Official Survivor All-Stars thread (spoilers likely)

[Beaver]

I don't follow these shows, but tonight I was home and it was on. If they are supposed to be on an island without any help, how does that Boston Rob dude keep a perfect goatee? And why don't these old dudes have hair on their back? TV magic? Fill me in, please.

 

[Mike Olbinski]

They have luxury items sometimes, like a razor, etc.

Last night's show was friggin' awesome...Boston Rob is a master of this game...he may be the smartest guy to ever play the game, and also the best at the challenges.

Mike

 

[maddogkf]

Is it me or is Amber gettng hotter each week?

 

[Mike Olbinski]

Is it me or is Amber gettng hotter each week?

Yes...and I was majorly hoping she wouldn't go...the storyline of Rob and Amber is too good to throw away. I mean, Rob REALLY likes her, the guy was practically crying.

And I'd love to see a final four of Lex, Kathy, Rob and Amber. That would be very cool.

Mike

 

[Jersey Girl]

Yo, I am so much more attracted to Boston Rob after last night! I can't believe how upset he was. I mean, he's only known Amber for, what, 20 days? Of course, there aren't any other distractions on that island, so I guess it's easy to fall for somoeone.

I just hope Boston Rob doesn't screw himself over next week. The previews didn't look good for him.

Was glad to see Jerri go. She annoys me. And she was starting to look really rough.

I think Lex, Shi-Ann and Kathy were stupid NOT to vote Amber off. She has no loyalty toward them. Of course, Rob did say he would take care of Lex, so if Rob does screw himself with his tribe, he could always make an alliance with Lex, Kathy, Shi-Ann and Amber.

I need to get a life. I am too into this show.

 

[Mike Olbinski]

I need to get a life. I am too into this show.

You can NEVER be too into this show

Mike

 

[Brian in Mesa]

As much as Rob stabbed Lex in the back, Kathy did him one better.

When she told him that she was going to give him the immunity necklace, it stopped him from running around trying to pull another deal to get someone like Amber voted off.

He was sitting there all smug during the first part of the tribal council, knowing that he had Kathy's immunity coming to him. When Jeff opened it up for Rob or Kathy to give up their immunity and she said she had thought about it and decided to keep it - Lex was blown away.

I was hoping she would give him the immunity. Imagine the battle between Rob and Lex that would have resulted in...

 

[Shane]

As much as Rob stabbed Lex in the back, Kathy did him one better.

When she told him that she was going to give him the immunity necklace, it stopped him from running around trying to pull another deal to get someone like Amber voted off.

He was sitting there all smug during the first part of the tribal council, knowing that he had Kathy's immunity coming to him. When Jeff opened it up for Rob or Kathy to give up their immunity and she said she had thought about it and decided to keep it - Lex was blown away.

I was hoping she would give him the immunity. Imagine the battle between Rob and Lex that would have resulted in...

I was really hoping she would have given the immunity to Lex. That would have made everyone panic and not have a clue who to vote for. They would have went to the vote with only about a minute to make a decision.

Really would have made for great drama. I wonder who would have been voted off in that scenario?

 

[CaptTurbo]

I was really hoping she would have given the immunity to Lex. That would have made everyone panic and not have a clue who to vote for. They would have went to the vote with only about a minute to make a decision.

Really would have made for great drama. I wonder who would have been voted off in that scenario?

I was hoping for the same thing shane. It was there best hope. Then lex and comapnay vote for amber and the other group might vote for two different people making the Lex group win!

Lex and Kathy were very stupid not to vote of amber.

And my fellow PA hottie Amber is off my list of ever wanting to date! How the hell can you like Boston Rob. I mean YUCK!

 

[KingofCards]

Dude, Big Tom, Rupert and Jenna are idiots.


Why didn't they join up and vote off Ambuh?

Sunday's tribal council is a guaranteed tie.

Two votes for either Rupert or Jeanna and two votes for either Rob or Amber.

I think Rupert is going to win the million dollars.

 

[Mike Olbinski]

Anyone else think the jury is full of the biggest bunch of babies?

Lex, Shii Ann, Alicia...all rolling their eyes at everything...like NO ONE has ever lied in this show before?

Unbelievable how this cast is so uptight about the way people change alliances, etc. That's only happened over the entire course of the show.

Only one person can win, alliances will be broken.

Good episode tonight...Rob pitting Rupert and Tom against each other just shows you how well he plays the game.

Although, voting Tom out didn't make sense to me...I think Rupert is more of a threat than anyone else left besides Rob.

Mike

 

[KingofCards]

I think I would have voted off Jenna if I was Rob.

