Poll : What team will Peyton Manning pick to play

What team will Payton Manning pick to play for in 2012

  • Miami Dolphins

    Votes: 11 14.1%
  • New York Jets

    Votes: 6 7.7%
  • Arizona Cardinals

    Votes: 47 60.3%
  • San Francisco 49ers

    Votes: 6 7.7%
  • Washington Redskins

    Votes: 3 3.8%
  • Other

    Votes: 5 6.4%

  • Total voters
    78
  • Poll closed .

az jam

ASFN Icon
Joined
Mar 6, 2004
Posts
13,029
Reaction score
5,329
Location
Scottsdale, AZ
What team will Peyton Manning pick to play

What team do you really feel that Peyton Manning will pick to play for in 2012.
We are assuming that the Colts will drop him and he becomes a free agent.
 
Last edited:
OP
OP
az jam

az jam

ASFN Icon
Joined
Mar 6, 2004
Posts
13,029
Reaction score
5,329
Location
Scottsdale, AZ
I chose Miami Dolphins as he has a condo there and he an his wife really would like to live there. I also think the owner will make a big push to get him. I'm not sure if the Bidwills will even go after him.

I didn't include Seattle or the Titans which could also be in play for him.
 

Crazy Canuck

ASFN Icon
BANNED BY MODERATORS
Joined
May 14, 2002
Posts
10,077
Reaction score
0
I chose Miami Dolphins as he has a condo there and he an his wife really would like to live there. I also think the owner will make a big push to get him. I'm not sure if the Bidwills will even go after him.

I didn't include Seattle or the Titans which could also be in play for him.

Well, Miami made big pushes for Harbaugh and Fisher and failed, not for lack of money. The changes in their FO and coaching hardly speaks to the type of stability that (IM0) would be part of Manning's decision. Amongst other pluses, AZ offers a minimum of 9 indoor games (11 in 2012) to a guy who's played his whole career under a dome. The condo will be there in the offseason, as it has been for years.
 

Absolute Zero

ASFN Icon
Joined
Aug 9, 2005
Posts
17,700
Reaction score
9,161
I say he retires. Life is too short, why screw with a serious neck injury and end up vegetablized?
 

Cardinals.Ken

That's Mr. Riff-Raff to you!
Joined
Jan 13, 2003
Posts
13,359
Reaction score
60
Location
Mesa, AZ
If this is "all things considered" (ie. healthy enough to play, same money/years on contract, etc.) I think he would pick the Jets off that list.

The country's #1 media market, plus Ryan is more of a defensively minded coach so he would be more likely give him autonomy to develop their offensive scheme. IMHO
 

Pariah

H.S.
Supporting Member
Joined
Feb 3, 2003
Posts
35,345
Reaction score
19
Location
The Aventine
I went with SF.

Big market, great defense, easier division, solid run game, good coach and cardinal luck all point to SF.

I hope I'm wrong.
 

CtCardinals78

ASFN Addict
Joined
Nov 2, 2006
Posts
7,256
Reaction score
2
I went with SF.

Big market, great defense, easier division, solid run game, good coach and cardinal luck all point to SF.

I hope I'm wrong.

SF are Super Bowl contenders next year with Alex Smith. No way would they screw around with that. Sure they probably would be with Manning too, but he's 37, hasn't played in a year and is coming off of three major surgeries with lots of questions about arm strength. Re-signing Alex Smith is the less riskier option for SF and the one I think they opt with.
 

PACardsFan

ASFN Icon
Joined
May 15, 2002
Posts
10,309
Reaction score
12,405
Location
York, PA
After little bro's 2nd SB ring, one thing is for certain, Peyton will NOT retire. He'll obviously go to a team that he feels is a QB away from getting him back to a SB. It'll be up to Whiz, Fitz & the Cardinal brass to convince the Mannings that we are that team. I say the "Mannings", because Dad will have a big say in that decison making process.

It looks like Peyton will make it as financially soothing as possible. He's not out to rape the teams that step forward with interest. This will greatly increase the number of candidates. Even with an enlarged pool, the Cardinals have plenty to offer. I'm sure that the Cardinals will point to the success they had with Warner, but we'll need Warner to help us drive that point home. From his recent comments, I'm a little leery of whether his input will help or hurt us. I'm going to go out on a limb & still say that Warner will help us in this process.

