The philosophy of keeping in state talent may be overrated. Does losing Kirk sting, of course as he is a 5-star and any team would love to have a 5-star at any position but I would rather have kids that want to be here. If a kid wants to go out of state there is no use trying to convince him otherwise as usually their minds are made up. The last few years in state kids that ended up staying in state committed early, Chans Cox, Tyler Whitley, Trevor Wood, Keenan Walker, etc. The longer a kid draws out his recruitment the more likely they are heading out of state. I would be happy getting 4-star kids from CA, TX, etc than fret over losing in-state kids who are set on going elsewhere. ASU has won 69% of their games under Graham (27-12) and have gone to 3 straight bowl games; Rodriguez has gone 26-13 (66% winning percentage) so its not like AZ schools are bottom dwellers so those who say they need to win to get the kids to stay have no real argument. ARZ kids can't ignore the glamour of going out of state. AZ schools have done fine without them and some kids have ended up coming home after finding the grass isn't greener out of state.
In ASU's case give me Irwin & Broadus or Hawkins and we are set at WR. I am actually more interested in landing a couple of the stud LB's & DL we are still in on to finish out the class.