Cardinals Draft 2010: The Juggle For Needs

Mitch

Crawled Through 5 FB Fields
Joined
Aug 10, 2005
Posts
13,405
Reaction score
2,982
Location
Wrentham, MA
Kent Somers prioritizes the Cardinals' draft needs as follows:

1. ILB

2. NT

3. OLB

4. QB

5. WR

The Cardinals have 5 picks in the first 124: #26, #58, #88, #89 and #124.

Rod Graves has indicated that he's very happy with the depth in the draft at the Cardinals' positions of need.

What that may suggest is that the Cardinals will take the BPA/N...in other words, the best player on the board that addresses one of their needs.

I think we all agree that if Rolando McClain and Sean Weatherspoon don't fall to #26, the Cardinals would likely look to select an ILB later, and the BPA/N would apply.

The five players at #26 that I consider BPA/N talent and impact wise are:

1. Brandon Graham, OLB/DE, Michigan. He is another Lamarr Woodley in the making and would be a stellar addition at SOLB. But, I think that he will be off the board.

2. Jerry Hughes, OLB/DE, TCU. He'd be such a good fit for the Cardinals because he's a left side rusher who could line up opposite Joey Porter. What's amazing about Hughes is that most elite pass rushers are right side (blind side to the QB) rushers. The left side rushers can be seen quicker by the QBs and yet in Hughes' case he converges to the QB so quickly that they have a hard time eluding him.

3. Jared Odrick, DT, Penn. St. The motor on this kid is sensational...not only does he have quick, relentless feet, he's big and strong (6-5, 301). I strongly believe that he would be a major threat at DE, NT and pass rushing DT. He's one of those players who you can line up anywhere and he will create havoc for the offense.

4. Sean Weatherspoon, LB, Missouri. Plays with great intensity, and has the speed and range to deliver tackles from sideline to sideline. He's not as good, IMO, running downhill to the ball, but he's great in coverage, as evidenced by the interception he had in the Senior Bowl when he beat the RB up the right sideline to the ball and intercepted it right inside the pylon.

5. Golden Tate, WR, Notre Dame. Does a superb job of shaking his man and is physical enough to stave him off when the ball is in the air. He is excellent at timing his jumps and catching the ball at its highest point.

I think any of these five players would be a great addition. All of them are NFL ready and can contribute immediately.

WILB candidates beyond the #26:

1. Sean Lee, LB, Penn. St. Another very good player from Linebacker U. Plays smart, instinctively and aggressively. Knee injuries have slowed him, which makes you a little leery.

2. Daryl Washington, LB, TCU. Perhaps the most gifted athlete at ILB in this draft. Can handle all the responsibilities of the position. Has very good range, is a good tackler and has the speed and instincts to be very good in coverage. But, he lacks experience, looks a little slow to react at times, and doesn't have as quick a forward gear as you would hope for.

3. Rennie Curran, LB, Georgia. I think he is one of the most under-rated players in this draft, because he lacks prototypical height and size. But, go watch him play. He played Dansby's WILB spot at Georgia and he has, without a doubt, save perhaps Rolando McClain, the best forward gear of his class. He has a penchant for blowing up plays, because he is extraordinarily quick to react and because he plays a highly physical style. However, because of his forward gear he can bite on play fakes at times, and will need to become more reliable in coverage.

4. Jamar Chaney, LB, Mississippi St. Lacks ideal size but plays fast and tough. Is a tackling machine and a pure sticker in coverage. You do not want to be trying to catch the ball with him in the vacinity. He will lay you out. The issue I saw with him is he's not a great sifter through traffic the way Curran is.

5. Dakota Watson, LB, Florida St. A superb athlete who can play WILB, IMO. He has the best and quickest range of the bunch. Because he played on the edge at FSU, he would have to learn the plug and coverage responsibilities, which may take a little time.

6. Koa Misi, LB, Utah. This guy is the Tasmanian Devil on the football field. He's always around the ball making plays and is exceptionally versatile. He can chase with the best of them, he can apply consistent heat as a pass rusher, he can tackle in space and he has the speed and agility to cover. He's dropped some weight recently which actually may make him even more suited to playing WILB.