So who's REALLY interested out there, and who really has a need for a veteran QB, who is looking to win NOW?

Washington - They defintely have the need & their owner loves to make splashy moves. They have a solid D, but no receivers & a very average running game. Shanahan is no longer considered an offensive genious. They would offer Peyton the moon in return, but one thing cannot change. The Skins play in the same division as the Giants. I honestly don't see the Mannings wanting that strife. They are OK with competing with each other once a season, but not 2-3 times at the expense of one of those teams not making the playoffs. Top it off with an inept owner & I don't see this happening. Could happen with any other family, but not the Mannings.

Minnesota - Definite need, with a great RB to complement Peyton. Too many negatives - 1. They feel Ponder is ready to play now & they like him. 2. Coaching staff is on thin ice, future uncertain. 3. Franchise's status is questionable. 4. Team has so many holes. They couldn't win, even with Peyton. Huge longshot.

Tampa Bay - As bad as Freeman was, I still don't see them giving up on him yet. Manning family doesn't want a 1st year HC & Schianno is an ******.

San Francisco - This is the one that I fear, because Harbaugh will do ANYTHING to win. He's the most competitive individual I have ever seen. He is a great salesman & is also sincere & loyal. If he can convince ownership (and he can) that Peyton is where they need to go, then Manning will be priority one. I could see the Mannings loving this option. The only downside is their lack of receivers. Manning would bring along Wayne & this is very much a possibilty. If Manning goes here, they can win 2-3 SB's in the next 5 years. They're definitely a favorite in the Manning sweepstakes.

Seattle - They are also a team that has a need. Solid D, solid running game, solid fan base, But arrogant, pompous HC. Not sure that Manning wants to play in that climate either. Longshot!

Miami - Definite need, with some upside. They have a strong nucleus & can win right away, but ownership has more bark than bite in getting what they want. Warmer home games, although rain will rear its ugly head. Road games in Buffalo, New England & New York are not positives. Furthermore, HC was brought in to help secure Flynn as their future. I don't see them deviating from that course.

Tennessee - Here's a distinct possibility. Hassellbeck is just about toast & Locker is questionable at best. They have a solid D, a great OL, a great RB, & a couple of dangereous receivers. Peyton LOVES that part of the Country. With Manning, they are a SB contender. One of the top 3 candidates!

Jacksonville - I think they have a definite need, but this franchise has questions everywhere. Just not going to happen.

Kansas City - Definite need, but the Mannings wouldn't be interested while they have a defensive minded HC there.

Arizona - Almost a picture perfect match, with the exception of our OLine. Dome stadium, with perfect weather conditions. A HOF WR, with some very underrated talent to complement Fitz. Could also bring along Wayne, which would make our aerial offense perhaps the most dangerous in the league. The OL gets 50% better, just adding Manning & his ability to spot blitzes & react accordingly. A solid RB tandem in Wells & Williams. A solid & up and coming defense that could create many short fields for Manning & company. I think that Peyton would LOVE to play for Whiz. I also think that Daddy would also love to see his son play for Whiz. Whiz wouldn't have to create a vision for Peyton. Bring out the Warner tapes & Peyton could see for himself. Whiz won a SB with a very young QB & almost won one with a very old one. His pedigree speaks for itself. I think that Michael Bidwill is a gentleman & the Manning family would like him very much. It comes down to how well we can convince Peyton that we will upgrade the OL, or show him on tape that Kolb & Skelton's inexperience had a lot to do with our OL woes. We'll be a finalist!

Top 3 options in no particular order:

Arizona

San Francisco

Tennesee
 
Last edited:

kerouac9

Klowned by Keim
Joined
Feb 14, 2003
Posts
39,065
Reaction score
31,436
Location
Gilbert, AZ
Anothre reason that Miami might be appealing is its much greater proximity to the Madison Avenue endorsers that Manning is so close to. Because Miami plays in the AFC East, they are on when most of the nation is watching football games, and they get exposure to the enormous media markets of New York (Jets) and New England (Pats) four times a year.

Arizona may no longer be the "armpit of the NFL" when it comes to the play on the field, but there still aren't the marketing opportunities here that there would be on the East Coast.

