Our receiving options without Hopkins

[DaHilg]

We are in trouble at WR to open the season. Trying to minimize it, analyze it away, explain it away, doesn't change that. Can we overcome this trouble? A dispassionate analysis says we can, if a lot of things go right, and our coach can do his job properly. Looking at what we're hoping for--an aging AJ Green to be the #2, hoping Rondale Moore can be the #3, hoping we get significant help from a rookie 2nd-round TE, hoping, hoping, hoping, paints a bleak picture.

It is what it is, a crappy situation we aren't prepared for. Will the intervening months mitigate the situation? Only the shadow knows.

Agree.. also Oline. If we are getting the same pressure on Kyler down the stretch in the interior we know history says Kyler can’t handle it.

 

[juza76]

xc_hide_links_from_guests_guests_error_hide_media

Hall of Famer just for his girlfriend

 

[TruColor]

What a weird comparison to make considering that all these units play their opposing defensive counterparts and not each other.

Seahawks=tanking trash
San Fran=run game and play action gods
St Louis = reigning champs and Kliff’s personal daddy

The Horizontal Raid is alive and well until proven otherwise.

Ummm...St. Louis?

 

[Krangodnzr]

Obviously it's never good to lose a star player, but as I said in the Nuk thread we still have a lot of options.

So I wanted to see how we stack up through those 1st 6 games vs the rest of the division.

Cardinals

WR1 - Hollywood Brown
WR2- AJ Green
WR3 - Rondale Moore
TE1 - Zach Ertz
TE2 - Maxx Williams
Receiving back - James Conner

Rams

WR1 - Cooper Kupp
WR2- Allen Robinson
WR3 - Van Jefferson
TE1 - Tyler Higbee
TE2 - Kendall Blanton
Receiving back - Kyren Williams?

Seahawks

WR1 - Tyler Lockett
WR2- DK Metcalf
WR3 - Freddie Swain
TE1 - Noah Fant
TE2 - Will Dissley
Receiving back - Kenneth Walker

Niners

WR1 - Deebo
WR2- Brandon Aiyuk
WR3 - Jauan Jennings
TE1 - George Kittle
TE2 - Ross Dwelley
Receiving back - JaMycal Hasty


It's clear that all 3 teams have a higher peak than we will have. Lockett, Deebo and Kupp are all currently better than Brown. I think Brown can be much better in our system with Kyler but it's unrealistic to think he's going to be Kupp or Deebo.

AJ Green isn't cooked. You don't get 850 yards and finish WR32 despite being 3rd in target share if you are cooked. He did have more yards than Aiyuk last year though. He's still a good player but he isn't what he was and the Seahawks and Rams beat us here also.

But after that I think we are the best of the bunch. The others don't have much at WR3 outside Van Jefferson but I think Moore can make a similar leap in year 2 as Van did. Our overall TE groups are better and Conner as a receiver is the best of the bunch.

As long as we spread the ball around as we usually do we should be fine.

And when Nuk is back I think we have the best overall receiving options in the division.

Van Jefferson isn't really that good of a player, and he was older coming out so he has less growth. Rams fans are already starting to feel he is a meh player and is highly replaceable.

Robinson was a risky add by the Rams and relying him could undo their passing offense to a degree.

 

[cardsfanmd]

Maxx Williams likely wont be playing in the first 6 games, let alone occupying the #2 TE spot.

Also, who wants to make a wager on the Brown vs Deebo starlike for the season. I think Brown will def beat him in yards and will only be beaten in total TD’s if SF has Deebo running the ball in the red zone.

 

[BurqueCardFan]

I could care less who we have at receiver. It's time for Kyler and Kliff to prove their worth.
Transcendent QB's like Brady & Rogers have made due with mediocre receiving options at different times of their careers. Or they have made stars of the guys nobody knew about. Guys like Welker, Edelman were castoffs prior to going to NE. Same can be said for GB. I don't think they have ever invested in round 1 WR during Rogers tenure. All were 2nd/3rd rounder's (Adams, Cobb, Jordy, Jennings, etc...).
If Kyler wants to be paid like the top QB in the league, then he better produce no matter who is catching the ball. I will bet Mahommes and Reid will be just fine without Tyreek and company from last year.

 

[BritCard]

Van Jefferson isn't really that good of a player, and he was older coming out so he has less growth. Rams fans are already starting to feel he is a meh player and is highly replaceable.

Robinson was a risky add by the Rams and relying him could undo their passing offense to a degree.

Van had 800 yards last year. He's not bad.

I don't get the Woods for Robinson switch. I think Woods is better in the scheme (unless he wanted out. He wasn't happy last year).

I don't think the Rams are as good as last year.

 

[jf-08]

What a weird comparison to make considering that all these units play their opposing defensive counterparts and not each other.

