Pre-Season Weekly Who impressed you and why? (Bears)

[TJ]

Saying that I am not sure he is going to end up starting Week 1. I am more convinced then ever Wiz just isn't a Leinart guy. After seeing many of this choices Wiz has made while watching these preseason games, it almost like he doesnt want him to get numbers. Its counter intuitive but seems to be true. I can't understand why Wiz wouldn't go for it 4th and 1 on the 50 or leave him in there for the rest of the third quarter. I would think he wants to give Matt more confidence but it seems like he pulls the plug as soon as Matt starts to get on a roll.

I guess I could be wrong but it's JMHO.

As you know I didnt watch the game, but from what I can imagine, after going 9/10 1 TD 0 INT in a rather unusual QB competition, I think Whiz was convinced that he did fine. Im not sold on Whiz having a vendetta out for Leinart; otherwise, he simply wouldnt be here and Whis would not have blown smoke up our butts all offseason saying "Matty is out guy" and praising him for his work ethic.

 

[Longcolts]

I'll give a shout out to Big Gabe "Lo-Fat" Watson. I never saw a QB try to hide between the blades of grass before, but when he saw Gabe coming right at him he was hugging dirt and trying to disappear.

Hugging dirt nothing, he was trying to dig himself a hole!

 

[desertrat218]

That ball to Hightower was in no way an easy catch. I also only remember Beanie dropping 1 pass that was later in the game after Anderson was already out(maybe I missed an earlier one though). Regardless Anderson has a career comp % of 53%, and you pretty much know you're not getting an accurate QB if you play him.

Leinart's career pass pct is 57%, not really that big a difference...especially considering Matt has had some of the best WRs in the NFL to throw to.

The QBs played well tonight, Skelton was the only one that really didn't shine. I hope Komar wins a roster spot too, he showed toughness and made plays. There were a lot of positives tonight, but I don't think the QB situation has been resolved in any way. At least now I feel a lot better about things no matter which one wins the starting job.

 

[SunsTzu]

Leinart's career pass pct is 57%, not really that big a difference...especially considering Matt has had some of the best WRs in the NFL to throw to.

Leinart has a 60% completion rate as a starter. Anderson's comp % in college was 51% compared to Matt's 65%. Don't really see how anyone could argue accuracy between the 2.

 

[TJ]

Leinart has a 60% completion rate as a starter. Anderson's comp % in college was 51% compared to Matt's 65%. Don't really see how anyone could argue accuracy between the 2.

This

The two are polar opposite QBs. One has a big arm but is inaccurate. One is very accurate but doesnt have ideal arm strength.

More often than not, those who are more accurate than strong armed succeed in the NFL. This is why I hope Matty is the starter. Maybe he doesnt light up the joint, but my guess is he doesnt lose games like Anderson is capable of.

 

[Shane]

the TD was all YAC)

The same could be said for Breastons TD too BTW.

 

[desertrat218]

Leinart has a 60% completion rate as a starter. Anderson's comp % in college was 51% compared to Matt's 65%. Don't really see how anyone could argue accuracy between the 2.

College stats don't matter, it's not like they played on even teams. Leinart played on a team full of future NFL players, Anderson didn't. I merely pointed out that their pro numbers aren't that far apart, and Leinart did have the best WR tandem in the NFL to throw to. I think either QB can win some games, but not sure if either one of them will be good enough to beat the elite teams.

 

[Mulli]

I dug it when Washington went up against Olin Kreutz, the most over-rated C ever( but still decent), and Washington was able to shed the block and make the tackle.

 

[nashman]

Matt outplayed DA tonight, his throws were accurate and in stride. DA did not play horrible but Williams made his numbers better on some pretty poor throws, ie behind him and such. Also DA did not start moving the ball early until Whiz threw Beanie in in the third series or so and it seem to spark the offense (you know the threat of run that he did not give leinart the first 2 preseason games). It really seems as though Whiz just has a personal issue with Matt and as well as he has played he still may get snubbed because of this issue. Matt should be the starter IMO and most others who have eyes and can see! Not sure what the hell is going on but Matt is the QB Whiz has said in the past he wanted a ball control QB not making mistakes. Why all of a sudden is he wanting someone to wing the ball all over the field when that always leads to TO's especially with a guy like DA? Its all very strange not sure what the hell is going on in Whiz's head.

 

[Mulli]

Would like to add Ken whisenhunt to the list! Master motivator. Both qb's responded in a good way! Good stuff!

No way, Whiz was mediocre.

/clif

 

[nashman]

Their college stats are more fair to compare than the Pro ones when DA has started way more games than Matt has been given a chance too. I know this DA still has a terrible accuracy problem and he has been in the league for years. Matt has not had the opportunity and still looks better.

 

[Buckybird]

Matt outplayed DA tonight, his throws were accurate and in stride. DA did not play horrible but Williams made his numbers better on some pretty poor throws, ie behind him and such. Also DA did not start moving the ball early until Whiz threw Beanie in in the third series or so and it seem to spark the offense (you know the threat of run that he did not give leinart the first 2 preseason games). It really seems as though Whiz just has a personal issue with Matt and as well as he has played he still may get snubbed because of this issue. Matt should be the starter IMO and most others who have eyes and can see! Not sure what the hell is going on but Matt is the QB Whiz has said in the past he wanted a ball control QB not making mistakes. Why all of a sudden is he wanting someone to wing the ball all over the field when that always leads to TO's especially with a guy like DA? Its all very strange not sure what the hell is going on in Whiz's head.

and throw in the fact Leinart is much better in play action. I feel your pain, but I really feel DA gets the job

 

[Brian]

Leinart is far & away the star of the game. He came in with a lot of pressure on him & looked outstanding. Cut Anderson & keep Hall & Skelton!!

