I would think that coordinators would love to work for Adrian Wilson because he would give them the autonomy they crave. Wilson's chief role as the HC would be to create the proper culture through motivation, accountability and hard work. Some of the best HCs are master delegators. One thing that impressed me a great deal about Sean McVay this year is that he asked STC John Fassel to advise him on in-game decisions. McVay would make the final call, but McVay always wanted to hear Fassel's take first.
You're 100% correct. Many of the best coaches never played in the NFL. But so much of today's game in the NFL today is predicated on motivating the players. I think the Cardinals have a motivation problem. It seemed like every other game, the players from the week before didn't show up. Adrian Wilson showed up every game he played, even with one arm hanging by a thread. This kind of motivation has to start somewhere and AW could bring it, imo, as well as anyone.
I have always thought that there were two recent Cardinals I would love to see as HC one day: Adrian Wilson and Kurt Warner. Two of the most competitive and dedicated players ever to don Cardinal red.
Those who can: DO..... Those who can't: Teach
which former "Great" player has made a good coach in the NFL?
Lots of former, "mediocre" players have made good coaches,... lots of "Backup" QB's and such
Joe Green, not so good... Mike Singletary... Failure
Harbaugh might be the "Best" player to be a good HC... and he wasnt that great as a player..averaged 12TD's and 11INT's per season
John Madden??
Gary Kubiak was a decent coach...and a backup level QB...
Dungy was a good coach... mediocre player
Del Rio was a good player...and so far a mediocre coach... I think better than he gets credit for,.. but the stats are what they are.
I'm an AW fan as much as anyone else... but we need more than Rah-Rah at HC and I cant see any reason to think AW brings anything more than that...
hell,...he is a scout now... which players has he scouted that took off...who were not already nationally known? Has he picked out some mystery 6th round pick nobody else ever heard of that became a pro bowler?
Hiring him as a HC would be putting him in position to fail... a position in which he cannot contribute to the team winning and his attempts to do so would likely cause more harm than good...
even the fact that he broke into the NFL ranks as a scout tells you he aint a coach... scouts move up to office positions... not coaching...
if he wanted to coach,...we could have had him in as a DB coach.... but he ended up a scout