7. Pat Angerer, LB, Iowa. Like Rennie Curran is undersized but plays with speed, instincts and toughness. Is very good in coverage.

Again, I would like any of these players...which gives you some flexibility at #58 if you want to wait until the #88 pick to take one them. I think all of them will be there at #88 except perhaps Lee (who still may slide due to his knee issues), Washington (who may slide due to his lack of experience) and Misi (who currently lacks the bulk to be a 3 down edge player).

To me the best and most physcial tackler of this group is Rennie Curran. This kid jacks people up. His lack of height doesn't concern me because he plays must bigger than he is and because it actually helps him sift through traffic quicker. What irked me so much about Karlos Dansby was that he was so slow ansd reluctant to step up on inside runs or to blow up screen and quick hitches to his side. Curran is so quick to the ball and so aggressive that the big plays the Cardinals have given up to the weak side for years now would be significantly fewer. I'd rather have a great tackler at WILB than a so-so tackler who can cover, because I believe that with good coaching Curran, with his speed and aggressiveness should be able to cover any back out of the backfield. And with Henderson in charge of the secondary, the Cardinals will now be shunning the soft zone for a steady diet of aggressive in your face man-to-man...something Curran should be able to handle very well.

For this reason, he's the guy I would take at #88, so that I could take Jerrry Hughes at #26 and address another need at #58.

Let's get the #58 pick. The big question here becomes NT or WR?

If you think, for example, that NT Cam Thomas is head and shoulders better than Linval Joseph, Torrell Troup or Al Woods, then Thomas is your guy at #58. While I like Thomas and thought he played solidly at the Senior Bowl, I like Troup and Woods just as much and I can see them both being available at #89...and even possibly at #124.

This is why I want to grab in impact WR at #58...unless, CB Kareem Jackson of Alabama is on the board. Jackson is the best press CB in this draft and would be perfect fit for Donnie Henderson's style.

The WR I love (second to Golden Tate) is Mardy Gilyard of Cincinnati. This kid is a TD waiting to happen. Just as DRC lit up the Senior Bowl, so did Gilyard. But, the game of Gilyard's that I remember the most is the Pittsburgh game that was, in effect, the Big East Championship game...and it was in late November, it was snowing heavily and the field was slick. The game was somewhat like the Cardinals' Packers' playoff bonanza in that both teams were scoring left and right and the lead was seesawing back and forth. QB Tony Pike was struggling with the conditions...but down the stretch Gilyard took the game over and caught the game winner on a nifty double move sideline pass. He's fast and slithery and sure footed, and can catch seemingly everything thrown in his direction. As he shopwed in the Senior Bowl too, he has an uncanny penchant for slipping behind his CB. Plus, Gilyard is a gifted return man. He averaged 29 yards per kickoff return this past year.

if Gilyard is off the board, there are still some major talents at WR to snag at #58:

1. Damian Williams, USC. NFL ready. Polished and nifty route runner. Excellent hands.

2. Brandon LaFell, LSU. Q Jr.?

3. Dexter McCluster, Mississippi. Greased lightning on a football field. Excellent reurn man as well.

4. Arrelious Benn, Illinois. Great size to speed ratio.

5. Jordan Shipley, Texas. A faster, slightly taller, Wes Welker?

6. Taylor Price, Ohio. A speed burner with good hands.

7. Dezmon Briscoe, Kansas. Clutch WR. Rises to the occasion. A real chain mover.

I would be fine with any of these WRs. I didn't inlcude Demaryious Thomas of GT because I think he will be taken early in the second round. I also think Benn and McCluster will be taken prior to #58. But, I think Gilyard has a chance and if he's there I would do cartwheels.

At #89...here's where I am looking at NT Torrell Troup or Al Woods...but...I think they can still be had in the early or portion of round 4 or at #124 and if we can trade down and recover the 5th round pick we gave up in the Boldin deal, we do it. If we can't trade down we take Troup or Woods.

