Common, George. You know that the Marbury trades both in and out were good trades for us. And Penny's was a gamble gone bad. And Goog's was pure bad luck, triggered by Dice's diss.
IMHO, It turned out to be an awful trade for the Suns.
The problem with Marbury was that he was not a true point guard. He was just another AI who was great on isolation plays and coming off picks to get to the basket. If cut off getting to the basket, he would kick the ball out to a shooer which generated some assists. But if he couldn't get into the lane, he'd just keep dribbling on the wing and wait to pass until the clock had about run out..
Marbury would not, or could not, run the break. If he had the ball on the break, he'd either brick a three or stand around waiting for everyone else to get down into the offense so he could get a pick to clear to the basket. The Suns averaged 93.4 ppg on 44.3% shooting during their 2002-03 season.
But look at what happened with Kidd in New Jersey. They were better before and after Marbury
New Jersey
1997-98 43-39
1998-99 16-34 (Marbury's first season)
1999-00 31-51
2000-01 (Marbury's last season) 26-56
2001-02 52-30
2002-03 49-33
2003-04 47-35
Phoenix
1997-98 56-26
1998-99 27-23
1999-00 53-29
2000-01 51-31
2001-02 36-46 (Marbury's first year in Phoenix)
2002-03 44-38
2003-04 29-53 (Marbury traded in mid season)
2004-05 62-20
The Knicks were bad before Marbury came, but the record of his team is:
2003-04 39-43
2004-05 33-49
2005-06 23-59
2006-07 33-49
2007-08 23-59 (injured)
Marury has had two seasons over 500 in his entire career. In the case of the Wolves, they went from 25-25 in his last season 1998-99 to 50-32 the first year he was gone. To make this even more troubling, his only 500 plus season in the last decade was during his contract year.
D'Antoni has his work cut out for him.