Duckjake said:Funny that you guys would use Brees as a comparison when San Diego used the #1 pick in the draft to take a QB just two years ago.
Stout said:Funny how that QB has yet to sniff the starting job. Funny how QBs take time to develop.
FlagstaffDave said:Funny how the Chargers seem very reluctant to part ways with Philip Rivers, or to give Brees that long term contract.
On the flip side I couldn't care less what Vick or Brees do, I'm interested in the Cardinals.
Shane H said:Of course there is. But overall Atlantas running game is nothing to snivel at.
AzWins23 said:Vick also sucked in the Pro Bowl!
Stout said:You have a complete and utter lack of shame, propriety, and sense of common decency. Label me a racist and I refuse to hold a discussion with you. Retract that immediately.
SuperSpck said:#1 in the NFL in Rushing Offense/Rushing Yards per game.
To which, as you can see above, Micheal Vick added some yardage worth mentioning of his own. Denver and Seattle were right behind the Falcons.
If Vick can cut down on his mistakes, then he becomes the most dangerous man at his position, as of right now, he's not.
Over the last 2 years Brees has looked like the better QB.
Pigmentation does not make or break a qb, nor does it define a roll or what type of qb that person has to be. The anti-Vick? Peyton Manning, the runner up? Byron Leftwich. Micheal Vick trivia: Which QB does Vick claim to most pattern himself after? Steve Young, greatest scrambling qb of all time (and multiple super bowl winner and record holder).
If you have to, check the skin color. Seems pretty balanced.
BigDavis75 said:I reread my post and no where did I label you a racist. It is pretty much ignorant to say that Brees has a better shot at winning the SB when Vick has a better winning %, better playoff winning %, and has gotten farther in the playoffs.
BigDavis75 said:The threat of Vick also adds a lot, if he hands off and then bootlegs he draws at least one defender. Also, he is spyed a lot and Brees is almost never spyed on. Lets look at their playmakers vs. eachother. Brees has the better WRs, TE, and RB.... there is no contest there and yet Vick has won more than Brees and proved himself in the playoffs, it should be pretty obvious who the better player is.
BigDavis75 said:I reread my post and no where did I label you a racist. It is pretty much ignorant to say that Brees has a better shot at winning the SB when Vick has a better winning %, better playoff winning %, and has gotten farther in the playoffs.
fball13 said:I agree, Brees is a better passing quarterback than Vick... but with that said, who would you rather have on the Cards, Vick or Brees? I'd take Vick any day of the week. The reason is that although Brees is a good passing QB, he's nowhere near the best. He's not a gamebreaker. I'd take a below average passer who is a gamebreaker any day over an average passer.
Stout said:Funny how that QB has yet to sniff the starting job. Funny how QBs take time to develop.
Stout said:Disagree vehemently. At this point, if he's going to be healthy, I'd take Brees in a minute.
fball13 said:I agree, Brees is a better passing quarterback than Vick... but with that said, who would you rather have on the Cards, Vick or Brees? I'd take Vick any day of the week. The reason is that although Brees is a good passing QB, he's nowhere near the best. He's not a gamebreaker. I'd take a below average passer who is a gamebreaker any day over an average passer.
FlagstaffDave said:And you've made your point like a dozen times in this thread. We all get that you prefer Drew Brees, move on.
fball13 said:I agree, Brees is a better passing quarterback than Vick... but with that said, who would you rather have on the Cards, Vick or Brees? I'd take Vick any day of the week. The reason is that although Brees is a good passing QB, he's nowhere near the best. He's not a gamebreaker. I'd take a below average passer who is a gamebreaker any day over an average passer.
Shane H said:Where is this Vick is a gamebreaker talk coming from? WHy the heck does is he responsible for 15 less offensive TD's if hes such a gamebreaker? Seems to me the guy that score more is more of a gamebreaker. Call me crazy.
Shane H said:You do realize what a message board is for right? Its called debate. You know point, counterpoint. Now that we got that straight have a nice day
Shane H said:No its not. Who cares what Vicks team has done in the past. It has no bearing on who has a better shot at the SB at this point in time. Brees is clearly the better QB he produces more points as a field general then Vick has or likely ever will.