I would rather have Patrick Peterson be a poor tackler and play 16 games per season than be a great tackler and risk a concussion or shoulder injury.
It is the same with Fitz. I trust Fitz to determine when he needs to put his body on the line and when he needs to protect himself, and he sure as hell makes those decisions on a play by play basis.
Mitch could make the same argument against Russell Wilson as he makes with Patrick Peterson. Wilson consistently makes decisions and gives up yards to protect himself. Where I differ is that I am willing to trust Peterson/Wilson to make that decision in the moment.
In regards to Peterson being one of the best CBs in the game today...he is, and has been for years now. PFF shows him being the 49 best CB which is laughable, but if you want to go that route, their manufactured rankings are your best argument.
Nope. That is not how it works, at least based on what I am reading on this post.
It is clear as day that Fitzgerald will hit the dirt the moment he feels it is a lost cause. There are so many examples of Fitzgerald doing this in games this year that you would have to be purposefully looking the other way not to notice.
The difference is one player is beloved, and another scorned. That is it. If you look hard enough at Fitzgerald's game, you could easily pick out flaws with what he does on the field, but that has not been done, because its Fitzgerald, his overall play makes up for those negatives. Peterson just doesn't get the same respect for what he brings to the team outside of the negatives.
Why ? Have no idea, other than to say personal preference. Which is fine, but I call that out as such. The only argument so far between the two is "well, Fitzgerald has more heart." That is fine too. An opinion based on speculation but an opinion none the less.
BTW, The way Fitzgerald decides when and when not to put that extra effort in is, in my humble opinion, the smart way to play football in the NFL.
Why risk injury and a possible fumble/turnover fighting for two more inches ?
Who cares about two inches on a football field if you fumble the ball ?
Who cars about two inches if Fitzgerald gets hurt on that play ? Heck, he can go down, live for another day, and catch a pass for 15 yards on the next play, which is a hell of a lot more productive then two inches.
Same goes for Peterson, you live to fight another day, and possibly get a INT on the next one.
Football is a fame of effort, but in the pros, you have to be smart about it. It is a long season, and you need your best players to make plays all season long, not just for one play.
Where does the line between effort and smart lie ? I have no idea. I am not a professional athlete. Personally, I think Fitzgerald has mastered the art of when to take chances and when not to.
I think that long run he made against the Packers happens because NO ONE expected him to cut back when he went towards the sidelines. It is like an Ace-in-the-whole, or like a good fastball pitcher that understands if you throw about 90% for most the game, if you choose your spots to throw 100% they will not be expecting it, and you save your arm.
Again, its professional sports, not highschool.