Sigh.
The other thing for me is that I think that turnover fatigue is really starting to fit in. For a long time, you could argue that the departures of guys like Ray Thompson, L.J. Shelton, Ronald McKinnon, Kyle Vanden Bosch, Marcel Shipp, etc., were good for the team because whomever replaces them couldn't possibly be worse than the guys who left. Even David Boston probably wore out his welcome here, and Thomas Jones was never going to get used the right way here or been motivated to be the player he became after he left.
I was even willing to give the new coaching staff the benefit of the doubt on Leonard Davis, because Russ Grimm came in with such a great rep. Five years later, it seems pretty clear that Davis was exactly what this team looks for in a LT (big, doesn't have to run much), and we wasted five years trying to get Levi Brown as good as Leonard Davis at either tackle position (and he's still not there).
But in the last two years we've seen good players leave for nothing and they were replaced with players who were inferior. My favorite players on the Super Bowl team were Dansby, Fitz, Dockett, Wilson, and Deuce. I bought a Matt Leinart jersey the day that we drafted him, and a Rolle jersey was my first "new" jersey. Dominique Rodgers-Cromartie was my wife's favorite player and electrifying to watch his first two seasons.
Now two of my favorite players are gone, Wilson is clearly on the downside of his career, and Deuce is riding pine for a guy who was at best non-descript in the preseason and wasn't good enough to start last year. This coaching staff has no credibility with me on the issue of player acquisition and development. I can't get excited for Kevin Kolb until he actually does something against someone good (completing 62% of his passes and moving the offense Sunday would be a good start) and I'm skeptical of Daryl Washington in this system right now (BTW--there would probably no bigger beneficiary of a Tampa-2 conversion than Washington; this coaching staff continues to try and fit square pegs into round holes). Calais Campbell is poised to leave in free agency next year.
Oh, and Dan Williams is fat and getting pushed for playing time by a 7th round pick from UCLA who wasn't even listed in a ton of draft guides. Every unknown draft pick can't be a steal, and it's frequently a bad sign when all of your draft picks make the roster.
I don't think that an 8-8 record wins the division this year, and I think that people are criminally underrating the 49ers. Alex Smith is an average quarterback right now by all statistical measures, and he does have weapons in the passing game in Crabtree, Edwards, and Vernon Davis. They play their toughest AFC North games (Baltimore and Pittsburgh) at home this year.
The "All In" Arizona Cardinals could end up in 3rd place in the NFC West, and I'm not looking forward to the litany of excuses that will come mid-season (lockout, Kolb's still becoming familiar with the offense, injuries in the secondary, new Defensive Coordinator, Joey Porter is at least trying hard, etc., etc.).