Why would the #89 pick garner some interest for a trade? It would be the end of the second night and teams with extra picks could easily want to move up to that spot to take a player on the board they think might go in the last few picks of the third round.

So, if a trade can be made...I think we become concerned that overnight teams that want to draft a QB may be looking to draft one in the 4th round, so we take a QB there with the first of our two 4th round picks. The two I like the best at that point are Mike Kafka and Levi Brown. Either one would be fine with me. Then we hope that at #124 Troup or Woods is on the board. I think Woods will be, so he's the pick. If both of them are taken, we look for a CB (Javier Arenas) or DT (Earl Mitchell) here and look to draft a NT like Stanford's Ekom Udofia (6-4, 326) or Georgia's Cade Weston (6-5, 318) in round five or six.

What I would hope for is that we could take Udofia or Weston in round 6 and draft Iowa's ILB A.J. Edds in round 5. Edds may be the best cover ILB in this class, and would be the perfect compliment to Rennie Curran.

As for the 7th round, as I've said, I would love to add the new Sean Morey in Virginia Tech's SS Cody Grimm who would like to say a nice little hello to the likes of Ted Ginn, Jr. and C.J. Spiller.

The Results:

1. Jerry Hughes, OLB, TCU
2. Mardy Gilyard, WR/KR, Cincinnati or Damian Williams, USC
3. Rennie Curran, ILB, Georgia or Jamar Chaney, Mississippi St.
4a. Mike Kafka, QB, Northwestern or Levi Brown, Troy
4b. Javier Arenas, CB/NB/PR, Alabama or Al Woods, NT, LSU
5. A.J. Edds, ILB, Iowa
6. Cade Weston, NT, Georgia
7. Cody Grimm, SS, Virginia Tech

Your thoughts?
 

O

LD @ F.O.H.
LEGACY MEMBER
Joined
Aug 2, 2002
Posts
13,905
Reaction score
5
Location
The Vortex!
I would be very happy with Mardy Gilyard.
 

Cardiac

ASFN Icon
Joined
Jul 21, 2002
Posts
12,062
Reaction score
3,331
That's a LOT of good info Mitch. I gotta believe that the Cards have plans for addressing their needs base on how the draft falls, just like you have done.

My thought process is that WR doesn't need to be addressed in the top 2 rds even though many "experts" say this is where the value for the position will be.

If the Cards take a QB in this draft then I will be okay with it because in Whis I trust. My hopes are that we go UDFA at this position so we can draft a player who should contribute this year.

I'm a fan of both Angerer and Edds.

At this point I'm leaning towards Joeseph at NT in rd 2 and then another power pig in rd 6 or 7. Once again it all depends on how the draft falls.
 
OP
OP
Mitch

Mitch

Crawled Through 5 FB Fields
Joined
Aug 10, 2005
Posts
13,405
Reaction score
2,982
Location
Wrentham, MA
I would be very happy with Mardy Gilyard.

If we loved it when LSH was crying after getting drafted, boy Gilyard may keep the sentiment going. here's a kid who lived out of his car for a year hoping to catch on at Cincinnati. What a rags to riches story this is going to be.

What I love about him, O, is that he's not only very elusive up the sidelines, he's tough as nails over the middle. Plus, his return game is a real bonus.
 
OP
OP
Mitch

Mitch

Crawled Through 5 FB Fields
Joined
Aug 10, 2005
Posts
13,405
Reaction score
2,982
Location
Wrentham, MA
That's a LOT of good info Mitch. I gotta believe that the Cards have plans for addressing their needs base on how the draft falls, just like you have done.

My thought process is that WR doesn't need to be addressed in the top 2 rds even though many "experts" say this is where the value for the position will be.

If the Cards take a QB in this draft then I will be okay with it because in Whis I trust. My hopes are that we go UDFA at this position so we can draft a player who should contribute this year.

I'm a fan of both Angerer and Edds.

At this point I'm leaning towards Joeseph at NT in rd 2 and then another power pig in rd 6 or 7. Once again it all depends on how the draft falls.

