I'd have to go with Amare if it was just confidence alone. No doubt Amare would try to dunk over Him on the first possession. However, I just can't seem to get over that "command over all of the elements" thing. I have heard of torching a defender, but never seen it literally. Would hate to sacrifice a talent like Amare. Amare definately has the power to embarass people...but who's to say he won't turn STAT into a pillar of salt at tip off?
What position does God play anyway? all-POWERful FORWARD?
He created it all, so anywhere they play He's got home court advantage.
If the game occurred, I believe Amare would learn the meaning of SMITE.