McCarthy will be available. Anyone interested?

[TJ]

Mike McCarthy (GB)
Wins - 125
Losses - 75
Ties - 2
Win Pct. - .624
Playoff wins - 10
Playoff Losses - 8
Super Bowl wins - 1
QB-Aaron Rodgers

Sean Payton (NO)
Wins - 113
Losses - 72
Ties - 0
Win Pct. - .611
Playoff wins - 7
Playoff Losses - 5
Super Bowl wins - 1
QB-Drew Brees

Show me where the great discrepancy is. Similar won/loss record, similar playoff record, same number of SB wins, and two great QBs. What makes Payton all that much better than McCarthy

How about this: Neither are very good coaches and shouldn’t be considered for anything more than a coordinator position.

Funny how one can win 60% of their games with a first-ballot HoFer behind center.

 

[DVontel]

Difference between Payton & McCarthy right now is eye for talent. Saints arguably had 1 of the best drafts I have ever seen in 2017 while the Packers’ draft have been kind of lackluster for a while now.

 

[Willie D]

Since we are dreaming - I’ll take W. Phillips as DC

That would be great, except I don't think Wade is in danger of being unemployed soon. If he is in fact, someone should whack Stan Cranky upside the head.

[dispatch] 1-Adam-12, domestic dispute, L.A. Coliseum
[1-Adam-12] Someone fired Wade Phillips
[dispatch] 1-Adam-12, sometime ya just don't have to teach stupid.

 

[PACardsFan]

If we want Wade that badly, we’d have to hire him as the HC. And we don’t want that.

 

[cardpa]

Difference between Payton & McCarthy right now is eye for talent. Saints arguably had 1 of the best drafts I have ever seen in 2017 while the Packers’ draft have been kind of lackluster for a while now.

I would think the GMs and scouts might have an impact on the draft even more than the HC.

 

[cardpa]

How about this: Neither are very good coaches and shouldn’t be considered for anything more than a coordinator position.

Funny how one can win 60% of their games with a first-ballot HoFer behind center.

Who would you consider better than either of these two?

 

[DVontel]

I would think the GMs and scouts might have an impact on the draft even more than the HC.

Doesn’t really change what I said though.

 

[iLLmatiC]

Difference between Payton & McCarthy right now is eye for talent. Saints arguably had 1 of the best drafts I have ever seen in 2017 while the Packers’ draft have been kind of lackluster for a while now.

Took McCarthy 11 weeks to start Alex Jones, whereas, Payton would've been featuring him week 1. McCarthy's an idiot. Rodgers is just that great of a QB to overcome the head coach.

 

[GuernseyCard]

Difference between Payton & McCarthy right now is eye for talent. Saints arguably had 1 of the best drafts I have ever seen in 2017 while the Packers’ draft have been kind of lackluster for a while now.

Who's eye for talent?

That's not the HC's primary job.

 

[PACardsFan]

Took McCarthy 11 weeks to start Alex Jones, whereas, Payton would've been featuring him week 1. McCarthy's an idiot. Rodgers is just that great of a QB to overcome the head coach.

Spoke with a Packer season ticket holder just this morning. Alex Jones definitely deserves to be on the field NOW. But, his pass blocking is/was atrocious. That's the reason he sat for as long as he did.

 

[TJ]

Who would you consider better than either of these two?

I would rather a coordinator like DeFillipo. Although there's no measurable success, this is the trend in the league. Would rather have some young blood.

 

[PACardsFan]

You know Packer fans that dislike Aaron Rodgers Huh.


Riiiiiight

Actually yes. Rodgers is whiny, aloof, and at times a punk. There are actually Packer fans that see him pout weekly & it annoys them. Is he a 1st ballot HOFer? Absolutely. But don't kid yourself, McCarthy's offensive schemes & system also put Rodgers in a position to be great. It takes both a great QB & a great system to see results in the NFL. McCarthy would be a phenomenal opportunity for this Cardinal team, especially with Rosen waiting to be taught.