Cards Wining and Dining Nick Bosa

Joined
Nov 15, 2002
Posts
13,301
Reaction score
1,175
Location
SE Valley
Nope. Rosen was historically awful last year and every other comparable QB has not been a top QB in the NFL.

Facts.

I'm not sure if the above post was Krang "trolling" or he thought he was stating facts. But I didn't have to look far (first one I thought of).

NFL QB whose first season in the NFL was statistically worse than Rosen's rookie stats. This QB went on to have a pretty successful career. As a bonus I also included stats from this QB's second season in the NFL, in which his stats were still equivalent with Rosen last season.

Code:
ROSEN
   G    GS    Comp    Att    Pct      Yds       Avg   TD    Int    Sck    SckY    Rate
  14   13    217     393    55.2    2,278   5.8    11    14    45    320     66.7
 
OTHER
  11   --     155     293     52.9   1,749   6.0     9     18    19   155     55.7
 
15     --      226    399    56.6    2,579   6.5    11    18    39   288     66.6

The OTHER QB in the above stat chart -
Troy Aikman

I am not intending to imply that Rosen's career will come close to that of the other QB, the point is we simply don't know yet. But I saw enough last year to suggest it would be foolhardy to prematurely quit on Rosen. . .
 
Last edited:

Krangodnzr

Captain of Team Conner
Joined
Jul 21, 2002
Posts
36,490
Reaction score
34,466
Location
Charlotte, NC
I'm not sure if the above post was Krang "trolling" or he thought he was stating facts. But I didn't have to look far (first one I thought of).

NFL QB whose first season in the NFL was statistically worse than Rosen's rookie stats. This QB went on to have a pretty successful career. As a bonus I also included stats from this QB's second season in the NFL, in which his stats were still equivalent with Rosen last season.

Code:
ROSEN
   G    GS    Comp    Att    Pct      Yds       Avg   TD    Int    Sck    SckY    Rate
  14   13    217     393    55.2    2,278   5.8    11    14    45    320     66.7
 
OTHER
  11   --     155     293     52.9   1,749   6.0     9     18    19   155     55.7
 
15     --      226    399    56.6    2,579   6.5    11    18    39   288     66.6

The OTHER QB in the above stat chart -
Troy Aikman

I am not intending to imply that Rosen's career with come close to that of the other QB, the point is we simply don't know yet. But I saw enough last year to suggest it would be foolhardy to prematurely quit on Rosen. . .

Totally different era. You cant compare stats from 30 years ago to today.
 

MrYeahBut

4 Food groups: beans, chili, cheese, bacon
Supporting Member
Joined
May 20, 2002
Posts
17,859
Reaction score
13,480
Location
Albq
Very good??? 88.5 rating is not "very good".

This is what I'm talking about. For Rosen last year, very good was an average to below average game.


For most of us who watched the entire excruciating season, except for a few really good throws, we could classify, let's just say Josh was average for a rookie on a bad team. Rosen didn't have much going for him with either the line play, WRs, his team mates or coaching. Could he have shown better? Yes, imo and I think he will be better this season. I've going to stay in my lane, bro. No one is a sure thing but I've decided to go with those that say Keep Rosen, draft Bosa.... In case anyone is interested in keeping score so those of us who deserve it can be laughed at later. Once you've had colon surgery as I have with Dr's and nurses poking you just about anywhere you wouldn't want to be poked, you learn a sense of humility to where being laughed at is easy money.... Child's play actually.

In a spirit of further humiliation, I present a feeble attempt at Haiku

. Murray In The Wings.
. Bosa Taken As The Pick.
. Cry For The Children.

.
I won't quit my day job.
 

Brian in Mesa

Advocatus Diaboli
Super Moderator
Moderator
Supporting Member
Joined
May 13, 2002
Posts
72,792
Reaction score
24,413
Location
Killjoy Central
Nope. Rosen was historically awful last year and every other comparable QB has not been a top QB in the NFL.

Facts.

Historically awful?

Better rookie year than Aikman. Similar QB's of similar size (and from UCLA). Aikman got better as they placed other pieces around him.
 

GatorAZ

feed hopkins
Joined
Oct 17, 2011
Posts
25,467
Reaction score
18,374
Location
The Giant Toaster
Can we stop talking about Murray in this thread and, instead, talk about the prospect of Chandler Jones and Nick Bosa averaging 25 sacks per game if paired together?

Bosa has a high/safe floor. I think it would be the equivalent of Chandler Jomes/Mario Williams duo which you can sign me up for right now.
 

blindseyed

I'm saying you ARE stuck in Wichita
Joined
Mar 20, 2003
Posts
7,945
Reaction score
5,656
Location
Verrado
Well, yeah, the guy is a midget (a very talented midget)... but of course what would you expect given his height, any midget comment falls short lol
That's a wee bit overboard taking a miniscule part of the meaning and diminishing the tiny fact that being under sized is just short--sighted ...:)
 

Staff online

Forum statistics

Threads
553,717
Posts
5,410,922
Members
6,319
Latest member
route66
Top