I hate Wilner, but he's not wrong. Miller needs to stop acting like Coach Cal and stop getting nothing but OADs year in and year out. Sure, you don't pass on the Aytons of the world, but Rawle and Trier are not your quintessential Miller guys. They don't play defense and have no desire to lock anyone up.
In many respects, not being able to recruit top-tier guys for the time being will be a blessing in disguise for Miller. He can develop players and have them ready to play by their junior season.
I disagree on Alkins, in fact he was considered one of the better defensive players in that class, along with Josh Jackson. he was a good defender for a freshman, he wasn't this year IMO largely because he wasn't nearly as quick after the foot injury.
Remember when Alkins did the NBA workouts one of the things the NBA teams loved about him was his defense. Trier I agree with, terrible defender, very little effort. I know I said it at the time too but when UCLA won at McKale this year one of the big reasons was that Miller let Trier talk him into putting Trier on Holiday to start the game. Holiday ate Trier up, got UCLA off to a good start which gave them confidence and took the crowd out of the game. In the rematch PJC, not a great defender himself, played probably the best defensive game of his career guarding Holiday and it was a key reason Arizona won.
Miller is recruiting what I call mercenary recruits, I don't mean just the ones involved in the FBI story but guys who don't really buy into the team system they have their own agenda. The classic one was Kobi Simmons. There's a big difference between an Aaron Gordon who had some demands on offense but was offset by being such a great defender and rebounder, with Simmons and kids like that you don't get enough good to offset the bad IMO. UCLA has the same issue right now with Jaylen Hands IMO.