Wow, did he hit a nerve or something? To call the PS3 junk compared the the 360 is just stupid. You'll most likely eventually have a problem like everyone else. I've owned both, and finally sold the 360 after sending it in for a second time.
The PS3 is rock solid. Sold it though since I wanted some extra money for a laptop for work, and I'm more of a PC gamer. Wish I didn't because I got a pretty good deal on a Dell, so I'll probably re-buy one once a new bundle is announced.
You have a point but the rest of your statement is completely out of date. Since the Jasper version of the 360 came out there have not been any widespread failure reports. Since that version and the new one will be the only ones in the Retail pipeline, those issues are in the past.
So say "you'll most likely eventually have a problem like everyone else" is just as stupid.
I don't blame you for getting frustrated and selling but clearly the 360 has the better game library and IMO MS (although late) did right by their customers by extending their warranties so those that had older systems could still get repairs for the most common cause of failures.
My console gaming experience has never really been loyal to any system. I was a Ps1 and Ps2 gamer because they had the best library. Now MS does in this generation IMO. In terms of the PC, I have always been a PC gamer as well but I get just as frustrated as you probably did with the XBOX 360 when I have to deal with constant patch cycles, bug fixes etc with PC Games. Plus there are some games in IMO that simply play better on consoles (i.e. sports). I am also getting sick of the PC market coming up with new shader tech every 2 years and then I have to buy another GPU for my PC Rig to take advantage.
Their are definitely advantages and disadvantages to both. I love both PC and console gaming. I have a Wii, Xbox 360 and will probably pick up a PS3 this year because I need an another Blu Ray Player. It's a win win because there are about 4 or 5 games I would love to play on the PS3 which is an added bonus. I will continue to game on my PC but I probably buy about 75% less PC games then I used to.