Help me - Need 10 best Cardinals of all time

[LDL]

OJ Anderson is right there, though it's tough to differentiate all the great players (that guy is # 11, and not top ten??). My take would be to list ALL the POSSIBLE TOP TEN, and then have the fans vote.

YES!!! A poll.

 

[sundevil04]

Tim Rosenbach
Chris Chandler
Kent Graham
Max Hall
John Skelton
Dave Brown
Stoney Case
Gary Hogeboom
Jeff Blake
Tom Tupa

 

[cardpa]

Tim Rosenbach
Chris Chandler
Kent Graham
Max Hall
John Skelton
Dave Brown
Stoney Case
Gary Hogeboom
Jeff Blake
Tom Tupa

All hall of fame candidates for sure!

 

[Totally_Red]

Tim Rosenbach
Chris Chandler
Kent Graham
Max Hall
John Skelton
Dave Brown
Stoney Case
Gary Hogeboom
Jeff Blake
Tom Tupa

Jeopardy question: What are the ten worst quarterbacks to play for the Arizona Cardinals?


Roger Wehrli has to included in the list of the top 10. The guy is a HOFer.

 

[BigRedRage]

Tim Rosenbach
Chris Chandler
Kent Graham
Max Hall
John Skelton
Dave Brown
Stoney Case
Gary Hogeboom
Jeff Blake
Tom Tupa

kevin kasper

 

[Lifer]

From that same great o-line with Dierdorf you've got Tom Banks and Conrad Dobler. Banks was a multiple ProBowler and I think he was All Pro at least once.

 

[Jetstream Green]

Fitz
Kurt Warner
Roger Werhli
Charlie Trippi
Dick Lane
Q
Aneas Williams
Larry Wilson
Dan Dierdorf
Ollie Matson
Jackie Smith

That's 11 but I couldn't find one I'd leave off

Suck it up, you have to leave off Fitz or Boldin... in other words Q has to go. I'm a huge fan of Roy Green but for the top ten Fitz takes him lol

 

[Jetstream Green]

In No particular order
1. Larry Fitzgerald
2. OJ Anderson
3. Jackie Smith
4. Roger Werhli
5. Larry Wilson
6. Charlie Trippi
7. Dan Dierdorf
8. Anneas Williams
9. Ollie Matson
10. Adrian Wilson

Sorry, we love A-dub but as a player on the field he has to go for someone like Warner... Warner took us to the Super Bowl

 

[Jetstream Green]

From that same great o-line with Dierdorf you've got Tom Banks and Conrad Dobler. Banks was a multiple ProBowler and I think he was All Pro at least once.

Banks was good but does not sniff the list as a top ten entry... come on really lol

 

[Buckybird]

Sorry, we love A-dub but as a player on the field he has to go for someone like Warner... Warner took us to the Super Bowl

Yep! If Warner ain't on that list, there's not a list IMO. He raised the bar from black eyed peas to poker chips! What he did in 2 1/2 yrs in Arizona was almost god like...without him we would be same ol same ol

Banks was good but does not sniff the list as a top ten entry... come on really lol

Yessir my man. Wolfman was like comparing hall of fame to hall of good!!! And yes, Banks was the Wolfman if I ever saw one

 

[RugbyMuffin]

Sorry, we love A-dub but as a player on the field he has to go for someone like Warner... Warner took us to the Super Bowl

Could have swore Adrian Wilson was on that team, and 51 other players besides Warner and himself.

 

[BW52]

Roger Werhli CB
Larry Wilson S
Ollie Matson RB
Dan Dierdorf G-T
Jackie Smith TE
Charlie Trippi RB-DB
Roy Green WR-DB

Jim Hart QB

Aeneas Williams CB
Larry Fitzgerald WR

 

[Russ Smith]

Gotta have mel Gray and Terry Metcalf in there.

In todays NFL the numbers they'd have put up my goodness.

 

[Russ Smith]

I'd also say Lomax deserves consideration but everyone hates that era because the team fell apart over drugs(not Lomax).

Hell EJ Junior too but he was involved with drugs so people tend to leave him off.

 

[Southpaw]

From that same great o-line with Dierdorf you've got Tom Banks and Conrad Dobler. Banks was a multiple ProBowler and I think he was All Pro at least once.

and Bob Young.

 

[Duckjake]

Speaking of linemen: Ken Gray OG from San Saba Texas played 12 years for the Cardinals.

6 pro bowls and 2 times 1st team All-Pro. Of course there were only 14 teams then.

 

[Cardsfanstl]

Sorry, we love A-dub but as a player on the field he has to go for someone like Warner... Warner took us to the Super Bowl

I thought about Warner but I went for longevity with the team. All the players I have on my list were with the team longer than Warner was. Not sure about Matson's years on the team but he is a HOF.

 

[Jetstream Green]

I thought about Warner but I went for longevity with the team. All the players I have on my list were with the team longer than Warner was. Not sure about Matson's years on the team but he is a HOF.

Warner played for five years with the Cardinals and took the team to it's only Super Bowl in the modern era. For me I think it is impossible to leave him off, Gayle Sayers only played seven years (the last years marred with injury) for the Bears but it would be hard to leave him off their list. In comparison, it would be easier to leave Sayers off the Bear's list than Warner because the goal of a player is to win and even though it was not Sayer's fault... those Bear teams did not win much and Warner holds stats in the post season which where impressive as a Cardinal. I guess excellence can be viewed in terms of quality and longevity but again for me Warner's grade of quality is too high

 

[Duckjake]

Warner played for five years with the Cardinals and took the team to it's only Super Bowl in the modern era. For me I think it is impossible to leave him off, Gayle Sayers only played seven years (the last years marred with injury) for the Bears but it would be hard to leave him off their list. In comparison, it would be easier to leave Sayers off the Bear's list than Warner because the goal of a player is to win and even though it was not Sayer's fault... those Bear teams did not win much and Warner holds stats in the post season which where impressive as a Cardinal. I guess excellence can be viewed in terms of quality and longevity but again for me Warner's grade of quality is too high

Hey Charley Johnson is the only one of the top STL/ARZ Cardinal QBs: CJ, Hart, Lomax, Plummer, and Warner, with a winning record as the Cardinals starting QB.

Now how Charley ended up in the Bronco's Ring of Fame I have no idea.

 

[Jetstream Green]

Hey Charley Johnson is the only one of the top STL/ARZ Cardinal QBs: CJ, Hart, Lomax, Plummer, and Warner, with a winning record as the Cardinals starting QB.

Now how Charley ended up in the Bronco's Ring of Fame I have no idea.

Those guys in Denver have been smoking excessive pot long before it was legalized lol

 

[themilkman1]

Im looking at these lists and even though Jet Stream is my favorite Cardinal, Terry Metcalf is without a doubt the most exciting Cardinal ever