Brenly: Bad call cost us game
BOB McMANAMAN
The Arizona Republic
PHILADELPHIA - Major League Baseball has an electronic device to make sure home plate umpires get it right calling balls and strikes.
The Arizona Diamondbacks will tell you baseball needs another mechanical eye when it comes to calling runners out at first base.
Arizona thought it had turned a double play to get out of the third inning, but it didn't get the call. The Philadelphia Phillies promptly smacked back-to-back homers to account for all the runs in a 4-0 victory in front of 43,721 fans, the second-largest crowd to date at new Citizens Bank Park.
"It's a damn shame," Diamondbacks manager Bob Brenly said after his club dropped its second straight and fell to 9-13.
"The replays showed the runner was out at first base, and we're out of the inning. They end up scoring four runs, and they shouldn't have even had those hitters at the plate in that inning."
Diamondbacks' right fielder Danny Bautista managed a single up the middle in the seventh inning off starting pitcher Randy Wolf (2-1) to extend his hitting streak to 21 games, but that's not what the Diamondbacks were talking about after the first game of this six-game swing through Philly and then Chicago.
It was the controversy at first base, where Arizona played its first game without injured slugger Richie Sexson.
With one out, starting pitcher Elmer Dessens (1-3) allowed consecutive base hits to Wolf and center fielder Marlon Byrd. Placido Polanco then hit a sharp grounder to shortstop Alex Cintron, who flipped the ball to Matt Kata for one out.
Kata's throw to first baseman Greg Colbrunn arrived a half-step before Polanco, but first base umpire Tony Randazzo called Polanco safe.
"I know he's trying to bear down and make the best call he can as he sees it," Brenly said, "but this is one particular instance where a missed call cost us the ballgame."
That's because Bobby Abreu followed with a three-run homer to right-center field off a 2-2 pitch from Dessens. Once the right-hander received a new ball from home plate umpire Fieldin Culbreth, slugger Jim Thome sent the next pitch to almost the same spot for his seventh home run and a 4-0 lead.