Future of Hollywood Brown as a Cardinal

[BritCard]

Hilarious. Yes, if you ignore the fact that he missed nearly a quarter of a season he was very good!

Yes, he was good. Glad we agree.

I'm pretty sure there's a middle ground between playing almost zero snaps per game (the first 10 weeks of the season) and the 80% he played in the last seven weeks due to injury. I don't think most people want or need to see Greg Dortch play 80% of downs on a good team.

Dorth is never going to play 80% of snaps. We don't use a 3rd WR that much. Rondale only played 67% and that was with all the times he lined up at RB or some other gadget position. Dortch would play 60% max.

Tanking teams make strange roster decisions. Shocking.

What has Nico Collins being frequently injured got to do with "roster decisions"?

 

[BritCard]

Brit, you are all over the board with your takes. Dortch at #3 is a starter but Wilson at #3 is getting benched? Make up your mind.

Which poster is calling for Dortch to be a starting WR for the Cards this season? Name them, please. People want him on the roster and want him to contribute, not start. I sure in hell don't.

MHJ, legit #2, Wilson, Dortch, yes, that would be acceptable. I'd prefer more proven depth, but that would suffice.

This isn't the difficult. Wilson getting moved from a full time #2 role where he plays 90%+ of snaps to a part time slot role where he plays 50-60% is the equivalent of getting benched.

And there are no "legit #2" available. Unless you want to name who you have in mind?

Dorth played 45% of snaps in 2022 and 40% last year. Playing ore on this team is starting in the slot where he might play 60%.

You still haven't answered the original question. Would you be fine with MHJ, Wilson, and Dortch as our 1-3?

Am I fine with MHJ as #1? Yes

Am I fine with Wilson at #2? Yes

Am I fine with Dortch at #3? Not so much, but then I expect we will draft a 2nd WR that will play a role here.

 

[kerouac9]

Dorth is never going to play 80% of snaps. We don't use a 3rd WR that much. Rondale only played 67% and that was with all the times he lined up at RB or some other gadget position. Dortch would play 60% max.

It's so easy to check facts before posting.

You must be registered for see images attach

 

[Cardiac]

I do know that I want this thread to die, it keeps reminding me of how wrong I was with my vote.

 

[cardncubfan]

It's so easy to check facts before posting.

You must be registered for see images attach

What would the average be? 45%? I assume he means for the season.

 

[Mulli]

It's so easy to check facts before posting.

You must be registered for see images attach

Did he mean Dortch will never play 80% again?

 

[BritCard]

It's so easy to check facts before posting.

You must be registered for see images attach

You know what else you should have checked? That for the 1st 4 of those Wilson was out and Dortch took his role, and for the last 3 Hollywood was out and Dortch took his role.

Try harder.

 

[BritCard]

Did he mean Dortch will never play 80% again?

No, I just don't count games where Wilson or Hollywood was out that gave Dortch a much larger role as #2.

 

[kerouac9]

You know what else you should have checked? That for the 1st 4 of those Wilson was out and Dortch took his role, and for the last 3 Hollywood was out and Dortch took his role.

Try harder.

So you're assuring me that neither Wilson nor anyone else will hurt and so Dortch will have to play more snaps?

Sure.

 

[BritCard]

So you're assuring me that neither Wilson nor anyone else will hurt and so Dortch will have to play more snaps?

Sure.

I'm not sure what so confusing for you about "Dortch will only play about 60% of snaps in the slot".

In his increased role last year he had to fill in outside so played much more. That's very unlikely to happen this year.

 

[kerouac9]

I'm not sure what so confusing for you about "Dortch will only play about 60% of snaps in the slot".

In his increased role last year he had to fill in outside so played much more. That's very unlikely to happen this year.

Oh okay.

 

[Stout]

This isn't the difficult. Wilson getting moved from a full time #2 role where he plays 90%+ of snaps to a part time slot role where he plays 50-60% is the equivalent of getting benched.

And there are no "legit #2" available. Unless you want to name who you have in mind?

Dorth played 45% of snaps in 2022 and 40% last year. Playing ore on this team is starting in the slot where he might play 60%.



Am I fine with MHJ as #1? Yes

Am I fine with Wilson at #2? Yes

Am I fine with Dortch at #3? Not so much, but then I expect we will draft a 2nd WR that will play a role here.

At least you answered the original question. I appreciate the clarification.

You consider Wilson #3 a non-starter and Dortch at #3 a starter. Hypocrisy. Can't have it both ways.

Also, very curious to see you name just who was asking for MHJ, Wilson, and Dortch as our 1-3 WRs. Who were these posters? I'll wait, because that's what you led off with and it's as ridiculous a take now as it was then.

 

[BritCard]

At least you answered the original question. I appreciate the clarification.

You consider Wilson #3 a non-starter and Dortch at #3 a starter. Hypocrisy. Can't have it both ways.

Also, very curious to see you name just who was asking for MHJ, Wilson, and Dortch as our 1-3 WRs. Who were these posters? I'll wait, because that's what you led off with and it's as ridiculous a take now as it was then.

Well obviously everyone has been asking for MHJ at 4 which is default WR1.

Lots of people have been asking for Dortch to play much more for years. As he was WR4 the only more is WR3.

 

[BritCard]

Brown confirms he took less money to go to the Chiefs.

xc_hide_links_from_guests_guests_error_hide_media

 

[unseenaz]

Brown confirms he took less money to go to the Chiefs.

xc_hide_links_from_guests_guests_error_hide_media

I mean, that makes sense to me. Go play with the best QB in the league and have a chance to win a superbowl (or 3, whatever)

 

[iLLmatiC]

I haven't done enough research on this but has it been confirmed he just wanted to go to the Chiefs or are we assuming the Cardinals made no offer?

 

[Ronin]

xc_hide_links_from_guests_guests_error_hide_media

 

[Stout]

Well obviously everyone has been asking for MHJ at 4 which is default WR1.

Lots of people have been asking for Dortch to play much more for years. As he was WR4 the only more is WR3.

So no one. Got it.

 

[Stout]

Brown confirms he took less money to go to the Chiefs.

xc_hide_links_from_guests_guests_error_hide_media

Good. Bye!

 

[Mulli]

Good. Bye!

He got hurt when the door hit him on his way out!

 

[BritCard]

I mean, that makes sense to me. Go play with the best QB in the league and have a chance to win a superbowl (or 3, whatever)

And play in a vibrant passing offense that gives you a chance to ball out and get paid next year. Which would not happen in AZ.

 

[Redsz]

Happy for him. Not sad to see him go. Did not live up to potential.

 

[Cardiac]

How do I kill this thread.

 

[Cardiac]

Stop posting in it for one thing