2014-15 NFL Season: Heroes and Goats

kerouac9

Klowned by Keim
Joined
Feb 14, 2003
Posts
38,293
Reaction score
29,539
Location
Gilbert, AZ
I did my post-Wild Card round Heroes and Goats Saturday Night. I wanted to take a moment and do some H&G for the entire season, since we are all doing a little bit of new year's review. Heroes are recognized for their exceptional contributions through 16 games; goats the same.

You must be registered for see images attach


1. Jared Veldheer, OT. I think the arguments about whether Veldheer is the best free agent signing in NFL history are premature. There is no arguing though that Veldheer was a significant factor in the remarkable turnaround in Arizona's pass protection in 2014. The Cards' offensive line was 6th in the NFL in Adjusted Sack Rate at just 4.6%.

2. Deone Bucannon, DB. It's difficult to remember the last time the Arizona Cardinals depended so much on a rookie 1st round pick. Bucannon played more than 65% of the Cardinals defensive snaps, almost all of them from an inside linebacker position at which he had almost no experience. Bucannon made some mistakes and wasn't perfect, but he more that did the job.

3. Chandler Catanzaro, K. There were a number of fans on this board who were skeptical about whether Catanzaro would be able to stand up to real-world kicking situations once the pressure was on. Those fans seem pretty foolish today. Catanzaro was effective on field goals and gave the Cards a leg on kickoffs that we hadn't seen since Guilliam Grammatica was approaching the tee.

4. Alex Okafor, OLB. Kept out of the linebacker rotation until Week 5 due to injury, Okafor was a revelation almost as soon as he entered the lineup. Okafor did what was needed of him in Todd Bowles's pressure scheme: defeat single-blocking on a consistent basis.

5. John Brown, WR. John Brown played almost 60% of the Cards' offensive snaps and delivered what they were hoping to get from The Dude--a big-play speed option. This contribution is even more remarkable considering the small-school origins of the diminutive speedster.

You must be registered for see images


1. Daryl Washington, ILB. If Daryl Washington were more of a leader on the field, this loss would've been even greater. But Washington's decision to selfishly indulge himself cost the team one of the top four or five best players for the entire season and crippled the team's ability to generate a pass rush.

2. John Abraham, OLB. Take a step back from the week-to-week on Abraham, and you'll see a guy who drove drunk at midday, the held the team captive for almost all of training camp, came back in time to guarantee his 2014 salary, and promptly left again for the remainder of the season.

3. Jonathan Dwyer, RB. Dwyer made a dumb choice in his personal life that hurt his team and his ability to provide for his family in at least the near future. For the Cards, Dwyer's choice removed certainty over contributors behind Andre Ellington in the running game, and they struggled to find a consistent solution for the entire season.

4. Michael Floyd, WR. Michael Floyd squandered and opportunity to clearly supplant Larry Fitzgerald as the go-to receiver in the Arizona Cardinals offense. Floyd recovered at the end of the season enough to lead the team in touchdowns and yards, but was 3rd in receptions and behind Fitzgerald in 1st downs.

5. Jonathan Cooper, OG. Cooper came into 2014 coming off a difficult injury. Instead of seizing the opportunity handed to him by the departure of Daryn Colledge, he underperformed and was benched in training camp for Ted Larsen. Cooper wasn't able to earn his way into the starting job until Paul Fanaika suffered an injury late in the year. Cooper failed to make the most of this opportunity handed to him, and he ended the season with a wrist injury that progressively got worse in reporting as the last three weeks of the season wore on.

It was hard to limit this list to just 5. I feel bad that Bruce Arians didn't make the top 5, nor Todd Bowles, but it feels, in retrospect, that these guys more continued to function at an amazingly high level rather than stepped up their game or made new contributions. It was also hard to leave off Kevin Minter, but I feel like despite the debate in the preseason, his level of non-contribution was more or less expected.
 

82CardsGrad

7 x 70
Joined
Dec 31, 2004
Posts
36,033
Reaction score
7,871
Location
Scottsdale
Additional Heroes:

- Calais Campbell
- Frostee Rucker
- Larry Foote

Additional Goats:

- Butler
- PP21
- Carlson
- Housler
- Run Attack (take your pick of contributors...)
 

