A late happy birthday to you, and no 58 is not "old".
Its cool that you can identify with so much of the show. I love the show, but could not identify with it so much. Before Jack Pearson dies, and perhaps other than bringing third Randall into the family as an infant, the Pearsons seem like the standard iconic blue collar American family. The "kids" were raised well into their teens in a comfortable two parent home, and Jack as the dad did a stellar job of keeping the problems of his own childhood experience from invading the home. The characters go though all sorts of problems that life throws at them, but land on their feet in high achieving fashion, Kevin becoming a famous actor, Randall a senator, and even Kate's great success is mentioned in the last episodes. Things don't always work out so nicely in real life, but they did a great job capturing many of lives struggles along the way.
Thx for the bday nod and confirming that I am not an old fart! I should probably clarify a little...specifically the comment about how I "identify" with this incredible show. Perhaps the term, "identify," isn't really the best term here. I certainly didn't grow up in a "standard blue collar American family." My dad left my family when I was just 5 yrs old. My mom was left to raise me and my two younger brothers...so 3 crazy-ass boys boys the oldest being 5 (me). My mom never graduated high school... she was a hair-dresser...and a restaurant hostess. We were dead broke. Moved around a lot. I grew up on welfare and one of the earliest memories I have - aside from watching my dad drive away, thinking he was going on a trip since I can recall helping put stuff into his suitcase... was standing in a grocery store watching my mom dig into her purse to pay for our groceries. She pulled out what I thought were stamps, but she then handed them to the clerk and our groceries were paid for.
Anyway... Randall's actual parents were certainly anything but the "standard blue collar family," his mom unable to be a mom due to her drug addiction, and his father suffering from the same addiction, bringing Randall to the local fire station in hopes he would end up in better conditions...
And though Kevin, Kate & Randall had the foundation of a solid family, there were so many dysfunctional undercurrents that ultimately needed to be dealt with.
The relational issues within the family are things I can relate to/identify with... Overcoming is a theme I can relate to...as no one who knew me as a youngster and knew the conditions of my early childhood would never have expected my life to have turned out the way it did...
The love shared amongst family that is able to weather and survive what feels like insurmountable dysfunction and separation...I can identify with that. When my daughter married a black man from Kenya, I can't begin to describe the firestorm it ignited throughout my family. I didn't speak with my mom and brothers for almost 2 whole years. But remarkably, we've been able to reconnect and though the cracks are still present, we can enjoy one another again...
The sense of loss - when Jack died... or, that feeling Randall always had, knowing his "parents" weren't his real parents and therefore, he had a mom and a dad who gave up on him... I can relate to that as well.
The show is historically popular and to a great extent, it is because there are a multitude of themes and story-lines that are in fact, relatable and identifiable...
Yes, in far too many instances, real life stories don't end up as solid as this story/stories did... But, many sure do... People overcome every day... Maybe they don't become tv stars, or politicians, or enjoy the type of career fulfillment as did Kate (though, there are TONS of very successful people who have overcome unspeakable odds!), but "overcoming" is ultimately a state of being that should only be gauged and enjoyed by the one who has experienced it. We shouldn't judge someone's degree of overcoming...(not saying you are AZ). So for me and apparently a BILLION others, perhaps we can simply relate to dealing with dysfunction in our own respective ways... and, in our own respective ways, overcoming...