The WR situation is a little more needy than we think, Cardiac. Steve Breaston becomes a UFA next year. But, Joseph in round 2 may make sense even though at that point he may be a reach.

Yeah, I like those Hawkeye LBers. Smart and gritty. I also like their CB Amari Spievey.
 

Assface

Like a boss
Supporting Member
Joined
May 6, 2003
Posts
15,106
Reaction score
21
Location
Tempe
As far as the return guys go, I really like McCluster. He's just so explosive. Also, we have so many big WRs on the roster, I think having a little jitterbug slot WR would be a nice complement.
 

Buckybird

Hoist the Lombardi Trophy
Joined
Nov 11, 2002
Posts
25,281
Reaction score
6,230
Location
Dallas, TX
Dang Mitch you covered the full spectrum today, draft day must be approaching.

Didn't see Brandon Spikes on your list of potential picks.:mulli: I luv Gilyard, you must have been looking at some of my earlier posts :D

My possiblities/wishlist for Dday:

1) Hughes-2nd best OLB in the draft, Weatherspoon gone.

2) Spikes-plays faster than his times & produces. Hopefully he's there, will be a stud

3) Gilyard-if he's there in Rd 3 he's the pick. Bigtime producer in the mold of DeSean Jackson. could fall to Rd 3 because of size.

3) Syd'Quan Thompson-dynamic man to man skills, physical tough little man

4) Micah Johnson-replacement for Hayes

6) Levi Brown-I've been touting him since the season ended, maybe drafted in Rd 5

7) Martin Taveaseu-run stuffer deluxe
 

Monty

2010 Cardinals Draft Guru
Joined
Mar 8, 2010
Posts
1,209
Reaction score
0
Your best one yet in my humble opinion and you covered many of the guys i like in this draft. I like Mardy Gilyard a lot as he everything you'd want from a WR speed, good hands, strong after the catch, bounces of tackels, genuine deep threat and a fantastic character. Plus he is excellent in the return game as well. I would love to have him on our team but i cant see where we are gonna draft him. He might be there at ##58 but i just cant see us going WR and there is minimal chance he is there at #88 but if he is i think the Cards should be all over him.
 

Garthshort

ASFN Addict
Joined
Aug 11, 2002
Posts
9,498
Reaction score
5,756
Location
Scarsdale, NY
Mitch, I have two problems with your draft, even though I thought your post, with so much useful info, was great. One I think that the second round is too early to draft a WR (although I know we need one, even with Onrea Jones on the roster), since we have so many defensive needs. And Curren, about the size of Pat Tillman, is too small for LB in the NFL. Sounds like a SS/ST player. Chaney is a couple of inches taller and about 20 lbs. heavier. If we go BPA in the first two rounds, and hopefully we will, I could see an OLB or a CB, before other positions.
 

kerouac9

Klowned by Keim
Joined
Feb 14, 2003
Posts
38,419
Reaction score
29,818
Location
Gilbert, AZ
Both Kafka and Levi Brown are likely going to be undrafted free agents. It would be a mistake to take either of them before the sixth round, if then. Neither of those guys started more than 15 games in college.

I don't think that there will be more than a dozen quarterbacks taken in this draft. There will be 8-12 perfectly good prospects available once the draft is complete that would be just as good as those two.
 
OP
OP
Mitch

Mitch

Crawled Through 5 FB Fields
Joined
Aug 10, 2005
Posts
13,405
Reaction score
2,982
Location
Wrentham, MA
Mitch, I have two problems with your draft, even though I thought your post, with so much useful info, was great. One I think that the second round is too early to draft a WR (although I know we need one, even with Onrea Jones on the roster), since we have so many defensive needs. And Curren, about the size of Pat Tillman, is too small for LB in the NFL. Sounds like a SS/ST player. Chaney is a couple of inches taller and about 20 lbs. heavier. If we go BPA in the first two rounds, and hopefully we will, I could see an OLB or a CB, before other positions.

My thinking, Garth, was that I like Mardy Gilyard so much that he wouldn't make it to #88...and when you like a player that much you are willing to make the pick. Plus, because I like Curran so much, I am confident that he will be there at #88.

