Is Simeon An Option?

George O'Brien

ASFN Icon
Joined
Nov 22, 2003
Posts
10,297
Reaction score
0
Location
Sun City
If Ike's reach is as great as is being said, he seems likely to be off the board by the time the Suns pick. Taft and Villanueva are viewed as head cases and May is not in very good condition. One guy who might be available is Simien .

The knock on Simien is that he isn't very tall, doesn't have Ike's reach, and he's considered injury prone. The injury reputation might make him drop lower than he would otherwise go, but adds to the risk. On the plus side, the Suns trainers may be the best in the NBA. McDyess credits them with saving his career (why the Suns bothered is a completely different subject). If the Suns think they can cut down on Simien's injuries, he's actually a pretty attractive prospect at the 21 slot.

Wayne Simien - 6-9 255, PF, Senior, School: Kansas, Hometown: Kansas
Stats: 20.3 ppg, 11.0 rpg, 1.4 apg, 0.6 spg, 0.6 bpg, 55.2% FG, 81.6% FT, 28.6% 3FG in 34.3 mpg

Here is nbadraft.net:

Wayne Simien
Birthdate: 3/9/83
NBA Position: Power Forward
College: Kansas
Class: Senior
Ht: 6-8
Wt: 255
Hometown: Leavenworth, KN
High School: Leavenworth
Team Site Profile 2004 Stats

Strengths: He is an absolute beast on the block. He has an NBA body already and is very strong. Finishes with ferocity rarely seen at the college level. Loves to dunk and does so like he has a personnel vendetta against the rim. He is a dominating rebounder because of his leaping ability, strength and willingness to jockey for position as opposed to just trying to jump over people. He has a surprisingly soft touch around the bucket when he is not ripping the rim off of the backboard. He also has the ability to knock down the mid range jumper just like former KU big men Nick Collison and Raef Lafrentz. He runs well especially considering his bulk and can handle the ball fairly well for his size.

Weaknesses: Durability is a major concern for him. In each of the last three seasons he has suffered an injury that has kept him off the court for varied stretches of time. He must have basically an injury free junior campaign if he wants to be a lottery pick, and even if that happens don’t be surprised to see him stay for his senior year. He is not a shot blocker, which is odd because of how aggressive he is in all other facets of the game. He must prove that he can be a go to guy for crunch time buckets, he has had the luxury of playing alongside Drew Gooden and Nick Collison during his first seasons at KU so opposing defenses have never really been keyed just to stop him. In order to develop into a dominant PF at the next level he will need to hone his game in the post by adding a wider array of offensive moves, right now at the college level he is so much stronger then everyone he faces he can just overpower them down low but that trend will not continue on a nightly basis playing against the Karl Malone’s of the world. Maybe a little undersized.
-------------------------------------------------------------
draft city

Wayne Simien is one of the most successful players in recent college history, playing in two final fours with one more chance to win a national title yet to come. He is one of the top post scorers in the country, period. Seemingly relishing contact on the blocks, he can score with a variety of fundamental spin moves, hooks, fadeaways, and bank shots. He is willing to take bigger players in the mid/high post, while abusing the traditional PF on the low blocks. There aren’t many college defenders that can slow Simien down. He has a very nice “traditional PF” frame, standing around 6’8 and weighing a chiseled 260 pounds. Most players simply aren’t strong enough to keep him from doing what he wants on the blocks. Simien is a standout rebounder and a physical post defender as well. Simien’s feel for how to score down low is what sets him apart from the pack. He is a very savvy, cerebral player, and understands how to get the ball in the air before help defenders can react. He has absolutely outstanding touch on the ball, and his post moves almost never do anything but swish. His midrange jumper is improving, and Simien has even started hitting an occasional three pointer. He is also an exceptional free throw shooter, and destroys teams by getting to the line multiple times in short amounts of time.