Yeah, yeah, yeah... Los Angeles is right around the corner, but those aren't the same kind of business interests that Peyton courts. He doesn't want a movie career.
 

Cardinals.Ken

That's Mr. Riff-Raff to you!
Joined
Jan 13, 2003
Posts
13,359
Reaction score
60
Location
Mesa, AZ
Arizona may no longer be the "armpit of the NFL" when it comes to the play on the field, but there still aren't the marketing opportunities here that there would be on the East Coast.

I would offer up Steve Nash as proof that Arizona is not the place to be for market exposure, regardless of which sport an athlete plays.
 

thephoenixson28

All Star
Joined
Oct 14, 2009
Posts
927
Reaction score
114
Manning doesn't need to go to a big market team to sell his stuff. He just wants to win. Hopefully San Francisco doesn't go after him, Cuz Arizona I think would be in trouble. I doubt they let Smith go, depending on what type of money he wants.
 

Crazy Canuck

ASFN Icon
BANNED BY MODERATORS
Joined
May 14, 2002
Posts
10,077
Reaction score
0
Manning doesn't need to go to a big market team to sell his stuff. He just wants to win. Hopefully San Francisco doesn't go after him, Cuz Arizona I think would be in trouble. I doubt they let Smith go, depending on what type of money he wants.

But, I wonder whether Manning would want to follow in the Montana, Young footsteps or blaze his own path.
 

splitsecond

ASFN Addict
Joined
Jan 16, 2009
Posts
5,584
Reaction score
1,538
Location
Chandler, AZ
Every single one of you voting against AZ is voting against instinct and just doing so to save yourself the sadness if for some reason it doesn't happen.

Preorder your #18's folks.
 

thephoenixson28

All Star
Joined
Oct 14, 2009
Posts
927
Reaction score
114
Every single one of you voting against AZ is voting against instinct and just doing so to save yourself the sadness if for some reason it doesn't happen.

Preorder your #18's folks.
Yeah Shane, don't fight it. It's going to happen.
 

Totally_Red

Air Raid Warning!
Joined
Apr 26, 2005
Posts
8,976
Reaction score
4,992
Location
Iowa
There's as much chance for the Cardinals as anyone else IMO. It's up to Whis and Fitz and MB to pull out ALL the stops to land Manning. If it's pure dollars than Washington wins. If all the intangibles are added, it could be us. As for SF, that is a run-first conservative offense. I'm not sure that's want Peyton wants at this stage of his career.
 
OP
OP
az jam

az jam

ASFN Icon
Joined
Mar 6, 2004
Posts
13,029
Reaction score
5,329
Location
Scottsdale, AZ
Good analysis PAcardsfan. I didn't show the Titans for two reasons:
1. The drafted Locker last year with the 8th pick in the first round. I think he will be starting soon & not sitting 3 to 4 years behind Manning.
2. The Titans are in the same division as the Colts. Manning has a lot of class and I really don't think he wants to be against them twice a year. He is not a Farve who signed with the Vikings to show up the Packers and Tom Thompson for getting rid of him. It will be very positive parting with the Colts and Irsay even though there has been some bickering.
 

Phrazbit

ASFN Icon
Joined
Oct 10, 2011
Posts
20,627
Reaction score
11,899
I would offer up Steve Nash as proof that Arizona is not the place to be for market exposure, regardless of which sport an athlete plays.


Football is a different can of worms. The sport itself is bigger than any market. Brett Favre was one of the most popular players of ALL TIME while playing in rural Wisconsin... and its not like Peyton struggled with exposure while playing in Indianapolis.

I think media market will be at the bottom of his priorities. Winning, teammates, coaches and climate will be at the top, and probably in that order.
 

Cardinals.Ken

That's Mr. Riff-Raff to you!
Joined
Jan 13, 2003
Posts
13,359
Reaction score
60
Location
Mesa, AZ
Football is a different can of worms. The sport itself is bigger than any market. Brett Favre was one of the most popular players of ALL TIME while playing in rural Wisconsin... and its not like Peyton struggled with exposure while playing in Indianapolis.

I think media market will be at the bottom of his priorities. Winning, teammates, coaches and climate will be at the top, and probably in that order.

Good point.
 

Staff online

Forum statistics

Threads
560,033
Posts
5,469,472
Members
6,338
Latest member
61_Shasta
Top