As for Curran, he has been training like a madman with a high-profile trainer in Georgia and is up to 238. He led the SEC in tackles last year with 130 (Chaney had 98) and what jumps out when you see him play is how hard he hits...he fires his hips into the tackles, lays heavy wood and finishes up with a flourish. He is a sticker deluxe...has a real seek and destroy type mentality. And what I like best about him is that he meets the RB at the line of scrimmage (which is where he makes most of his tackles)...no hesitation, no dilly dallying, his forward gear is outstanding.

I want a great tackler for once in the middle of our defense...someone who will blow up plays before they get started. This kid is a great tackler.
 
OP
OP
Mitch

Mitch

Crawled Through 5 FB Fields
Joined
Aug 10, 2005
Posts
13,405
Reaction score
2,982
Location
Wrentham, MA
Both Kafka and Levi Brown are likely going to be undrafted free agents. It would be a mistake to take either of them before the sixth round, if then. Neither of those guys started more than 15 games in college.

I don't think that there will be more than a dozen quarterbacks taken in this draft. There will be 8-12 perfectly good prospects available once the draft is complete that would be just as good as those two.

I guarantee you, K9, both Kafka and Brown will be drafted. Not only did Kafka draw raves with his play at the East-West, his Pro Day was outstanding. The Raiders flew him in for a visit recently. He will go in the 4th or 5th, and Brown will go in the 6th or 7th.
 

Buckybird

Hoist the Lombardi Trophy
Joined
Nov 11, 2002
Posts
25,281
Reaction score
6,230
Location
Dallas, TX
Mitch do you not think the Cards have any interest in Spikes potentially in Rd 2? I didnt see you mention him. I would run to the podium if he were there in Rd2.
 

Duckjake

LEGACY MEMBER
LEGACY MEMBER
Joined
Jun 10, 2002
Posts
32,190
Reaction score
317
Location
Texas
Jordan Shipley, Texas. A faster, slightly taller, Wes Welker?

Could be. Even though everyone knew McCoy was looking for Shipley on almost any pass play defenses still couldn't stop him. The kid just has a knack for getting open.

Jordan even had two TD catches against Alabama with Texas' true freshman QB throwing the ball.
 
OP
OP
Mitch

Mitch

Crawled Through 5 FB Fields
Joined
Aug 10, 2005
Posts
13,405
Reaction score
2,982
Location
Wrentham, MA
Mitch do you not think the Cards have any interest in Spikes potentially in Rd 2? I didnt see you mention him. I would run to the podium if he were there in Rd2.

I would think so, Bucky, as Hayes' eventual replacement. They way things are looking, Spikes may be available at #88. At that point he would be a steal and I think the Cardinals would have DRC sprint the card to the podium in 4.29 seconds flat.
 

kerouac9

Klowned by Keim
Joined
Feb 14, 2003
Posts
38,419
Reaction score
29,818
Location
Gilbert, AZ
I guarantee you, K9, both Kafka and Brown will be drafted. Not only did Kafka draw raves with his play at the East-West, his Pro Day was outstanding. The Raiders flew him in for a visit recently. He will go in the 4th or 5th, and Brown will go in the 6th or 7th.

Well, how many quarterbacks do you honestly think are going to get drafted this year? Four will go in the first two rounds, right? Bradford, Clausen, Tebow, and McCoy. Tony Pike, Dan LeFevour, Jarret Brown, Zac Robinson, and Sean Canfield are almost certainly draftable prospects--that's five more. Add in John Skelton, Jonathon Crompton, and Jevan Snead--two of those three will almost certainly be drafted.

That's eleven quarterbacks whom I think we can agree will probably be drafted ahead of Kafka or Brown, right? Would you take all of them ahead of those two guys? I would.

From 2005-2009, an average of 12 QBs have been drafted every year. Want to know how many of those 62 QBs went in the 1st round? 13.

In the 2nd? 8.

In the 3rd? 7.

In the 4th? 4.

