Is it time to move on from Kyler Murray

[Garthshort]

Think he meant Red Skelton. Pressers would be pretty funny.

 

[602 Native]

A definite laugh out loud moment comparing the two.

I was alive when Cards fans would say McCoy was better than K1.

 

[Garthshort]

I was alive when Cards fans would say McCoy was better than K1.

Are you sure, or just dreamed you were alive?

 

[WisconsinCard]

Think he meant Red Skelton. Pressers would be pretty funny.

We just got beat by Red Skelton. Dat ETP was a funny man to watch

 

[HairZach]

You just described Matt Stafford prior to LA

C'mon Kyler has never approached being as good as Stafford in Detroit. That guy was consistently top 10, Kyler is more than serviceable but he isn't top 15. A Superbowl can be won with Kyler, but if you watch his game and look at advanced statistics, he doesn't come close to being as good as guys like Stafford, Geno or Purdy.

 

[urs]

I was alive when Cards fans would say McCoy was better than K1.

I was alive when people on this board were saying Dobbs was better. The hate for Kyler is hilarious

 

[QuebecCard]

C'mon Kyler has never approached being as good as Stafford in Detroit. That guy was consistently top 10, Kyler is more than serviceable but he isn't top 15. A Superbowl can be won with Kyler, but if you watch his game and look at advanced statistics, he doesn't come close to being as good as guys like Stafford, Geno or Purdy.

KM has passed for more TDs than Geno has combined, passing and running in his 11-year career.

In 2024, Geno has 4 TDs, passing 4 INT and a QBR of 64.2.

Career: 81 games: 88 TDs passing - 11 rushing.

KM has 6 TDs, passing 1 INT and a QBR of 68.4.

KM 69 games: 100 TDS passing - 26 rushing

 

[ASUCHRIS]

C'mon Kyler has never approached being as good as Stafford in Detroit. That guy was consistently top 10, Kyler is more than serviceable but he isn't top 15. A Superbowl can be won with Kyler, but if you watch his game and look at advanced statistics, he doesn't come close to being as good as guys like Stafford, Geno or Purdy.

You had me until the bolded part...half a season of supe rbowl winning QB play out of 6 is not nearly enough to make the assertion that a super bowl can be won with Kyler.

 

[Cheesebeef]

Half of the league is in the same boat. It's just what QB's cost now - because there is such a shortage and because of their importance.

And if this team was even consistently in the first half of the league as far as competence was concerned, it wouldn’t be as big of a problem. But those other QBs you point to all contribute to their teams being at least average. Kyler doesn’t even do that.

 

[Garthshort]

KM has passed for more TDs than Geno has combined, passing and running in his 11-year career.

In 2024, Geno has 4 TDs, passing 4 INT and a QBR of 64.2.

Career: 81 games: 88 TDs passing - 11 rushing.

KM has 6 TDs, passing 1 INT and a QBR of 68.4.

KM 69 games: 100 TDS passing - 26 rushing

STOP confusing us with FACTS. Simply, not fair.

 

[Bobster]

Murray may or may not be the answer at QB, but there are other issues that demand immediate attention. The defense has been horrible and line play on both offense and defense needs to improve. How much they can do during the season is debatable.

 

[Brian in Mesa]

STOP confusing us with FACTS. Simply, not fair.

To be fair, Geno wasn't a starting QB for 6 of those seasons. In reality, Geno has only started 70 games, so one more than Kyler.

Since Seattle put him in as their starter he has done very well.

Currently leading the league in passing yards.

You must be registered for see images attach

 

[Cheesebeef]

STOP confusing us with FACTS. Simply, not fair.

Kyler Murray has averaged a TOTAL of 21 TDs per season over 6 1/4 seasons.

That FACT IS BAD for any QB, and PATHETIC for a QB making a top 10 salary.

 

[Cheesebeef]

Murray may or may not be the answer at QB, but there are other issues that demand immediate attention. The defense has been horrible and line play on both offense and defense needs to improve. How much they can do during the season is debatable.

The idea that this team can’t walk and chew gum at the same time bewilders me to no end.

 

[Chopper0080]

STOP confusing us with FACTS. Simply, not fair.

Here are some facts for you. These are Kyler's stats after the GB game in 2021 excluding his horrid playoff game. I use this because it is a clear line of demarcation in his QB play.

29 games played.
9-20 record. .310 win %
657/991 66.29 completion %.
6455 yards. 225.65 yards per game.
37 TDs. 16 INTs.
166 rush attempts for 1102 yards. 38 yards per game.
8 rush TDs. 22 fumbles. (not fumbles lost) .75 fumbles per game.

Essentially this Kyler's average game log.

22.65 completions
34.17 attempts
66.29% completion %.
225.65 yards
1.27 passing TDs.
0.55 interceptions

5.72 rush attempts
38 yards rushing
0.27 rushing TDs
0.75 fumbles

 

[Chopper0080]

Fun comparison.

22.75 completions
36.0 attempts
63.2% completion %
220.3 yards passing per game
1 passing TD per game
0.75 ints per game

5.75 rush attempts per game
17.5 yards rushing
0 rushing TDs
0.25 fumbles per game.

 

[Chopper0080]

The comparison is Daniel Jones stat line this year.

 

[Chopper0080]

So, since after the GB game in 2021, Kyler Murray's per game stat line (29 games) is similar to Daniel Jones per game stat line this season. That is the level of play he is producing. Kyler's win % is .310. Jones win % .250.

 

[Chopper0080]

However, to be fair...Kyler is only making 6.1 mil more per year on his average annual salary per year than Jones. So the contracts are similarly close to the production.