Originally posted by Alphaman
It's interesting how fans view the same players. I'd say that 70% of Chiefs fans prefer Gary over Jones. The general perception is that Jones is a bust because he couldn't produce behind the Cardinals' massive offensive line. I am in the minority amongst my Chiefs brethern. I'd prefer Jones and by a wide margin.
Oh I agree.
Gary is obviously a product of the system with Denver, and has had a few injuries lately. Gary was a slowish back to begin with, and from what I hear he is now a very slow back.
Jones' main problem is: he has terrible run vision. Watching Shipp vs. Jones and you can tell that a) Jones is more physically talented b) Shipp is more mentally talented. Jones, imo, will never be a great NFL back because he lacks the instincts. Shipp will be better (and he was head and shoulders better than Jones) but he lacks the speed to be an elite back.
Gary won't be able to provide the big plays that Jones will, but he would probably be a little more consistent on a run-to-run basis.