kerouac9 said:
. Very quickly, here are 20 wideouts all better than Anquan:
1. Randy Moss
2. Terrell Owens
3. Marvin Harrison
4. Javon Walker
5. Torry Holt
6. Hinz Ward
7. Chad Johnson
8. Mushin Muhammed
9. Derrick Mason
10. Rod Smith
11. Lee Evans
12. Darrell Jackson
13. Plaxico Burress
14. Jimmy Smith
15. Andre Johnson
16. Joe Horn
17. Eric Moulds
18. Chris Chambers
19. Roy Williams
20. Larry Fitzgerald
Hope that clears everything up for you.
Very quickly here is all the holes in your list.
Derrick Mason is barely better
Chris Chambers is not
Lee Evans is not, AND HE IS NOT EVEN A TOP 50!
Darrell Jackson? is obviously not, he still has problems catching the ball
Plaxico Burress is not
Andre Johnson is not, he still has problems catching the ball
Roy Williams is about the same
Larry Fitzgerald is not.
But here is were I really think K9 is going out of his way to be difficult. K9, I love reading your stuff here and you make A LOT of good points and you are knowledgable. But this is total B.S.
JEVON WALKER?????? Better than Boldin?
Not only is it untrue. But Jevon Walker has practically done exactly what Boldin has done. He had one good year (and it wasn't as good as Boldin's 2003 year) and he also has Brett Farve throwing to him. I think it is safe to say Farve is better than Blake, or McCown. ALSO, Jevon has a bad knee which calls into question his durability. Jevon also is holding out for a new control.
I have sat here and read post after post that delt with all the reasons you thought Boldin didn't deserve this and that. Why Boldin is not as good as we all think. ETC, ETC, ETC.....at nauseam.
Now you go and put Jevon Walker on a pedistal above Boldin? That is borderline hypocritical. You cannot spend days discussing with people about the quality of players on this team, and not be held accountable. Many of things you said about Boldin can be said about Walker.
Sorry, man needed to say it.
I mean ask 50 people to make a list of the top 20 WR's in the NFL and you get 20 answers.
The better discussion to have is why Fitz is better than Boldin, or visa versa.