Matt Hasselback has been a below-average QB for three seasons, two of which have been in offenses tailored to his skill set. Like McNabb, Hasselback is a pure West Coast QB and would be coming into an offense that doesn't suit his skill set. Add in the fact that he's been knocked around the last three straight years and I have no idea what people are looking at.
1) Bulger - He's free. He's young-ish. He's been productive in a similar offense (assuming we're still running the Martz-Cribbed offense that Warner brought). He's had a year to re-group and should be fresh.
As far as ability goes, Bulger really is the perfect option. He's got a quick release, is pretty good at identifying a defense and pre-snap reads and has good accuracy. I'd say his decision making is a bit lacking but not alarmingly so. Durability was, is and will be the question with him.
2) Alex Smith - He's free. He's young. He's been productive in a spread shotgun offense that we've been running. He's more athletic than Blaine Gabbert. He has leadership ability and would like to stick a fork in our division rivals.
I've got nothing against Alex Smith and think the book's still relatively open on him. Way too much instability with coaches and schemes in his career to consider him a fully defined QB. From what I've read though, he's probably going back to SF for another year. Not sure he'd be a good marriage with Whis either considering how much Nolan questioned his toughness.
3) Trent Edwards - He's free. He's young. He has the attributes of a Martz-type quarterback and excels in fair conditions. He's a competitor.
Edwards has always disappointed me whenever I've watched him. Seems to have the physical tools but he rarely seems to get positive results on the field. He would really scare me as the starter. His decision making and accuracy were very shaky from what I saw. Certainly not as cerebral as I thought a successful Stanford QB would be.
4) Kellen Clemens - He's free. He's young. He'll lose a competition with John Skelton.
Two different coaching staffs have given up on this guy and looked for any option other than him before they gave up. Not too encouraging. As bad as Sanchez played at times, they still didn't give him a shot. Career 51% passer with more than 2/1 INT/TD in his career in the time that he has played. Seems like "just a guy". Why bother, just stick with Skelton.
5) Carson Palmer. He'll cost a draft pick. He's on the hook for 2 years, $25 million. His skills are declining. He passed the Bengals into at least two losses last season. He probably doesn't want to play here.
Love Palmer's skills and potential and think a change of scenery will do him well. I agree that he probably doesn't want to play for the Cardinals and would probably cost too much anyway.
6) Kevin Kolb. He hasn't been productive. He doesn't have leadership ability. He's from a QB-friendly offense with superior tools. He'll cost draft picks and a mega-contract.
I agree. Has done far too little to warrant the attention and the price the Eagles are asking. If I could find a QB that actually hasn't looked good in the Eagles offense it would be easier to give him the benefit of doubt. But I can't help but think the Eagles wouldn't be shopping him if he was really the next superstar QB. For the price, he hasn't even proved to be durable.
7) Matt Hasselback. He's free. He's old. He's hilarious. Good leadership ability. Not a downfield passer.
If he came cheap enough, I wouldn't suggest against seeing how much could be squeezed out of the rest of his career but he seems like a career WCO guy who's best years were due in large part to an incredible running game and MVP RB. His accuracy and overall ability seem like they would trump a system change and at the very least, the Cardinals should be extremely familiar with his strengths and weaknesses.
8) Dennis Dixon. Restricted free agent. He's a former Steeler. He has mobility.
The Steeler connection makes for an obvious link but they really wanted to give him the 2nd string job last year and he couldn't do it. Got one decent game out of him and then he sprained his knee. In 59 career attempts, has 1 TD/2 INT. I think they still like him but hasn't capitalized on his chances. I don't think Whis is on firm enough ground to start a complete unknown at QB in '11 though.