Weaknesses:

While Simien is clearly one of the top college basketball players in the nation, it remains to be seen whether his game translates into the NBA. While he doesn’t have any trouble scoring in college, he is a bit undersized to play PF in the league, and it’s been well documented how unpopular undersized 4’s are on draft night. Despite being quite fluid and running the floor well for a big man, his game is always going to be rooted in the post. He is an adequate athlete for a post banger, but doesn't have the burst, lateral quickness, or ballhandling ability to play out on the perimeter. This limits his upside. For every Elton Brand, there is a John Wallace, Marcus Fizer, or Corliss Williamson. To separate himself from this group, Simien is going to have to prove that he can defend NBA big men. He has the strength and nature to bang with anybody, but he may not have the length. He is not a shotblocker, even on the college level. The other weakness to talk about is his tendency to get injured, which has plagued him most of his career. Simien has had recurring shoulder problems, and missed time due to injury as recently as January. Other than these two issues, there is little not to like about Simien. However, these aren’t minor gripes. It’s not good to see a player who will be forced to rely on brute strength and physicality come up lame so often.
--------------------------------------------------------------------
College Hoops

NBA Draft Profile: Wayne Simien

College: Kansas
Class: Senior
Stats: ESPN Statistics
Height: 6-9
Weight: 255 lbs.
Accolades: 2003-04: 1st Team All Big-12; 3rd Team All-American

Scouting Report:

Bruising big man with an array of finesse moves around the basket… really knows how to use his body… very smart player who is fundamentally sound… exudes leadership… injury prone throughout college career… plays under the rim

Strengths: Bulk, touch, leadership

Weaknesses: Athleticism, sometimes struggles in big games

Projected Draft Range: Late First Round

Siegel's Take - Top 30 Scouting Reports

“Similar to fellow Big 12 forward Joey Graham, Simien’s greatest asset in college has always been his mature, physically developed body. The questions about Simien are the same you ask about most college to NBA forwards: when you take away the pure physical advantage, what can he really do that great? So much of Simien’s success at Kansas was about overpowering guys down low, so he’ll need to refine his post moves, and work on moving without the ball. It would also be nice if he could be an inch or two taller or be a better shot blocker. And of course, you have all the questions about his injury-prone past. Even if Simien manages to stay healthy for the rest of his career, he will never be a consistent starter in the NBA.”
-----------------------------------------------------------
If healthy, he appears to be a solid prospect to back up Marion at PF. None of the negitives appear to be fatal but may lead teams to pass on him for taller, more athletic guys.
 
Last edited:

cly2tw

Registered User
Joined
Oct 26, 2002
Posts
5,832
Reaction score
0
He sounds good to me. Can he be a taller Ron Artest?
 

PhxGametime

Formerly Bball_31
Joined
Jul 27, 2002
Posts
2,010
Reaction score
0
Location
Phoenix
Wayne Simien is a pretty decent Prospect, I don't have him rated that high because of his shoulder problems and that report on how Prospects fare without the big weight advantage, is pretty good question...

His numbers are pretty good, outside of BLKs and could be the bruiser a lot of fans are looking for. I'm not sure he'll be rated very high on my board but he can score and rebound, at a clip Ike Diogu can.
 

PhxGametime

Formerly Bball_31
Joined
Jul 27, 2002
Posts
2,010
Reaction score
0
Location
Phoenix
I have him rated #5 PF right behind Ike Diogu but Ike will probably jump Sean May and I have Channing Frye at C, along with Tiago Splitter, etc.
 
Joined
Mar 3, 2005
Posts
463
Reaction score
0
Joe Johnson was labled injury prone by many scouts because he was injured for much of his sophomore year. I don't know If Simien's shoulder problem is something that lends itself to reinjury or not. But sometimes NBA training and medical facilities make all the difference, as George was saying.

I wish I knew more about his injury (injuries?) in particular. Is it the same shoulder going bad? Or has he just had a string of bad luck?
 

haverford

Registered
Joined
Oct 28, 2003
Posts
447
Reaction score
1
Location
phoenix
George O'Brien said:
While he doesn’t have any trouble scoring in college, he is a bit undersized to play PF in the league, and it’s been well documented how unpopular undersized 4’s are on draft night.

LOL. In what universe is 6' 9" 255 lbs. "a bit undersized"? What kind of standard is at work here? Ninety percent of these pre-draft scouting reports consists of these distortions resulting from some fantasy of what is ideal.

George, I realize those are not your words I'm quoting, but the scouting report's.
 
Last edited:

Mainstreet

Cruisin' Mainstreet
Supporting Member
Joined
Oct 19, 2003
Posts
119,244
Reaction score
59,842
I think what is lost in many of these scouting reports is how well can a player play a position in the NBA. Scouting reports too frequently gets caught up in "idea" stats and measurements. I think Elton Brand is probably only about 6'8, and he is an awesome PF. Carlos Boozer is probably not even not that tall and he plays the PF position well. I guess Charles Barkley in this day and age wouldn't even be drafted as a PF.

