OK, here is SUNCARDfan's poll

[NFL_FAN]

And if you choose other, please add a message saying what you would like to see.


#1
SunCardfan
Registered User


Join Date: Apr 2003
Posts: 4,030 Should we trade Boldin if his demands are too high?

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Well people kept asking for a poll so here it is.... here's what I said in the last one. just think that would send a bad precedent for us... I don't players to think they can get out of playing for us by having a really high price tag. If Boldin does want to be traded I say keep him anyways unless the trade is huge..like maybe two firsts and a really good player or something...

 

[arthurracoon]

Can we vote for as many as we want?

 

[NFL_FAN]

Can we vote for as many as we want?

Sure, why not!!!

 

[NFL_FAN]

Sure, why not!!!

Nevermind, I can't go back and change it!

 

[mdsisquo]

PLEASE PLEASE PLEASE PLEASE PLEASE PLEASE do not trade Boldin. Please, if there is a god do not let this happen. He is possibly our best player on O and i do not want to see him go. Why would we trade him? What do we have to gain? If he leaves our offense is seriously hurt and may go from top 15 to bottom 30. Please do not let him leave. Bad franchises let stars leave....Good/great franchises retain their star players if it is at all possible!

 

[NFL_FAN]

PLEASE PLEASE PLEASE PLEASE PLEASE PLEASE do not trade Boldin. Please, if there is a god do not let this happen. He is possibly our best player on O and i do not want to see him go. Why would we trade him? What do we have to gain? If he leaves our offense is seriously hurt and may go from top 15 to bottom 30. Please do not let him leave. Bad franchises let stars leave....Good/great franchises retain their star players if it is at all possible!

I agree but this is just an exercise to see what is acceptable for the Quan if it happened.

 

[WisconsinCard]

I voted for the very least that I would take. Because I know no one would ever give us a #1 and a player.

 

[LoyaltyisaCurse]

I selected other, meaning I would never trade Boldin!

 

[HeavyB3]

Other. You don't trade boldin. Period.

 

[cardsunsfan]

Other. You don't trade boldin. Period.

 

[cardsunsfan]

I voted for the very least that I would take. Because I know no one would ever give us a #1 and a player.

I bet you they would...

 

[NFL_FAN]

Out of nearly 100 viewers to this thread only 32 made a pick. Interesting.

 

[40yearfan]

I picked other. There's no way you will get 2 first rounders and another player or even a first and an additional player. Therefore, I'd just as soon keep him.

 

[cardsunsfan]

I picked other. There's no way you will get 2 first rounders and another player or even a first and an additional player. Therefore, I'd just as soon keep him.

So you're saying that noone would give a late first round pick..lets say....28th and one of their average starters for Boldin? I think it's time we trade for Harrison than! I think we could get him for our 8th and Shelton easy!

 

[WisconsinCard]

So you're saying that noone would give a late first round pick..lets say....28th and one of their average starters for Boldin? I think it's time we trade for Harrison than! I think we could get him for our 8th and Shelton easy!

Thats exactly what I was saying a few spots up. Quan has and injury history, and I don't think any one will give you a number 1 and a starter.

 

[cardsunsfan]

Thats exactly what I was saying a few spots up. Quan has and injury history, and I don't think any one will give you a number 1 and a starter.

So do players in the draft...who's a bigger risk Q or that your first round pick will pan out? Many first round picks... Bryant.. Pace..Jones... don't end up being very good and they are high firsts. Q is a proven commodity... Why does it seem like all teams are sooo confident they'll pick the perfect guy in the first?

 

[Pariah]

Other. You don't trade boldin. Period.

I tend to agree we shouldn't trade him, but if a team said "hey Denny, we'll give you our #1 this year and our #1 next year and this player," I'd snatch that up in a second.

Think about it--the Vikes didn't even get that for Moss.