Seahawks=tanking trash
San Fran=run game and play action gods
St Louis = reigning champs and Kliff’s personal daddy

The Horizontal Raid is alive and well until proven otherwise.

Los Angeles

 

[Krangodnzr]

Van had 800 yards last year. He's not bad.

I don't get the Woods for Robinson switch. I think Woods is better in the scheme (unless he wanted out. He wasn't happy last year).

I don't think the Rams are as good as last year.

On 50 catches. It's nice playing 2nd fiddle to a superstar in Kupp, he got a ton less coverage.

It's funny because I think the Rams will be good most years with McVay as coach but I doubt they have many Super Bowl chances.

Once Donald slows down, people are going to quickly realize that most of that defense is filled with only okay players.

 

[Garthshort]

Deebo is VG, but I don't know who his QB will be. And that will play a big part on the type of year he has. IMO.

 

[PDXChris]

OBJ will be 7 months removed from knee surgery in kick off weekend for a 6-9 month recovery. Could be the cheapest option, even if we had to ease him back. I'd check in on him at the start of training camp.

 

[BritCard]

OBJ will be 7 months removed from knee surgery in kick off weekend for a 6-9 month recovery. Could be the cheapest option, even if we had to ease him back. I'd check in on him at the start of training camp.

Julio seems like the obvious answer if he's willing to sign for the 4m that Nuk is losing and except his body can only handle being part of a rotation now.

 

[PDXChris]

Julio seems like the obvious answer if he's willing to sign for the 4m that Nuk is losing and except his body can only handle being part of a rotation now.

Julio is my first choice as well. I assume he ends up in a more WR needy city. I could see him going to TB for a ring too. We'll probably bring in AB!

 

[Krangodnzr]

Deebo is VG, but I don't know who his QB will be. And that will play a big part on the type of year he has. IMO.

I'm a Deebo fan dating back to college, but I would fear spending big money on him because of his extensive injury history.

 

[QuebecCard]

Julio seems like the obvious answer if he's willing to sign for the 4m that Nuk is losing and except his body can only handle being part of a rotation now.

I'll go for Will Fuller at the same price.

 

[BritCard]

I'll go for Will Fuller at the same price.

Fuller is just a worse Marquise Brown though. Julio is more similar to Nuk.

 

[QuebecCard]

Fuller is just a worse Marquise Brown though. Julio is more similar to Nuk.

He's had his injury woes, a broken finger in 2021 but at 28, not 'shot' as I suspect is the case for Julio.

He's 6'1.

 

[mjb21aztd]

Any wr trade options? With nuk out heard suggested on 910 am tod

I know have brown but still tad weak at wr till nuk ret.... dangit hop

Really prayin mcbride shows somethin

 

[Cheesebeef]

Re: MAXX, I’m continually amazed how so many people keep penciling in players who are constantly injured as anything the team can depend on. Especially a constantly injured player who’s coming back from major injury.

 

[PJ1]

Fuller is just a worse Marquise Brown though. Julio is more similar to Nuk.

He is hardly similar to Nuk at this stage. He was lousy last year.

 

[AZfaninMN]

You must be registered for see images attach

 

[oaken1]

We are in trouble at WR to open the season. Trying to minimize it, analyze it away, explain it away, doesn't change that. Can we overcome this trouble? A dispassionate analysis says we can, if a lot of things go right, and our coach can do his job properly. Looking at what we're hoping for--an aging AJ Green to be the #2, hoping Rondale Moore can be the #3, hoping we get significant help from a rookie 2nd-round TE, hoping, hoping, hoping, paints a bleak picture.

It is what it is, a crappy situation we aren't prepared for. Will the intervening months mitigate the situation? Only the shadow knows.

No we ain't

 

[SoonerLou]

He is hardly similar to Nuk at this stage. He was lousy last year.

I dont think Julio signs up for 6 games.

It should be noted his PFF was 74.2. Higher than Kirk and AJ. He just has to not get hurt.

Julio isn't who he use to be, but I think we're being overall critical of his game. He had to make a major shift from the Falcons offense to the Titans offense. He had a 86 PFF with a more dynamic passing game.

 

[PJ1]

I dont think Julio signs up for 6 games.

It should be noted his PFF was 74.2. Higher than Kirk and AJ. He just has to not get hurt.

Julio isn't who he use to be, but I think we're being overall critical of his game. He had to make a major shift from the Falcons offense to the Titans offense. He had a 86 PFF with a more dynamic passing game.

I did watch some Titans games last year and wasn’t impressed at all. Yes he did get hurt but Titans didn’t want him back and he is still out there now.

 

[Jetstream Green]

Without Hop, we are average or maybe even a little above average if you take into account our TEs and how well Conner catches out of the backfield. Point, I'm a big fan of Kyler but he has no excuses with D-hop out