Rounds 6 & 7? 18.

Find me five QBs in the past 5 years who were drafted in rounds 3-5 who have amounted to anything. You'll find more on practice squads or out of the NFL altogether.

This QB class is seen as being below average. It's hard to think we'll see more QBs going higher this year than in the last half-decade.
 
OP
OP
Mitch

Mitch

Crawled Through 5 FB Fields
Joined
Aug 10, 2005
Posts
13,405
Reaction score
2,982
Location
Wrentham, MA
Well, how many quarterbacks do you honestly think are going to get drafted this year? Four will go in the first two rounds, right? Bradford, Clausen, Tebow, and McCoy. Tony Pike, Dan LeFevour, Jarret Brown, Zac Robinson, and Sean Canfield are almost certainly draftable prospects--that's five more. Add in John Skelton, Jonathon Crompton, and Jevan Snead--two of those three will almost certainly be drafted.

That's eleven quarterbacks whom I think we can agree will probably be drafted ahead of Kafka or Brown, right? Would you take all of them ahead of those two guys? I would.

From 2005-2009, an average of 12 QBs have been drafted every year. Want to know how many of those 62 QBs went in the 1st round? 13.

In the 2nd? 8.

In the 3rd? 7.

In the 4th? 4.

Rounds 6 & 7? 18.

Find me five QBs in the past 5 years who were drafted in rounds 3-5 who have amounted to anything. You'll find more on practice squads or out of the NFL altogether.

This QB class is seen as being below average. It's hard to think we'll see more QBs going higher this year than in the last half-decade.

You make great points, K9. I have been reading every 7 round mock draft I can get my hands on and all of them have Mike Kafka and Levi Brown in them and in all cases before round 7. One of them on draftsite.com has the cardinals taking taking Levi Brown in the 4th round. Another one has Mike Kafka going to the Raiders in the early 4th round. That doesn't mean the mocks are right, but there has been enough buzz around these two young QBs that I feel 100% sure they both will be drafted with one or possibly both going as early as the 4th round.

If I am wrong, I will give you a ton of credit.
 
OP
OP
Mitch

Mitch

Crawled Through 5 FB Fields
Joined
Aug 10, 2005
Posts
13,405
Reaction score
2,982
Location
Wrentham, MA
I think Kafka & Brown get drafted also.

I think too that if it had been a normal year and some of the UFA QBs had been able to sign with other teams, there'd be less of a demand to draft QBs.

Plus, now team have to worry about players leaving next year when they would finally become unrestricted.

Teams that most likely would be interested in drafting a QB: Rams, Browns, Raiders, Bills, Broncos, Jaguars, 49ers, Seahawks, Giants, Titans, Steelers, Patriots, Eagles, Ravens, Cardinals, Cowboys, Chargers, Vikings, Colts, Saints, Panthers.

That's 21 teams and a strong case can be made for all of them, primarily because these teams could well be losing QBs next year or in the case of the Rams, Browns, Broncos, Giants, Eagles, Chargers, Cardinals, Colts and Panthers have released or traded away one of their QBs this year...or, alas, lost a QB to retirement.
 

kerouac9

Klowned by Keim
Joined
Feb 14, 2003
Posts
38,419
Reaction score
29,818
Location
Gilbert, AZ
You make great points, K9. I have been reading every 7 round mock draft I can get my hands on and all of them have Mike Kafka and Levi Brown in them and in all cases before round 7. One of them on draftsite.com has the cardinals taking taking Levi Brown in the 4th round. Another one has Mike Kafka going to the Raiders in the early 4th round. That doesn't mean the mocks are right, but there has been enough buzz around these two young QBs that I feel 100% sure they both will be drafted with one or possibly both going as early as the 4th round.

If I am wrong, I will give you a ton of credit.

The current mock on DraftSite.com has the Cards taking Jarret Brown in the 4th. That draft also has an unprecedented 20 quarterbacks being drafted (!). In one of the shallowest QB classes in recent memory.

I think Kafka & Brown get drafted also.

