How can people continually call Graves a total failure when he helped provide the building blocks of the team that took us to the Super Bowl? He ain't perfect, but he is not the dismal failure people try to make him out to be.
I have no problem giving credit where credit is due, but it's should go to Graves IMO. Whiz and his staff (and a big shot out to John Lott) have come in here in two years and done more than anyone else has been able to in 60+ years. The team was well coached and was the healthiest team in the league. That has more to do with it than anything else IMO.
Graves has drafted well and I have never disputed this, but he has continually failed when it comes time to either resign or extend players.
Up until last offseason I had never been overly critical of Graves and actually was pretty supportive of him and was glad to have the guy. The debacle with Fitz flat out made me embarrassed to be a Card fan though. It was a HORRIBLE job by Graves, and I dont think there is any other way to see it.
I dont love the price of the deal, but that's not the bad part. What was so bad was that we wasted the entire offseason fighting over the deal only to cave right before camp and give Larry exactly what he asked for in the beginning. It's the good old" know when to hold/fold em". With the leftover money on the cap we didn't use you better believe had the deal been done earlier we could have had Allen Faneca or atleast two more solid role players. Basically, had Graves done his job in a timely manner we could have avoided suffering through watching Francisco in the Super Bowl.