In retrospect, (as an example) I think many teams and fans were intrigued by Carlos Boozer's workouts and game but passed on him because he was not tall enough.

I think scouting needs to start looking less at potential and how a player plays on the court. I have never seen Simeon play but if he is the best BPA, I would not shy away from him. The same can be said with Ike but he may be gone when the Suns draft. If there is a quality big of similar ability, of course go with size. The Suns should draft a player who will actually get some playing time and has the consumate desire to improve.

Can the Suns trade their first born or something for some more draft picks? :)

I really think they could fill most of their holes in this draft as it appears deep.
 
Last edited:
OP
OP
George O'Brien

George O'Brien

ASFN Icon
Joined
Nov 22, 2003
Posts
10,297
Reaction score
0
Location
Sun City
haverford said:
LOL. In what universe is 6' 9" 255 lbs. "a bit undersized"? What kind of standard is at work here? Ninety percent of these pre-draft scouting reports consists of these distortions resulting from some fantasy of what is ideal.

Everyone wants a 7 foot guy who is quick, has a good touch, and strong enough to keep opponents out of the paint. What teams end up doing is taking tall, quick guys and hope they get them to be stronger through weight training. It is not as easy as it sounds.

The rap on most of the shorter guys is that they simply overpower people in college, but can't do that on a regular basis in the NBA. Except, that this isn't always true. Some of the more effective PF's this season are in the 6'8" range. I'm not talking about just Brand:

Brand 6'8" 272 averaged 9.5 rpg

Boozer 6'8" 258 averaged 9 rpg

Udonis Haslem 6-8 220 averaged 9.1 rpg this season and 10 rpg in the playoffs

Kenny Thomas 6'7" 245 averaged 8.7 rpg in Sacramento

Reggie Evens 6'8" 245 averaged 9.3 rpg in just 23.8 minutes a game

Andres Nocioni 6'7" 225 averaged 8.2 rpg in the first round of the playoffs

Most teams prefer to have taller guys, but strength and toughness count for more than people give credit to.
 

F-Dog

lurker
Joined
Aug 27, 2003
Posts
3,637
Reaction score
0
Location
Tucson
If they're committed to the D'Antoni system, the Suns won't draft a PF who can't shoot three-pointers.

My guess is that Simeon is one of those PFs (like Chris Taft or Sean May) whom the Suns won't seriously consider.
 

hcsilla

ASFN Lifer
Joined
Sep 22, 2002
Posts
3,391
Reaction score
218
Location
Budapest,Hungary
Simien is almost as good as underrated.

I doubt that he will be available at #21.

He is a true, classical PF ala Karl Malone.
 
OP
OP
George O'Brien

George O'Brien

ASFN Icon
Joined
Nov 22, 2003
Posts
10,297
Reaction score
0
Location
Sun City
F-Dog said:
If they're committed to the D'Antoni system, the Suns won't draft a PF who can't shoot three-pointers.

My guess is that Simeon is one of those PFs (like Chris Taft or Sean May) whom the Suns won't seriously consider.

I'm not so sure. I suspect that there may be more to this "point center" thing than just a slogan to keep Amare in the middle. Amare creates tough matchups against everyone he plays and I would not be shocked if he adds a three point shot to his repertoir. If that is case, the Suns may want a guy hanging around the basket more than Marion.

There is no reason why a second low post player should be a problem - IF he knows enough to get out of the way and block out for the offensive rebound. Considering that Amare draws double teams every time he goes to the basket, he could add interior passing to his game and load up on assists by passing to the weak side.
 

fordronken

Registered User
Joined
Oct 17, 2002
Posts
3,806
Reaction score
0
Location
Los Angeles area
George O'Brien said:
I'm not so sure. I suspect that there may be more to this "point center" thing than just a slogan to keep Amare in the middle. Amare creates tough matchups against everyone he plays and I would not be shocked if he adds a three point shot to his repertoir. If that is case, the Suns may want a guy hanging around the basket more than Marion.

There is no reason why a second low post player should be a problem - IF he knows enough to get out of the way and block out for the offensive rebound. Considering that Amare draws double teams every time he goes to the basket, he could add interior passing to his game and load up on assists by passing to the weak side.