BillsCarnage

ASFN Addict
Joined
Dec 2, 2005
Posts
5,827
Reaction score
1,197
Location
The Flip Side
4. Michael Floyd, WR. Michael Floyd squandered and opportunity to clearly supplant Larry Fitzgerald as the go-to receiver in the Arizona Cardinals offense. Floyd recovered at the end of the season enough to lead the team in touchdowns and yards, but was 3rd in receptions and behind Fitzgerald in 1st downs.
This might be my biggest concern right now. You have Floyd who is given the keys and opts to sit in the garage stroking the steering wheel pretending he's driving. While on the other hand you might lose Fitz because BA doesn't want to work him into his system. Now you have questions at your top two WR spots.

I'm willing to give Floyd a small pass due to the QB situation, but the guy had the chance to step up and take the #1 WR spot and faltered. Makes you wonder about his commitment long term.
 
OP
OP
kerouac9

kerouac9

Klowned by Keim
Joined
Feb 14, 2003
Posts
38,293
Reaction score
29,539
Location
Gilbert, AZ
This might be my biggest concern right now. You have Floyd who is given the keys and opts to sit in the garage stroking the steering wheel pretending he's driving. While on the other hand you might lose Fitz because BA doesn't want to work him into his system. Now you have questions at your top two WR spots.

I'm willing to give Floyd a small pass due to the QB situation, but the guy had the chance to step up and take the #1 WR spot and faltered. Makes you wonder about his commitment long term.

I don't know. Floyd contributed in a ton of other ways, including some great run-blocking during the season. I just think that he's not consistent enough to do what Fitz does--and that's true of 97% of the receivers in the NFL, so it's not a huge hit on him, either.

I don't have any question that Michael Floyd can be a good #2 WR in this league, or for this team. I also am not sure that Arians wants a true #1 receiver in the mold of Dez Bryant or something. I think that Floyd can be what Arians needs him to be; I just hoped that Floyd was going to be something more.
 

Totally_Red

Air Raid Warning!
Joined
Apr 26, 2005
Posts
8,826
Reaction score
4,604
Location
Iowa
This might be my biggest concern right now. You have Floyd who is given the keys and opts to sit in the garage stroking the steering wheel pretending he's driving. While on the other hand you might lose Fitz because BA doesn't want to work him into his system. Now you have questions at your top two WR spots.

I'm willing to give Floyd a small pass due to the QB situation, but the guy had the chance to step up and take the #1 WR spot and faltered. Makes you wonder about his commitment long term.

Michael Floyd is not now and probably never will be a #1 receiver which is the biggest reason to retain Larry Fitzgerald. Michael occasionally shows flashes of being a solid #2 receiver as in the SF game, but if Fitzgerald leaves and defenses pay more attention to him he'll disappear IMO.

The days of Larry Fitzgerald, Anquan Boldin and Steve Breaston spoiled me regarding the potential of the wide receiver position.
 
OP
OP
kerouac9

kerouac9

Klowned by Keim
Joined
Feb 14, 2003
Posts
38,293
Reaction score
29,539
Location
Gilbert, AZ
Ted Ginn has to make the Goat list.

I know it feels that way, but our punt return was actually above average (3.0% DVOA) on the year, and our kick return was only 31st in the NFL (Oakland was worse) during the regular season.

I know that Ginn performed below expectations as a returner, but I'm not sure he was worse than what we saw from Peterson last year in the punt game, or from that guy we got from KC in kickoffs.
 

BigRedRage

Reckless
Supporting Member
Joined
Mar 25, 2005
Posts
48,274
Reaction score
12,525
Location
SE valley
Ted Ginn has to make the Goat list.


agreed, had the TD and a few runs over 20 yards but it seemed 90% of the time he DID return it, he lost yards or didnt make it to the 20.

Hell, the playoff fumble he returned from the VERY BACK of the endzone. What a dummy.
 

BillsCarnage

ASFN Addict
Joined
Dec 2, 2005
Posts
5,827
Reaction score
1,197
Location
The Flip Side
Michael Floyd is not now and probably never will be a #1 receiver which is the biggest reason to retain Larry Fitzgerald. Michael occasionally shows flashes of being a solid #2 receiver as in the SF game, but if Fitzgerald leaves and defenses pay more attention to him he'll disappear IMO.

The days of Larry Fitzgerald, Anquan Boldin and Steve Breaston spoiled me regarding the potential of the wide receiver position.
So would it be safe to say the #13 overall pick was wasted on a #2 receiver?

