BuckeyeCardinal
Cantankerous Curmudgeon
- Joined
- Jan 8, 2003
- Posts
- 2,252
- Reaction score
- 0
Just wonderin.
Eli Manning or Josh McCown?
- Thread starter BuckeyeCardinal
- Start date
LVCARDFREAK
In the league 20 years!
Gimme Eli!
OP
OP
BuckeyeCardinal
Cantankerous Curmudgeon
- Joined
- Jan 8, 2003
- Posts
- 2,252
- Reaction score
- 0
Well
Since someone in another thread said Josh was better than Eli I'll make it simple for ya.
Who would would you rather have as a QB?
You can't have both....and don't get so caught up in next year....think about who you think will be the best NFL QB.
Since someone in another thread said Josh was better than Eli I'll make it simple for ya.
Who would would you rather have as a QB?
You can't have both....and don't get so caught up in next year....think about who you think will be the best NFL QB.
LVCARDFREAK
In the league 20 years!
spanky1
Registered User
This is Buckeye Cardinals' way of avoiding responding to my post on the Mock Draft post earlier.......
- Joined
- Jan 2, 2003
- Posts
- 91,430
- Reaction score
- 68,612
Originally posted by LVCARDFREAK
I second that. I'd rather take Eli over Josh -but whatever decision Dennis Green makes in that regard I will have to trust - the guy's done more with over-the hill and even bad QBs than anyone I can ever remember.
I say both we have McCown but we can draft Eli and he can start next year.
OP
OP
BuckeyeCardinal
Cantankerous Curmudgeon
- Joined
- Jan 8, 2003
- Posts
- 2,252
- Reaction score
- 0
What?
I just responded dude.
Currently Eli is ahead 7-4......those 4 would rather have Josh as QB.....I respect their opinion and hope they're correct cause we won't get or won't draft Eli anyway.
I just responded dude.
Currently Eli is ahead 7-4......those 4 would rather have Josh as QB.....I respect their opinion and hope they're correct cause we won't get or won't draft Eli anyway.
OP
OP
BuckeyeCardinal
Cantankerous Curmudgeon
- Joined
- Jan 8, 2003
- Posts
- 2,252
- Reaction score
- 0
Re: What?
OOps.....make it 11-4 Eli ahead....must be 11 idiots voting.
OOps.....make it 11-4 Eli ahead....must be 11 idiots voting.
You guys can laugh at Ryans comments all you want but it really does make some semblence of sense.
Josh has shown an ability at this level in his last four games.
Can you honestly say that Eli has shown any level of ability at the NFL level? NO!
Most of you are going on name recognition which is fine. But if the exact same person in the exact same body had the exact same stats in college and didnt have a dad and brother named Manning how many of you would be harping on drafting him if he was Billy Jones????
If I had to guess not near as many!
McCown has all the physical tools to be able to suucceed at this level. Time will tell and I have faith in Greens ability to judge a QB!
Josh has shown an ability at this level in his last four games.
Can you honestly say that Eli has shown any level of ability at the NFL level? NO!
Most of you are going on name recognition which is fine. But if the exact same person in the exact same body had the exact same stats in college and didnt have a dad and brother named Manning how many of you would be harping on drafting him if he was Billy Jones????
If I had to guess not near as many!
McCown has all the physical tools to be able to suucceed at this level. Time will tell and I have faith in Greens ability to judge a QB!
OP
OP
BuckeyeCardinal
Cantankerous Curmudgeon
- Joined
- Jan 8, 2003
- Posts
- 2,252
- Reaction score
- 0
Yes
"McCown has all the physical tools to be able to suucceed at this level. Time will tell and I have faith in Greens ability to judge a QB!"
Yes it will.
But if we have a chance to pick Eli and/or Ben and we pass and if Josh sucks then I'll tell ya straight up that our talent evaluators are not of NFL caliber.
"McCown has all the physical tools to be able to suucceed at this level. Time will tell and I have faith in Greens ability to judge a QB!"
Yes it will.