+1

If you watched the game, RARELY did DA look away from his primary reciever. He would take the snap and stare down his target. A friggin' defensive lineman batted away one of his passes because of it. Way to scan the field DA...moron.

Hall seemed to be the only one that went through his progressions.

 

[Shane]

No way, Whiz was mediocre.

/clif

Ha!

 

[Dayman]

I thought Dray looked pretty good tonight. Actually, I've been impressed with him all preseason. He just needs to stay healthy.

Jason Wright had the run of the night.

Dan Williams didn't have a big stat game, but he ate up a lot of double teams. CC is going to have a huge year if DD and Williams keep taking on two blockers.

Daryl Washington might have saved us from a linebacking crisis. I expect him to struggle a bit in the beginning, but he's considerably more talented than Beisel or Togafau.

 

[Garthshort]

I haven't seen the game yet, it's on at 4PM in NY, but did follow it on NFL.com. Without knowing whom, I'd nominate someone from the OL to the honor roll. Would it be Deuce, Keith, Sendlein, I have no idea, but feel someone deserves kudos.

 

[SunsTzu]

College stats don't matter, it's not like they played on even teams. Leinart played on a team full of future NFL players, Anderson didn't. I merely pointed out that their pro numbers aren't that far apart, and Leinart did have the best WR tandem in the NFL to throw to. I think either QB can win some games, but not sure if either one of them will be good enough to beat the elite teams.

I don't even know what you're trying to argue. If Anderson actually had comparable accuracy to Leinart there wouldn't be any contest for the QB spot and the Browns would never have let him go.

Seriously just look at the pre-season stats with them playing with pretty much the same teammates. Leinart 82.6% and DA 58.5%.

 

[Doc Cardinal]

I haven't seen the game yet, it's on at 4PM in NY, but did follow it on NFL.com. Without knowing whom, I'd nominate someone from the OL to the honor roll. Would it be Deuce, Keith, Sendlein, I have no idea, but feel someone deserves kudos.

Yeah....I agree.....the OL has been bashed this preseason (and sometimes deservedly so)....good to see them hangin in there on both the pass and run.

I thought the play action stuff especially with Toast was effective.

 

[cardsfanmd]

College stats don't matter, it's not like they played on even teams. Leinart played on a team full of future NFL players, Anderson didn't. I merely pointed out that their pro numbers aren't that far apart, and Leinart did have the best WR tandem in the NFL to throw to. I think either QB can win some games, but not sure if either one of them will be good enough to beat the elite teams.

FWIW though, Leinart had to throw to Skillethands too

 

[MadCardDisease]

1. Matt Leinart: With the exception some protection break downs(not his fault) he was very good tonight. Accurate and decisive. Lead a scoring drive but should have lead 2 if not for Beanies "fumble"

2. Greg Toler: Been preaching it all training camp. The guy would hold his own physically against the likes of Larry fricken Fitzgerald. Continues to show he is astarting caliber CB who is athletic and has ball skills to match.

3. Daryl Washington: Again smooth and quick to the ball. in on a number of plays. Not easily fooled at all on run/pass. he is a natural and just has good instincts. I truly think he will be a better player than Dansby by next season. I hope he remains a starter from this point on.

4. Stephen Williams: Again just afantastic outing against another teams #1 CB's. This kid is a real gem. JUST WOW!

5. Dan Williams: Held his ground and was disruptive as well. Played well and looked like a 1st round DT should tonight.

6. Calais Campbell: PB talent and has the tools to be a HOFer if he can stay healthy. Thats a huge leap but I truly believe it.

7. Tim Hightower: Ran beautifully tonight. Was running around people and through people. Was a real pleasure to watch tonight!

8. Derrick Anderson: Made two bad throws tonight and was lucky one wasnt picked off. Other than that he was pretty damn good. lead a nice scoring drive and had some nice touch on a few passes.

9. Max Komar: this kid should absolutely make the final 53. It will be a shame when he doesnt. may be forced to carry 6 WR's and dump one of the QB's.

All of these plus add a Ben Grahamn to the list. Dude is punting at a probowl level again.

 

[Shane]

All of these plus add a Ben Grahamn to the list. Dude is punting at a probowl level again.

He shanked a pretty bad one last night.

 

[MadCardDisease]

He shanked a pretty bad one last night.

I forgot about that. Cut his a$$

 

[Shane]

I forgot about that. Cut his a$$

Yes cut him!

 

[jw7]

Yes cut him!

LOL, I know you and MCD are being sarcastic, but Ben has already had 2 bad plays this preseason.

The dropped snap and the shank.

On the positive (or negative) side, he showed in camp that Andre Roberts can not reliably catch his punts. Which might open up depth for Williams or a shot at roster for Komar.

 

[Cardiac]

LOL, I know you and MCD are being sarcastic, but Ben has already had 2 bad plays this preseason.

The dropped snap and the shank.

On the positive (or negative) side, he showed in camp that Andre Roberts can not reliably catch his punts. Which might open up depth for Williams or a shot at roster for Komar.

Roberts isn't getting cut. There is room for him and Williams on the roster. With the number of nicked up WR's on this team I bet we carry 6 WR's so Komar could make it as well.