Arians system may not need a #1 WR per se, but it does need reliable WR's.
Floyd caught to less than 50% of his targets. Again, I'll attribute that somewhat to the QB play, but the guy seemingly was a ghost in some games - http://espn.go.com/nfl/player/gamelog/_/id/14908/michael-floyd

It was his 3rd year, but I'll be hoping for much more consistency next year from him. No reason he can't be a consistent 65rec-1000yrd-10td WR.
 

BW52

Registered
Joined
May 14, 2002
Posts
5,043
Reaction score
1,904
Location
crestwood,Ky
I did my post-Wild Card round Heroes and Goats Saturday Night. I wanted to take a moment and do some H&G for the entire season, since we are all doing a little bit of new year's review. Heroes are recognized for their exceptional contributions through 16 games; goats the same.

You must be registered for see images attach


1. Jared Veldheer, OT. I think the arguments about whether Veldheer is the best free agent signing in NFL history are premature. There is no arguing though that Veldheer was a significant factor in the remarkable turnaround in Arizona's pass protection in 2014. The Cards' offensive line was 6th in the NFL in Adjusted Sack Rate at just 4.6%.

2. Deone Bucannon, DB. It's difficult to remember the last time the Arizona Cardinals depended so much on a rookie 1st round pick. Bucannon played more than 65% of the Cardinals defensive snaps, almost all of them from an inside linebacker position at which he had almost no experience. Bucannon made some mistakes and wasn't perfect, but he more that did the job.

3. Chandler Catanzaro, K. There were a number of fans on this board who were skeptical about whether Catanzaro would be able to stand up to real-world kicking situations once the pressure was on. Those fans seem pretty foolish today. Catanzaro was effective on field goals and gave the Cards a leg on kickoffs that we hadn't seen since Guilliam Grammatica was approaching the tee.

4. Alex Okafor, OLB. Kept out of the linebacker rotation until Week 5 due to injury, Okafor was a revelation almost as soon as he entered the lineup. Okafor did what was needed of him in Todd Bowles's pressure scheme: defeat single-blocking on a consistent basis.

5. John Brown, WR. John Brown played almost 60% of the Cards' offensive snaps and delivered what they were hoping to get from The Dude--a big-play speed option. This contribution is even more remarkable considering the small-school origins of the diminutive speedster.

You must be registered for see images


1. Daryl Washington, ILB. If Daryl Washington were more of a leader on the field, this loss would've been even greater. But Washington's decision to selfishly indulge himself cost the team one of the top four or five best players for the entire season and crippled the team's ability to generate a pass rush.

2. John Abraham, OLB. Take a step back from the week-to-week on Abraham, and you'll see a guy who drove drunk at midday, the held the team captive for almost all of training camp, came back in time to guarantee his 2014 salary, and promptly left again for the remainder of the season.

3. Jonathan Dwyer, RB. Dwyer made a dumb choice in his personal life that hurt his team and his ability to provide for his family in at least the near future. For the Cards, Dwyer's choice removed certainty over contributors behind Andre Ellington in the running game, and they struggled to find a consistent solution for the entire season.

4. Michael Floyd, WR. Michael Floyd squandered and opportunity to clearly supplant Larry Fitzgerald as the go-to receiver in the Arizona Cardinals offense. Floyd recovered at the end of the season enough to lead the team in touchdowns and yards, but was 3rd in receptions and behind Fitzgerald in 1st downs.

5. Jonathan Cooper, OG. Cooper came into 2014 coming off a difficult injury. Instead of seizing the opportunity handed to him by the departure of Daryn Colledge, he underperformed and was benched in training camp for Ted Larsen. Cooper wasn't able to earn his way into the starting job until Paul Fanaika suffered an injury late in the year. Cooper failed to make the most of this opportunity handed to him, and he ended the season with a wrist injury that progressively got worse in reporting as the last three weeks of the season wore on.

It was hard to limit this list to just 5. I feel bad that Bruce Arians didn't make the top 5, nor Todd Bowles, but it feels, in retrospect, that these guys more continued to function at an amazingly high level rather than stepped up their game or made new contributions. It was also hard to leave off Kevin Minter, but I feel like despite the debate in the preseason, his level of non-contribution was more or less expected.

Pretty good list and I see your reasoning for your choices.I still hope Cooper realizes what is at stake and shows up next season ready to play.How nice it was for the Cards to finally have a FA -OLINEMAN come in and perform well (its been a while).As for Daryl Washington I have doubts he will stay clean enough to come back and help.............I think management has to prepare for proceeding without him.
 