Getting giddy...
 

F-Dog

lurker
Joined
Aug 27, 2003
Posts
3,637
Reaction score
0
Location
Tucson
George O'Brien said:
I'm not so sure. I suspect that there may be more to this "point center" thing than just a slogan to keep Amare in the middle. Amare creates tough matchups against everyone he plays and I would not be shocked if he adds a three point shot to his repertoir. If that is case, the Suns may want a guy hanging around the basket more than Marion.

There is no reason why a second low post player should be a problem - IF he knows enough to get out of the way and block out for the offensive rebound. Considering that Amare draws double teams every time he goes to the basket, he could add interior passing to his game and load up on assists by passing to the weak side.

I agree that Amare will be spending a little time next season spotting up on the 3-pt line, but it's a complete waste for him to do that so a rookie PF with no perimeter game can clog the lane, giving the other team's center somebody to guard. Either the lane should be completely empty (Princeton-style) with the other team's center unable to defend the basket, or the Suns should be playing a true center who can anchor their defense.

Simeon can't play on the perimeter and he can't play center, so I don't think he can help the Suns.
 
OP
OP
George O'Brien

George O'Brien

ASFN Icon
Joined
Nov 22, 2003
Posts
10,297
Reaction score
0
Location
Sun City
F-Dog said:
I agree that Amare will be spending a little time next season spotting up on the 3-pt line, but it's a complete waste for him to do that so a rookie PF with no perimeter game can clog the lane, giving the other team's center somebody to guard. Either the lane should be completely empty (Princeton-style) with the other team's center unable to defend the basket, or the Suns should be playing a true center who can anchor their defense.

Simeon can't play on the perimeter and he can't play center, so I don't think he can help the Suns.

First, I think the Suns need a backup who can score in the low post. Even if this is only for 10 to 12 minutes a game, it would keep the pressure on opponents who can ignore the post when Amare is out.

Second, the big advantage to Simien and Ike is that they are not totally unschooled HS guys sitting under the basket waiting for the ball. They can move around and hit mid range shots. Ike in particular has shown three point shooting skill, though it is not a big part of his offense. In any case, both of these guys have a lot more range than Hunter, who has somehow not kept Amare from scoring a zillion points.

Third, I expect both Ike and Simien to become outstanding pick and screen guys. The Sonics had a lot of success using Evans and Fortson with zero scroing skills because they were so good at setting picks. If anything, I'd like to see the Suns use more of the picks and double screens to get JJ open (using plays similar to those used for Reggie Miller).

Fourth, I would like another physical defender and rebounder available - especially someone who could knock Manu on his butt a few times.

Fifth, I like the fact that both Ike and Simien are excellant foul shooters to go with being good on the offensive glass. As opponents keep trying to get physical with the Suns, being able to shoot foul shots in huge - and why Hunter can't be on the floor at crunch time.
 

JCSunsfan

ASFN Icon
Joined
Oct 24, 2002
Posts
22,115
Reaction score
6,551
Mainstreet said:
I really think they could fill most of their holes in this draft as it appears deep.

Drafts always appear weak in January and deep in June. Its just the hype. This draft is nothing special.
 

Mainstreet

Cruisin' Mainstreet
Supporting Member
Joined
Oct 19, 2003
Posts
119,244
Reaction score
59,842
JCSunsfan said:
Drafts always appear weak in January and deep in June. Its just the hype. This draft is nothing special.


Your probably right JCSunsfan, however, since the age barrier may be an issue in the new CBA (hopefully being worked out) I thought there might be some more talented High Schoolers and even Europeans who stay in the draft who might worry about a potential age restriction (thus making the talent pool deeper than usual).

I guess why I like this draft, if the Suns could get some more early second round picks, they might be able to get a PG to back-up Nash with their first pick and get some bigs with some second round picks. I know this might be extremely chancey to go with a PG the first pick, but unless there is a quality big there that the Suns are high on, they definitely need a back-up PG for Nash. Yes, I know Barbosa might develop as PG and JJ can play the point but the Suns need their PG of the future very soon so Nash can work with him and also so Nash can get some quality rest.

I usually think drafting big in the draft first, but some role players might be able to help their frontline. Also this draft appears to be a crapshoot except for a handful of players. Their might be a young Carlos Booxzer or a relatively unknown European the Suns like in the second round round.

