Okay... I think you somehow missed the entire point of my argument above. So, let's try this one last time. Trying to be super clear here:
Your argument is that motion offenses don't need the PG to create for everyone else, right? And your evidence is that it worked for the Triangle and Popovich. Is that right?
If so,I don't begrudge your first statement. Pop and the Triangle did work.
My argument is that I believe those offenses didn't need the PG to be the one guy who creates because those offenses had multiple high level creators... the Bulls with Jordan and Pippen during their first 3-peat and then Jordan, Pippen and Kukoc for their second. Meanwhile, Avery Johnson (who was a pure PG), Duncan and Robinson could all create for themselves and others during their first title and then Duncan, Parker and Ginobli did so for the dynasty Spurs.
Again, those teams you mentioned who were successful with motion offenses had multiple next level creators, most of which were also HOF level players which why it was possible for them to run offenses without one guy who creates for everyone else. We don't have that. We have Booker, who right now is a great creator of his own offense and has shown good playmaking abilities for teammates. And that it's it right now. I hope that one day Booker can reach Jordan's level of offense creating for others like he did when he was running the Triangle and that Josh Jackson can reach a Pippen-level of creation on offense... or that Ayton can reach Duncan's ability to create offense for himself and others. Because to run offenses like Pop or Phil did, you're going to need at least 2 of those 3 to happen, if not all 3. Fortunately, I DO think that in a perfect world, or even somewhat perfect world, those days CAN happen. Unfortunately, I don't think those days are happening this season. We might see flashes of it, but sustained success isn't coming down the pike for a couple years, IMO.
Does that make sense? I just think it's extremely hard to say Igor's offense can work right now because he doesn't have multiple next-level playmakers needed at different positions which would allow his motion offense to follow in Pop or Phil's footsteps.