BillsCarnage

ASFN Addict
Joined
Dec 2, 2005
Posts
5,827
Reaction score
1,197
Location
The Flip Side
I know that Ginn performed below expectations as a returner, but I'm not sure he was worse than what we saw from Peterson last year in the punt game, or from that guy we got from KC in kickoffs.
Statistically, he may not have been bad, but his judgement/decision making was atrocious. The number of times he'd field the ball at the 15 or 20 and not a player w/in 10yrds only to fair catch. The opposite, he'd run when players were right on top of him. Or how many times did he run backwards and lose yards.

It would have been nice to see Arians try some other players to maybe light the fire under Ginn's butt.
 

RugbyMuffin

ASFN IDOL
Joined
Apr 30, 2003
Posts
30,485
Reaction score
4,877
I would put Tommie Kelly in place of John Brown, personally. Kelly was HUGE for this team all year, and Frostee Rucker was pretty damn good, too. Those two really did a lot for this defense.


Putting Michael Floyd on the goat list is a little harsh, and I am not sure why John Carlson is getting so much flack ? Yeah, neither put up great numbers, but they played with 4 different QB's.


Kevin Minter has to be a goat. Yeah, I didn't expect him to play much this season either, but when you are getting stuck behind Glenn Carson ? There are issues. Not to mention Minter didn't do too much when he was out there.
 
OP
OP
kerouac9

kerouac9

Klowned by Keim
Joined
Feb 14, 2003
Posts
38,293
Reaction score
29,539
Location
Gilbert, AZ
Michael Floyd is not now and probably never will be a #1 receiver which is the biggest reason to retain Larry Fitzgerald. Michael occasionally shows flashes of being a solid #2 receiver as in the SF game, but if Fitzgerald leaves and defenses pay more attention to him he'll disappear IMO.

The days of Larry Fitzgerald, Anquan Boldin and Steve Breaston spoiled me regarding the potential of the wide receiver position.

I don't think this is fair. Is Michael Floyd going to be a #1 receiver like Dez Bryant and A.J. Green? I don't think that was ever really in his skill set. Can Michael Floyd be as good or better a #1 receiver than Jordy Nelson, Jeremy Maclin, and 70% of the other top receivers around the NFL?

No question in my mind.

I think that Floyd's 47% catch rate is probably going to be a long-term outlier. Had a 58% catch rate last year, 52% his rookie year--I don't think he suddenly forgot how to catch a football.

Hidden value of Michael Floyd: Floyd drew 3 pass interference penalties for 87 yards this year. He's good at using his body as a perimeter receiver, and he did a great job breaking up Ryan Lindley's frequent errant passes in the last month of the year.

Mind-boggling side stat: Torrey Smith of the Ravens drew 11 pass interference penalties for 229 yards! That's more than 1/3rd of his receiving yardage on the year (767).
 

b8rtm8nn

ASFN Lifer
Joined
Jan 14, 2003
Posts
3,370
Reaction score
1,647
Location
Tucson
Good list - I wouldn't have put Floyd on there, but I would have put Minter. Regardless that we expected Minter to be...uhm...inconsequential doesn't dilute the fact that when he is called upon to deliver his one strength of run stopping, he fails. He didn't even have the injuries of Cooper to justify being so mediocre.
 

Jetstream Green

Kool Aid with a touch of vodka
Joined
Feb 5, 2003
Posts
29,474
Reaction score
16,640
Location
San Antonio, Texas
The Cardinals WR group performed a lot like the Charger group which also has a Floyd... one had no idea which guy would play well week to week and you know there is talent but it would not always surface on a consistent basis
 
OP
OP
kerouac9

kerouac9

Klowned by Keim
Joined
Feb 14, 2003
Posts
38,293
Reaction score
29,539
Location
Gilbert, AZ
Good list - I wouldn't have put Floyd on there, but I would have put Minter. Regardless that we expected Minter to be...uhm...inconsequential doesn't dilute the fact that when he is called upon to deliver his one strength of run stopping, he fails. He didn't even have the injuries of Cooper to justify being so mediocre.

See--I think that Minter was playing with a torn pectoral all season. It was never enough to limit him in practice or make him probably on the injury report the whole season, but whatever hope we have that Minter could become a regular starter to this offense depends on him maybe being unhealthy--or something.

