I really think Jones, Monty and Sarver all played a role in this situation. And as has been mentioned, because of factors outside our control, we got far less opportunity to assess him than usual and he had far less opportunity to grow and improve. I think we made a mistake but far less egregious than it's being made out to be.
I agree with this. I think JJ salvaged the situation by bringing back Craig by trading Stix for him. Had he held onto Stix and they let him expire then the mistake of declining his option would have been much more apparent. All's well that ends well though.
The move also corrects another perceived misstep from last off-season, letting Craig walk. Some believed that was a bigger blunder than anything related to Stix. I'm happy with the trade, ultimately it was a better move than trading Stix with Saric for Thad Young. Hopefully they don't dump Craig this off-season. If they dump Craig for nothing or make another salary specific move like that then Sarver's fingerprints will be more noticeable than they have been lately.