Big Tom and Rupert are too dumb to make an alliance with each other.

You are right about Rob that was pretty good when he tricked those two into fighting with each other.

I think Big Tom was about to wring Rob's neck when he got voted off.

Lex is a baby too. No way Rob wins the whole thing. The entire remaining cast hates him except Amber.

 

[Jersey Girl]

I think I would have voted off Jenna if I was Rob.

Big Tom and Rupert are too dumb to make an alliance with each other.

You are right about Rob that was pretty good when he tricked those two into fighting with each other.

I think Big Tom was about to wring Rob's neck when he got voted off.

Lex is a baby too. No way Rob wins the whole thing. The entire remaining cast hates him except Amber.

I have to agree. Voting off Big Tom was silly. I'm thinking not too many people on the jury will vote for Rob, even though he has played the game remarkably well. Lex, Alicia, Tom all hate him.

Ruppert or Jenna has to win immunity next time. Hell, even if they don't just vote for Rob or Amber, whoever doesn't win immunity.

If there's a tie, it goes to previous votes, right? Who has the most outta the three, anyone know?

 

[Jersey Girl]

Okay, I am answering my own question. According to the website (and if I can count right), the previous votes are:

Jenna = 3
Amber = 6
Rupert = 1
Rob = 0

Amber better hope she has immunity next time.

 

[KingofCards]

Okay, I am answering my own question. According to the website (and if I can count right), the previous votes are:

Jenna = 3
Amber = 6
Rupert = 1
Rob = 0

Amber better hope she has immunity next time.

I don't think they go by previous votes anymore.

 

[Mike Olbinski]

Okay, I am answering my own question. According to the website (and if I can count right), the previous votes are:

Jenna = 3
Amber = 6
Rupert = 1
Rob = 0

Amber better hope she has immunity next time.

That is pretty dang amazing, that the one guy everyone apparently hates the most, HAS NO VOTES.

And I don't think they go off previous anymore.

Also, remember there is supposed to be a HUGE twist or something on Sunday...who knows what it might be.

I'm thinking it's going to be that they're winning more money.

Mike

 

[maddogkf]

They go by striptease. Unfortunately, Haggish has no chance of beating Ambuh

 

[Jersey Girl]

Okay. I think I do remember that there was some showdown at an immunity instead of previous votes.

Will be fun to watch.

 

[Dback Jon]

At this point, Rob or Ambuh deserve to win - the others have been too stupid to vote them out when they had their chances.

 

[CaptTurbo]

Anyone else think the jury is full of the biggest bunch of babies?

Lex, Shii Ann, Alicia...all rolling their eyes at everything...like NO ONE has ever lied in this show before?

Mike

I agree 100%. They make themselves look like fools whenever they do that.

I dont know why they voted off Tom either. My only thoguht is editing. i think last nights episode was very poorly edited. They didnt show genna talking with Rob and Amber at all even though she is in a deep alliance with them. They only showed her saying that once.

i think they did that for the shock value of the vote.

 

[jf-08]

They go by striptease. Unfortunately, Haggish has no chance of beating Ambuh

hagrid

 

[maddogkf]

hagrid

Haggish, Hagrid, Haggis, Hilga...whatever....

I agree that he, JEnna, & Big TOm shoulda voted off perky chest. Maybe they thought that the jury would not vote for Rob or Amber, so that's why they had to get rid of Tom?

 

[Mike Olbinski]

I agree 100%. They make themselves look like fools whenever they do that.

I dont know why they voted off Tom either. My only thoguht is editing. i think last nights episode was very poorly edited. They didnt show genna talking with Rob and Amber at all even though she is in a deep alliance with them. They only showed her saying that once.

i think they did that for the shock value of the vote.

Even if they did edit it poorly, that conversation Rob and Ambuh had with Tom would make me think Tom thought he was safe.

It was a shocker for sure, and that staredown he gave Rob was pretty scary.

But there are two things that could happen if Rob makes it to the final two:

1. They all hate Rob, and vote for whoever is next to him.

2. They all hate Rob, but he played the game hard, and better than everyone else, so the give it to him anyways, ALA Richard Hatch from Season 1.


Mike

 

[Mike Olbinski]

At this point, Rob or Ambuh deserve to win - the others have been too stupid to vote them out when they had their chances.

Dude, where did you get the Ambuh from? WE've been saying that for weeks...lol

"Ah put ahn 'A' ohn my ahm for Ambuh..."

Mike

 

[jf-08]

Whenever the camera pans on Ambuh, they always start at her meat puppets. Did anyone else notice that?