I'd chalk up mediocre play at the beginning of the season for Cooper knocking rust off following the lost season. But it's inexcuseable for him to look as bad as he did against the Chiefs and Rams after having a six-plus months to hone his craft.
 

D-Dogg

A Whole New World
Supporting Member
Joined
Sep 10, 2003
Posts
44,914
Reaction score
858
Location
In The End Zone
butler was horrific all season long. The fact that he was putting balls inside the 20 was because of all the punts from midfield and he can't kick for crap. has a horrific getoff time and blew field position all year, most notably in seattle and in the playoffs.

Just a bad, bad, bad, bad, bad, bad punter. and I don't care what you think of kickers in general, but punting is damn important.
 

BillsCarnage

ASFN Addict
Joined
Dec 2, 2005
Posts
5,827
Reaction score
1,197
Location
The Flip Side
butler was horrific all season long. The fact that he was putting balls inside the 20 was because of all the punts from midfield and he can't kick for crap. has a horrific getoff time and blew field position all year, most notably in seattle and in the playoffs.

Just a bad, bad, bad, bad, bad, bad punter. and I don't care what you think of kickers in general, but punting is damn important.
And even worse in bad weather when field position is at a premium.
 

D-Dogg

A Whole New World
Supporting Member
Joined
Sep 10, 2003
Posts
44,914
Reaction score
858
Location
In The End Zone
Someone made a hilarious golf analogy about Butler's inside the 20 kicks and Zasty's. When presented with the midfield punt, Zasty pulls a wedge out of his bag and tries to lay up while Butler grabs his driver and lets it rip. Both of them put it inside the 20, but the difference is that Zasty has a bag full of clubs left when the punt isn't from midfield and Butler doesn't have any more distance to bring to bear.

I laughed, and then just got super depressed at how true that was.
 

Cbus cardsfan

Back to Back ASFN FFL Champion
Joined
May 14, 2002
Posts
21,431
Reaction score
7,492
It's hard to disagree with the lists. After a nice start, I thought Carlson was a major disappointment. Cooper and Watford, arguably the 2 leading candidates to man the OG position prior to camp, not seeing the field very much was also very disheartening.
 

82CardsGrad

7 x 70
Joined
Dec 31, 2004
Posts
36,033
Reaction score
7,871
Location
Scottsdale
Someone made a hilarious golf analogy about Butler's inside the 20 kicks and Zasty's. When presented with the midfield punt, Zasty pulls a wedge out of his bag and tries to lay up while Butler grabs his driver and lets it rip. Both of them put it inside the 20, but the difference is that Zasty has a bag full of clubs left when the punt isn't from midfield and Butler doesn't have any more distance to bring to bear.

I laughed, and then just got super depressed at how true that was.


That is perfect!![emoji1]
 

mwanamatapa

Veteran
Supporting Member
Joined
Aug 19, 2012
Posts
227
Reaction score
94
Addition for the Goats, special teams coach.

Seems to me the special teams play has regressed in the two years he has been here. Taking nothing away from Justin Bethel, who I think had been tremendous once again - can't be all on the execution - the coach should be held to account.
 

Jake6233

All Star
Joined
Feb 10, 2013
Posts
561
Reaction score
258
John Abraham did some stupid stuff this past offseason but he went on IR, its not like he quit on the team for no reason.
 

football karma

Michael snuggles the cap space
Joined
Jul 22, 2002
Posts
15,163
Reaction score
14,056
I thought Carlson was a big dissapointment. After Palmer raved about him all offseason, I expected more than inconsistent hands and mediocre blocking.

Worse-- the poor hands came at the worst time. Witness last Saturday in Q3 on 3rd and 8 or so. Yes, the ball was tipped, but a struggling QB badly needed a vet TE to make a catch.
 

cardpa

Have a Nice Day!
Joined
Mar 14, 2003
Posts
7,399
Reaction score
4,134
Location
Monroe NC
For me Floyd was a big disappointment. Third year and no reason not to step up especially if you take into account that Fitz was drawing double coverage almost every time he was on the field. Wasted #13 pick in my book. You could grab 20 other guys and maybe even more who could provide you with the same production as Floyd and were not first round picks. As I had said before I expect a first round pick to be at the very least a superior player and certainly above average. Floyd is average.
 

Staff online

Forum statistics

Threads
551,529
Posts
5,387,752
Members
6,310
Latest member
sundevils78
Top