC Ken Whisenhunt---seemingly the best and brightest HC the Cardinals have had since the days of Don Coryell---suddenly seem so obtuse and obstinate in his decision making?
My theory is that there is a rather closely-veiled but simmering power struggle going on between Whisenhunt and the front office---and it's been building for quite some time---perhaps even to the point where the ultra-frugal Bidwills might actually be considering eating KW's new contract in favor of bringing in a new head coach...
But---imagine the perceptions around the league if the Bidwills showed the temerity to fire the coach who brought the franchise out of the duldrums and just three years ago had the Cardinals within 2:37 of winning the Super Bowl.
It all goes back to the day Whiz was hired---under the condition that he agreed to keep DC Clancy Pendergast---and under the expectation that Whiz would groom Matt Leinart into a Pro Bowl QB.
Not only did KW insist on firing Pendergast two years later---in many respects the timing of the move---following the defensive meltdown in the Super Bowl---made Pendergast the scapegoat.
The Bidwills could not put a classy spin on those developments, despite their affinity for Pendergast and his family.
What hurts Whiz's part in all this is that his hiring of Bill Davis as DC has not been the answer to the team's continuing defensive meltdowns and woes. And Whiz is so loyal to his coaches---one wonders if he would ever relieve Davis of his duties.
On to Leinart...
We've all saw how the situation played out. Whiz holds three different press conferences in 5 years to announce Leinart as the clear starter---says Leinart is "the guy"---only whenever it becomes fish or cut bait time, Leinart finds himself demoted, or as was the case this year, he finds himself released on the last week of the pre-season.
The question is...who really scheduled those press conferences? Was it Whiz?...or really Rod Graves?...or Bill Bidwill? Michael Bidwill?
Then there was the one leak to the media this year that Whizenhunt and his coaches had pleaded to the FO to go and sign UFA QB Marc Bulger when Bulger became available after the draft.
Certainly the Bidwills---having trimmed a cool $30M from the team's total player salaries in 2009---had plenty of money to invest in other free agent acquisitions---yet---they apparently refused to sign Bulger---
Wow.
The Bidwills wanted what they had been hoping for the day they hired Whiz---they finally wanted Whiz to turn Matt Leinart into the QBOF.
Yet---when you look at Leinart's game---did Leinart ever seem like a match for Whiz's system?
Do you think Whiz ever thought Leinart was a match?
When Leinart threw a pass that was a tad late and high to Fitz in the first pre-season game (which was reminiscent of the pass in the last week of the season last year which resulted in Anquan Boldin's injury)---and Fitz limped off---Whiz had all the ammo he needed. If the star WR fears playing with the incumbent QB---the incumbent QB has to go. Plus...in general, apparently his teammates thought Leinart was "soft."
Cris Carter---spoke nationally of Fitz's concerns about Leinart---and while there was much debate over whether Carter had the inside dope on the situation or not---let's just say that Fitz, when given ample opportunity to diffuse the hearsay---did not speak in a voice that was loud enough for anyone to hear.
Whiz's plan would have been to have Marc Bulger be the starter---but instead Whiz was left with Derek Anderson (clearly a panic signing made by the urgings of recently hired DOPP [Director of Pro Personnel], T.J. McCreight---formerly of---yup you guessed it---the Cleveland Browns).
One simply cannot imagine Ken Whisenhunt wanting any part of Derek Anderson.
Thus Whiz was saddled with both Leinart and Anderson---
But Whiz was at least encouraged by the prospects of the two rookies that he had a hand in bringing in: John Skelton and Max Hall.
Hall, in fact, came into camp showing that he was already completely fluent with the playbook---something that Matt Leinart in his first year with Whiz struggled so much so with that Whiz appointed Kurt Warner as the hurry-up QB in order to lessen ML's role.
But--if you think about it---Whiz's handling of the QB situation this year and his stubbornness about keeping DA the starter and not wanting to rush the best young talent on the team in John Skelton---this combined with Whiz's consistently poor, unaggressive play calls---especially on 3rd downs and on electing to punt time and time again on 4ths and 1---Whiz was and has been sending a clear message to the FO---this has been Whiz's way of saying this is what happens when you handcuff the HC.
Bill Parcells---embroiled in a similar power struggle---left the Patriots saying, "If you want me to cook the meal, you think you ought to let me shop for the groceries."
This year's QB debacle is just another part of a series of FO mismanagements...
The embarrassing way in which the FO conducted the Kurt Warner negotiations---one could argue and even see that those negotiations took a lot out of Warner---they dispirited him quite significantly---perhaps more than people realize.
Warner's contract was for two years. He played it for one.
There was the situation with Anquan Boldin---the star WR who was supposedly promised a new contract by the FO---but in the process developed a disdain for Whisenhunt after Whiz meddled in the talks.
It would seem that of all the Cardinal players Whiz inherited, the two he did not want to piss off and alienate were Anquan Boldin and Adrian Wilson...both Pro Bowl caliber players who exemplified the toughness and comeptitiveness that had been so glaringly lacking from the past personnel in Arizona.
But---whatever was happening within the organization---the truth of the matter is, of all the Cardinals' top players who had the chance to leave Arizona in the past two years, only Adrian Wilson remains.
How can players from a team that came within a whisker of winning a Super Bowl be so quick to want to leave town?
Boldin tried to force his way out of town for three years---and the FO simply let Boldin's ire linger and linger.
Not good.
Then---say and think what you will about the way in which the FO handled the Dansby and Rolle situations---here were two guys who were adored by their teammates---heck, Dansby's best friend is Adrian Wilson---and yet why then wouldn't Dansby not want to re-sign with the Cardinals?
He never did want to re-sign with the Cardinals, did he?
Why?
The stigma...
It all comes down to the the stigma of perceptions that the Bidwills are cheap at the core---that the Bidwills do not know how to run a winning NFL franchise.
And for every happy Adrian Wilson and Darnell Dockett...there are the Calvin Paces, the Antonio Smiths, the Anquan Boldins, the Karlos Dansbys, the Antrel Rolles, the Edgerrin Jameses---
The players are the ones most aware of such perceptions...and players---who have plenty of time at their disposal---talk, text and tweet. What do you think the Cardinal defectors are saying about the organization?
Do we have to even speculate about that?
Sure we can argue that it's undeserved at this point---and should be a thing of the past---but, if this year is any further proof---we fans got screwed because our owners decided to trim $30M and, in doing so, left us vulnerable at several positions, especially at the most important of all: QB.
You would think that after three great years from Kurt Warner anyone working for the Cardinals would understand that.
The interesting thing now is---has Whiz made his point with the FO?
Will the FO give Whiz more say and take more of a back seat in terms of personnel? Especially in terms of the team's QBs?
Whiz's saving grace?
Aside from salvaging some sorely needed grains of respect through the encouraging play of QB John Skelton...
It's that Fitz says he loves playing for Whiz.
And if the Bidwills let Fitz get away---
The stigma may last forever.
Last edited: