- Joined
- Oct 19, 2003
- Posts
- 119,244
- Reaction score
- 59,842
though i would have loved to see the mavs lose stack the suns killer, i am still optimistic about this trade from a suns standpoint.
kidd will make the mavs better against most teams. i think objectively it is difficult to argue against that fact. my only question with acquiring him is a similar question posed to the suns . . . a matter of style. just as people question the suns' ability to incorporate a slower half-court type player in shaq, the mavs' offense has largely been predicated on one-on-one iso's. the low number of assists is a great indicator of such. kidd needs a slightly more movement in the offense to be effective, much like steve nash.
but more importantly (to suns fans), this trade lowers the mavs ability to compete with the suns. for years the two places to attack the suns were at the rim and at the point. nash just cannot effectively defense quick pgs. harris in particular gave him fits. nash just couldn't stay in front of him. replacing harris with kidd means much less of an issue for nash, which in turn means less help defense necessary. and with kidd shooting in the 30 - 35% range, nash WILL sag considerably off him. our defense just got a lot better against the mavs.
and the second prong is a new twist for the suns . . . and it's shaq-based. the loss of diop means one less big body in the post to defend against shaq. it means its ericka dampier or no one against shaq. and we all know what shaq thinks of ericka. this leaves the mavs with ericka, dirk, and bass as their only post defenders, and two of those cannot even hope to defend shaq, and those two also will never be effective on amare. damp and diop had some limited success against amare due to their size, but now they won't be covering amare . . . dirk and bass will be. advantage suns. big time.
so while this trade may be overall in dallas' interest, it weakens them against the suns. imho.
You make some very good issues.
IMO, Kidd is most effective in an open court running game because of his mediocre (at best) outside shooting. Also the Mavs lack height. The Mavs will really need to focus on running (reminds me of past Suns teams). I'm not overly familiar with the Mavs roster but they seem to be lacking height except Dirk, a sometimes effective Dampier, Bass and the rookie big (Nick ...). To win it all the Mavs really need to rely on the 1-3 positions to get it done. Dirk although tall plays more like a SF.
So the Mavs may need to really try to run a GS offense which will cause them trouble the deeper they go in the playoffs. Maybe the Mavs are planning on making another trade?