But if we have a chance to pick Eli and/or Ben and we pass and if Josh sucks then I'll tell ya straight up that our talent evaluators are not of NFL caliber.
spanky1
Registered User
Re: Well
It was I....Spanky.....and I didn't say Josh was better, I said he was just as talented. Gheeez, Buckeye Cardinal, if you are going to "report, "report" accurately.
It was I....Spanky.....and I didn't say Josh was better, I said he was just as talented. Gheeez, Buckeye Cardinal, if you are going to "report, "report" accurately.
OP
OP
BuckeyeCardinal
Cantankerous Curmudgeon
- Joined
- Jan 8, 2003
- Posts
- 2,252
- Reaction score
- 0
Re: Re: Well
Shiet or get off the pot O'Spanky....if both are equal who would ya pick my Celtic brother?
Shiet or get off the pot O'Spanky....if both are equal who would ya pick my Celtic brother?
OP
OP
BuckeyeCardinal
Cantankerous Curmudgeon
- Joined
- Jan 8, 2003
- Posts
- 2,252
- Reaction score
- 0
Re: Re: Yes
So if Mannings there we pass on him?
So if Mannings there we pass on him?
az jam
ASFN Icon
(remember I'm the guy that spent 10 years in Minneapolis and am now retired and here in Scottsdale).
Go with McCown and draft one of the blue chippers! Denny will build a play off team here and does not need a super star as his qb. He always said its the offense system not the qb. Starters at Minnesota included a young Gannon, over the hill McMahon, Sailisbury, Warren Moon, Brad Johnsons, R. Cunningham, Jeff George, Duante Culpepper (I know I missed some).
McCown and King will do fine with Denny's system. We certainly don't need to waste the #3 pick on Manning (or Roethlisberger).
Pick Fitzgerald or Mike Williams and we will have a hell of a potent offense.
Go with McCown and draft one of the blue chippers! Denny will build a play off team here and does not need a super star as his qb. He always said its the offense system not the qb. Starters at Minnesota included a young Gannon, over the hill McMahon, Sailisbury, Warren Moon, Brad Johnsons, R. Cunningham, Jeff George, Duante Culpepper (I know I missed some).
McCown and King will do fine with Denny's system. We certainly don't need to waste the #3 pick on Manning (or Roethlisberger).
Pick Fitzgerald or Mike Williams and we will have a hell of a potent offense.
OP
OP
BuckeyeCardinal
Cantankerous Curmudgeon
- Joined
- Jan 8, 2003
- Posts
- 2,252
- Reaction score
- 0
Re: Re: Re: Re: Yes
Ballsy call....so we get Fitz?
Ballsy call....so we get Fitz?
spanky1
Registered User
Re: Re: Re: Well
Well if both were equal......and the operative word here is equal, well the I'd take McCown......and I'd use the draft choice elsewhere.
Remember, your question is....if they are both equal.
Let's get back to posting and not inflaming.....gheez
Well if both were equal......and the operative word here is equal, well the I'd take McCown......and I'd use the draft choice elsewhere.
Remember, your question is....if they are both equal.
Let's get back to posting and not inflaming.....gheez
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Yes
Nope my ideal situation would be to trade down a few spots to say 5-7 and draft Sean Taylor. Then Take a CB in the first pick of round 2 hopefully Strait from OK will still be on the board.
That would immediately sure up the secondary and make this defense compete with the big boys.
Nope my ideal situation would be to trade down a few spots to say 5-7 and draft Sean Taylor. Then Take a CB in the first pick of round 2 hopefully Strait from OK will still be on the board.
That would immediately sure up the secondary and make this defense compete with the big boys.
spanky1
Registered User
Re: Re: Re: Yes
Well, you know my answer!
Well, you know my answer!
My thoughts exactly, in todays NFL you don't need a superstar at QB to win. Add Fitz or M Williams giving McCown more weapons and just let this teamsoffense take off. McCown has as much bust potential as Manning. Lets just let McCown do his thing,he's had time to get used to the speed of the NFL game, He has had 2 years to learn. Now its time for McCown to show his stuff
az jam
ASFN Icon
If Manning is there we trade down if we can get a good deal.