Even if those guys end up getting drafted, that doesn't mean they'll get drafted in the 4th. I don't mind taking a QB late in the draft as a developmental prospect; I think it's a good idea to do that every three or four seasons. But it doesn't make sense to pass up a guy who will actually be able to play at some point in the next two seasons for some scrub who only played for a year or two like those guys.

I hope that Kafka and Brown get drafted in the 4th. That means that more good players are going to get down to us, or another quality, experienced quarterback prospect will be available in the last two rounds or undrafted.

For me, there's little to no difference between Kafka and Brown and any other of the lowly-regarded quarterback prospects I mentioned above. Mitch, you've been in love with a half-dozen QB prospects who won't be taken in the first four rounds this draft. Is is really important whether it's Kafka, Levi Brown, Jevan Snead, or Armanti Edwards? One of those guys is going to slip to the 6th.
 
OP
OP
Mitch

Mitch

Crawled Through 5 FB Fields
Joined
Aug 10, 2005
Posts
13,405
Reaction score
2,982
Location
Wrentham, MA
The current mock on DraftSite.com has the Cards taking Jarret Brown in the 4th. That draft also has an unprecedented 20 quarterbacks being drafted (!). In one of the shallowest QB classes in recent memory.



Even if those guys end up getting drafted, that doesn't mean they'll get drafted in the 4th. I don't mind taking a QB late in the draft as a developmental prospect; I think it's a good idea to do that every three or four seasons. But it doesn't make sense to pass up a guy who will actually be able to play at some point in the next two seasons for some scrub who only played for a year or two like those guys.

I hope that Kafka and Brown get drafted in the 4th. That means that more good players are going to get down to us, or another quality, experienced quarterback prospect will be available in the last two rounds or undrafted.

For me, there's little to no difference between Kafka and Brown and any other of the lowly-regarded quarterback prospects I mentioned above. Mitch, you've been in love with a half-dozen QB prospects who won't be taken in the first four rounds this draft. Is is really important whether it's Kafka, Levi Brown, Jevan Snead, or Armanti Edwards? One of those guys is going to slip to the 6th.

Did you see my previous post where I made the case for 21 teams to draft QBs because of the lack of movement in free agency? I do think that because of this year there will be more QBs taken than usual...even despite this being a less than stellar class.

If the Cardinals do wait until the 6th round I do hope, K9 that one of those 4 QBs is there. I'd be happy with that. But, this is where not having a 5th round pick is dicey. You don't want to spend a 4th on these guys but you risk losing the ones you like best by wating from pick #124 to pick #195...that's 71 picks. And in my case, I like Kafka more than enough to take him at #124 because I am 100% sure he won't be there at #195.

Armanti Edwards is more of a project and a potential combo #3 QB, RB, KR, slot WR. But because of his speed and versatility I think he'll be taken in the 4th-5th rounds.

Jevan Snead, because of his accuracy (most accurate QB at the Combine) and his intriguing arm strength will, IMO, go somewhere in the 100-150 range.

Levi Brown might make it to #195, but even that I doubt.
 
OP
OP
Mitch

Mitch

Crawled Through 5 FB Fields
Joined
Aug 10, 2005
Posts
13,405
Reaction score
2,982
Location
Wrentham, MA
Nice job Mitch, thanks for the great write up!

Thanks, CT. What's your Cardinals' choices? I'd be very interested to know.

I must say it felt good to hear Harry say that he thinks Jared Odrick can play NT, because I and others have been saying this. I think he could wreak havoc in the middle. But, you don't draft him at #26 to be a backup DE like Alan Branch who you traded up to #33 for three years ago.
 

Stout

Hold onto the ball, Murray!
Joined
Dec 30, 2002
Posts
39,805
Reaction score
24,008
Location
Pittsburgh, PA--Enemy territory!
Mitch, that was an incredible post with lots of good info. I agree with almost all of what you wrote. The big disagreement I have is with a player that I really would love us to have--Odrick. What disagreement? He would be one hell of a 3-4 DE, but aside from the odd 3rd and long situation, he would never line up at NT for us. In no way, shape or form is he a NT.
 

kerouac9

Klowned by Keim
Joined
Feb 14, 2003
Posts
38,419
Reaction score
29,818
Location
Gilbert, AZ
I can't believe that I'm going to waste time responding to this...

