Is Calais Campbell Worth of Cardinals Ring of Honor?

[NJCardFan]

There are players from the St. Louis days who deserve to be there ahead of CC. Neil Lomax, Jim Hart, Conrad Dobler(yes, I said Conrad Dobler), Jim Otis, Mel Gray, Otis Anderson, even Larry Centers belongs on the ROH. A ROH is supposed to be for what players did for your team, not just in the league overall. This is why the HOF criteria doesn't make any sense.

 

[Buckybird]

There are players from the St. Louis days who deserve to be there ahead of CC. Neil Lomax, Jim Hart, Conrad Dobler(yes, I said Conrad Dobler), Jim Otis, Mel Gray, Otis Anderson, even Larry Centers belongs on the ROH. A ROH is supposed to be for what players did for your team, not just in the league overall. This is why the HOF criteria doesn't make any sense.

Hart & OJ should be no doubt lol

 

[JeffGollin]

Hart is lol

Does Dierdorf deserve to be in the same group as Dobler, Hart etc.?

 

[Bodha]

There are players from the St. Louis days who deserve to be there ahead of CC. Neil Lomax, Jim Hart, Conrad Dobler(yes, I said Conrad Dobler), Jim Otis, Mel Gray, Otis Anderson, even Larry Centers belongs on the ROH. A ROH is supposed to be for what players did for your team, not just in the league overall. This is why the HOF criteria doesn't make any sense.

If thats the case then Kurt Warner wouldnt be in our ROH

3 good seasons and a superbowl loss? Sounds like Colin Kaepernick.

 

[AZ Native]

If thats the case then Kurt Warner wouldnt be in our ROH

3 good seasons and a superbowl loss? Sounds like Colin Kaepernick.

We wouldn't have been there with out Warner. Can't say the same about the other guy.

 

[NJCardFan]

If thats the case then Kurt Warner wouldnt be in our ROH

3 good seasons and a superbowl loss? Sounds like Colin Kaepernick.

There is so much stupid in this comment that it boggles the mind.

 

[Bodha]

There is so much stupid in this comment that it boggles the mind.

Just because you dont like it because it buries you doesnt mean it not factual.

Kurt and Kaepernick both had 3 good years with their teams, both went to 1 super bowl, and lost.

Kurt is in our ROH because hes beloved. But your assertion that "What a player does only for your team matters, not whole career" is murdered by this example of Kurt. 3 years of service and no rings does not deserve the ROH. Kurt is in our ROH because his entire career legacy was also taken into consideration.