- Joined
- Apr 2, 2004
- Posts
- 36,747
- Reaction score
- 16,501
Seems reasonable to me if he can stay healthy. If not, a tierdrop will soon follow.xc_hide_links_from_guests_guests_error_hide_media
KD in his own tier!
Seems reasonable to me if he can stay healthy. If not, a tierdrop will soon follow.xc_hide_links_from_guests_guests_error_hide_media
KD in his own tier!
Let’s just say if I have first choice in a local pickup game, KD is my choice hands down.xc_hide_links_from_guests_guests_error_hide_media
KD in his own tier!
Let’s just say if I have first choice in a local pickup game, KD is my choice hands down.
No way. He might have a few good minutes of him but he's a shell of his all-nba self. I'd take Lebron or KD over him in that scenario.A healthy Kawhi is my pick in that scenario. I remember after those first two Clipper games thinking he was the best player on planet earth,
Kawhi is my second choiceA healthy Kawhi is my pick in that scenario. I remember after those first two Clipper games thinking he was the best player on planet earth,
No way. He might have a few good minutes of him but he's a shell of his all-nba self. I'd take Lebron or KD over him in that scenario.
That matters. He’s less healthy than KD and that’s saying something.He’s not a shell of himself when he’s healthy. He’s just rarely healthy.
That matters. He’s less healthy than KD and that’s saying something.
If he only plays a couple games a month, there's no guarantee he's going to be otherworldly in every game. The guy is running on reputation right now and hasn't proven to be consistent even in the minutes he does play.Yeah it does matter but that’s different than saying he’s a shell of himself as a player.
Let’s just say if I have first choice in a local pickup game, KD is my choice hands down.
Gotta disagree. In the minutes he did play last year, he was 24/6/4, while still being a good defender. And even those numbers are skewed by the first two months of the season when he was held out for injuries and wasn’t back in good condition.If he only plays a couple games a month, there's no guarantee he's going to be otherworldly in every game. The guy is running on reputation right now and hasn't proven to be consistent even in the minutes he does play.
If he only plays a couple games a month, there's no guarantee he's going to be otherworldly in every game. The guy is running on reputation right now and hasn't proven to be consistent even in the minutes he does play.
I get what you’re saying. I also have the same feeling as chap though. Maybe it’s because he never finishes the playoffs anymore. So that’s much fresher in mind.He played 5 more games than KD did last season, shot over 50% from the field and 41% from 3 while all of his other stats were right around career averages. He did average 1 less point a game but he was also coming off an ACL tear. This idea he's a shell of his former self or never plays doesn't hold up very well when you look at his season and compare it to someone like KD, who you've praised heavily. He also played in more games than KD by month throughout 2023 once he worked his way back into shape from missing the previous season.
I get what you’re saying. I also have the same feeling as chap though. Maybe it’s because he never finishes the playoffs anymore. So that’s much fresher in mind.
Lebron at this age? Are you serious? I'm sorry he is so overrated at this point.In a pickup game, I'd choose Lebron. No one is taking a charge from him.
Lebron at this age? Are you serious? I'm sorry he is so overrated at this point.
I would take Paul George, Ingram, KD, Kwahi, Tatum, and Jaylen Brown over Lebron. I would even take Mikal over Lebron.
Which is not even really a shot at Lebron - it's understanding the reality of what being a 40 year old means.
And the second most overrated player is Jimmy Butler - I have seen several lists where he is ranked above Booker - that is just complete and utter BS. Rarely does he ever take over a game.
xc_hide_links_from_guests_guests_error_hide_media
KD in his own tier!
He's been pretty damned good in 20 or 30 games since then, if you ignore all the other games he's a supersar.PG smh, he hasn't been anything since the Pacers run.
He's been pretty damned good in 20 or 30 games since then, if you ignore all the other games he's a supersar.
PG smh, he hasn't been anything since the Pacers run.
He was a dark horse MVP candidate in OKC his second season there, finishing 3rd in the race and getting All NBA 1st team and All Defense 1st team honors. He helped push the Clippers to the WCF and win 2 games against us. He's definitely a star but he's had trouble staying healthy in LA.