I think too that if it had been a normal year and some of the UFA QBs had been able to sign with other teams, there'd be less of a demand to draft QBs.

Plus, now team have to worry about players leaving next year when they would finally become unrestricted.

Teams that most likely would be interested in drafting a QB: Rams, Browns, Raiders, Bills, Broncos, Jaguars, 49ers, Seahawks, Giants, Titans, Steelers, Patriots, Eagles, Ravens, Cardinals, Cowboys, Chargers, Vikings, Colts, Saints, Panthers.

That's 21 teams and a strong case can be made for all of them, primarily because these teams could well be losing QBs next year or in the case of the Rams, Browns, Broncos, Giants, Eagles, Chargers, Cardinals, Colts and Panthers have released or traded away one of their QBs this year...or, alas, lost a QB to retirement.

Rams - Sam Bradford. That's one.
Browns - They'll probably take Colt McCoy. That's two.
Raiders - I think it's 50/50 they take a top QB, but I'll give it to you. That's three.
Bills - They'll take Tebow if they can go up and get him, but I don't think they'll move for any of the lesser prospects, because they're no better than Edwards. That's the four top guys.
Broncos - Drafted Bradstater last season and still have Orton and now Quinn. There's no way they're drafting a QB; they don't have room on the roster.
Jaguars - Invested a ton of money in David Garrard, and those guys are still in positions of power. Their #2 is Luke McCown. They will likely take a run at one of the mid-round guys. That's' five.
49ers - Huh? They just drafted Nate Davis, they have Alex Smith, and they just signed David Carr. Again, there's no room on the roster.
Seahawks - They just gave $10 million to Charlie Whitehurst and drafted Mike Teel in the 5th round last year. No chance.
Giants - They gave $100 million to Eli, just traded for Jim Sorgi, and drafte Rhett Bomar in the 5th last season. Honestly, Mitch. You could have found these things out for yourself.
Titans - Vince Young is in place, and behind him they have Chris Simms and Kerry Collins. There's some possibility they'll draft a quarterback. That's six.
Steelers - They have Ben Roethlisberger and just re-signed Chaz Batch. They also really, really like 2008 5th-round pick Dennis Dixon. So there's no chance there, either
Patriots - Tom Brady's in place. They've been developing Brian Hoyer for the last two years, and he completed 70% of his passes in limited playing time last year. It's unlikely they'll go with another rookie; they're more likely to look for a veteran #3 like Brian St. Pierre.
Eagles - Definitely potential for a mid- to late-round guy here. That's seven.
Ravens - Got John Beck from the Dolphins last season. Even if Troy Smith leaves, they're not going to carry 4 QBs on the roster this season.
Cardinals - There's some chance they'll take a late-round prospect, but they have two players with starting experience, and at least one of them are going to be on the roster next year. That's eight.
Cowboys - have Romo in place and drafted Stephen McGee in the 4th round last year. No chance.
Chargers - There's some chance of a late-round player after they let Whitehurst leave. That's nine.
Vikings - LOL. They traded for Sage Rosenfels and still have Tavaris Jackson on the roster. If they wanted a developmental guy, they would have kept John David Booty.
Colts - Drafted Painter with a 6th round pick last season. If they need competition for Drew Willy, they'll bring in another undrafted guy.
Saints - Picked up UDFA Chase Daniel last year. They won't invest another draft pick at the position.
Panthers - They have three picks in the first four rounds, and five picks in the last two. They'll maybe use one pick on a developmental guy, but not until 175th overall. That's ten.

So you're looking at ten quarterbacks, maximum being drafted. So 10 quarterbacks, eleven prospects not counting Kafka and Brown. Want to make a bet about how many quarterbacks get drafted?
 
Last edited:

Staff online

Forum statistics

Threads
553,882
Posts
5,412,410
Members
6,319
Latest member
route66
Top