It's really only a thought. I just do not want the Suns to pass over the best BPA. Maybe the BPA will be a big but if he is a PG then the Suns seriously need to look at this position.
 
Last edited:

Joe Mama

Moderator
Supporting Member
Joined
May 14, 2002
Posts
9,501
Reaction score
964
Location
Gilbert, AZ
Don't forget that both Julius Hodge and Francisco Garcia are more than a debt that handling the ball. They are the type of players I can see the Phoenix Suns taking if they don't go big. Think versatility. I like Garcia better because he is saying much, much better shooter.

Joe Mama
 
OP
OP
George O'Brien

George O'Brien

ASFN Icon
Joined
Nov 22, 2003
Posts
10,297
Reaction score
0
Location
Sun City
Back in January I was saying I thought the late first round wasn't a huge drop from the mid lottery. Nothing has led me to think the Suns would be hugely better off at #10 than at #21, but the price would be a lot higher.

In some ways drafting at #21 has an advantage. When you draft early, there is a strong push to go for an "impact" player which leads to gambling. When drafting in the 20's, there is less inclination to gamble and a greater willingness to take a solid role player over a project who could be great someday.
 

Ouchie-Z-Clown

I'm better than Mulli!
Joined
Sep 16, 2002
Posts
64,047
Reaction score
58,936
Location
SoCal
haverford said:
LOL. In what universe is 6' 9" 255 lbs. "a bit undersized"? What kind of standard is at work here? Ninety percent of these pre-draft scouting reports consists of these distortions resulting from some fantasy of what is ideal.

George, I realize those are not your words I'm quoting, but the scouting report's.

he's got a lot of upper body strength and size. not a lot of junk in the trunk. that means he doesn't have a big base to work from. i think that's where the undersized notion comes from.

overall i think simien is a really nice prospect. he's not a leaper, but he's a good athlete that can get out and finish on the break. i think he'd be a great prospect to give amare and marion a blow.
 

tobiazz

Hall of Famer
Joined
Oct 28, 2003
Posts
2,153
Reaction score
4
cly2tw said:
Draftcity now has us take R. Morris.

Best case scenario: Magloire; Worst: Brendan Haywood? That sounds good enough for me.

He does not sound too bad. I could live with that pick. Their mock draft looks a little goofy, so I'm sure things will change drastically before the draft.
 

Mainstreet

Cruisin' Mainstreet
Supporting Member
Joined
Oct 19, 2003
Posts
119,244
Reaction score
59,842
This young man seems almost too good to be true, to have this much potential at such a young age and still growing (and likely to reach 7 feet). I don't know how draftnet can have him falling to the second round. If he is there when the Suns draft in the first round, he would be very hard to pass up as BPA. See link:


http://www.nbadraft.net/profiles/randolphmorris.asp
 
Last edited:

coloradosun

Hall of Famer
Joined
Jun 3, 2004
Posts
1,393
Reaction score
0
F-Dog said:
Simeon can't play on the perimeter and he can't play center, so I don't think he can help the Suns.

I agree, his scoring mainly came from down on the blocks as a low post threat. Also got a lot of scoring from the FT line after getting contact down low.
 

F-Dog

lurker
Joined
Aug 27, 2003
Posts
3,637
Reaction score
0
Location
Tucson
George O'Brien said:
First, I think the Suns need a backup who can score in the low post. Even if this is only for 10 to 12 minutes a game, it would keep the pressure on opponents who can ignore the post when Amare is out.

The Suns will never have fewer than two low-post options on the floor that are more favorable than going to Simien against the other team's center. Even Nash is an efficient inside player against a lot of PGs.


The problem is that the Suns' offense, as it currently stands, is one of the most efficient offenses in the history of the NBA. Opposing teams would love to see a player like Simien on the floor for the Suns, gumming everything up.

The Suns' offense was much easier to defend this year when Amare and Hunter were on the floor together. Hunter made up for that (on occasion) by anchoring the team's defense, which is not something you can expect from any of these PFs, no matter how much college experience they've got.


Like I said, if the Suns draft a PF, he's got to be able to shoot threes. :shrug:
 

Forum statistics

Threads
556,061
Posts
5,431,319
Members
6,329
Latest member
cardinals2025
Top