Stanton or Palmer

[Iceman]

Just curious on what everyone thinks of this. If Palmer is healthy today, who would you want in there vs. Broncos?

 

[LoyaltyisaCurse]

PALMER!

 

[Shane]

No question Palmer

 

[ajcardfan]

Palmer, 100%.

Look, it's a nice story with Stanton these last couple of games. But, there are throws Palmer can make that Stanton just can't. I laughed at the radio DJs today trying to make a controversy at QB. Palmer is the starter, period. The only exception to that would be if Palmer misses 8 to 12 games. Then, they might keep Stanton starter if we are still in a good position for the playoffs.

 

[LoyaltyisaCurse]

The more tape there is on Stanton, the harder it is going to be to succeed. He doesnt do anything spectacular...

 

[TJ]

Palmer, 100%.

Look, it's a nice story with Stanton these last couple of games. But, there are throws Palmer can make that Stanton just can't. I laughed at the radio DJs today trying to make a controversy at QB. Palmer is the starter, period. The only exception to that would be if Palmer misses 8 to 12 games. Then, they might keep Stanton starter if we are still in a good position for the playoffs.

I listened to Bickley, Gambo, and MJ today and while I wasn't surprised to hear this come up, it's still frustrating to listen to. Stanton hasn't even proven that Palmer is expendable after this season let alone be the starter this season.

 

[ajcardfan]

I listened to Bickley, Gambo, and MJ today and while I wasn't surprised to hear this come up, it's still frustrating to listen to. Stanton hasn't even proven that Palmer is expendable after this season let alone be the starter this season.

I suppose that sports talk show hosts try to create controversy to drive up their ratings. Stanton has proven he's really nice to have around as a backup who might have to step in when Palmer is hurt. THAT'S IT.

 

[Azlen]

Stanton has shown that he is a backup who can step in and win a game or two. Derek Anderson also showed that he was a capable back up the first week in Carolina. You don't want either of them starting long term.

 

[Shaggy]

Ok, let me ask you this. If Palmer's nerve is still giving him problems, are you worried about Stanton being the starter again against Denver? I'm not.

 

[ajcardfan]

Ok, let me ask you this. If Palmer's nerve is still giving him problems, are you worried about Stanton being the starter again against Denver? I'm not.

If Palmer still can't go against Denver, then it is what it is. Yes, I will still watch the game as I know the Cards, with that defense we are playing, can compete with anyone.

 

[CardLogic]

Palmer, with out a doubt! Just ask BA!

 

[Drop_D]

Too bad you fixed the thread title. I was going to vote Satan!

 

[GatorAZ]

Unless Palmer is 100%, Stanton. I'm liking his downfield throws and mobility.

 

[Iceman]

Ok, let me ask you this. If Palmer's nerve is still giving him problems, are you worried about Stanton being the starter again against Denver? I'm not.

Me either. I have all the confidence in both our QBs and team

 

[mrbyte]

Palmer

 

[Brak]

Palmer.

But while he's still lame, it scares the crap out of me that the only guy we have behind Stanton is LT. If Stanton goes down before Palmer is ready to go, we're hosed.

 

[Jetstream Green]

Palmer, but I am comfortable with Stanton

 

[nickolaskus]

I'd go with Palmer, as long as he's 100% and can make all the throws. That being said Stanton has been putting up some pretty good numbers. Sure his comp% was only 55% against the niners, but check out these stats.

13 of Drew Stanton's 33 pass attempts were 20+ yards downfield, most of any QB this season.

Drew Stanton's average depth of target (aDOT) yesterday was 16.7 yards. Highest figure of any QB since Week 11 of 2011.

Gotta give the oline credit for giving him ample time, but he doesn't check down much like a backup would. He knows the offence probably better than carson. And he hasn't had the big turnover. At this point I give a sleight edge to palmer, but Stanton is gaining. If Palmer misses 5-6 more games...it could be Stanton's team.

 

[D-Dogg]

Just curious on what everyone thinks of this. If Palmer is healthy today, who would you want in there vs. Broncos?

Palmer without blinking.

Ok, let me ask you this. If Palmer's nerve is still giving him problems, are you worried about Stanton being the starter again against Denver? I'm not.

No. He's proved himself as a solid backup QB who can manage a game and make timely throws. But he also misses a lot, and lets some balls sail. Tough and everything you want in a backup though. I'm not worried if he's starting but it does make it that much more difficult.

Honestly, I'm most worried about Palmer's nerve NOT healing and Stanton getting hurt and raw Logan Thomas (whom I like) having to come in. That's the nightmare fuel right now.

 

[Phrazbit]

Palmer.

Stanton, so far, appears to be a better game manager, but here and there we're going to need our offense to win a games for us and I'm not sold that he can make consistent plays.

Granted if Palmer plays all year he is almost certain to lose a game via 3-4 turnovers but overall the pluses outweigh the minuses.

 

[Garthshort]

Loyalty's statement that DS doesn't do anything special, reminds me of Buddy Ryan's comment about Chris Carter, "All he can do is catch touchdowns (or something like that)". So I'll say all that DS can do is win. At least so far. When we lose, and assuming that DS is still the QB, there will be blame to go around. But not now.

 

[RugbyMuffin]

Drew Stanton must remain Cardinals' QB over Carson Palmer
http://www.nfl.com/news/story/0ap30...n-must-remain-cardinals-qb-over-carson-palmer

PS - Don't shoot the messenger.

 

[82CardsGrad]

Palmer! And it isn't nearly as close as some think!


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[PACardsFan]

If Palmer is close to 100%, then he's the guy. But what if he's 75 or 80%? A nerve issue can take away exactly what Palmer does best, drive the ball downfield. It may also increase his proclivity to throw picks. Manning is the most accurate passer in NFL history, so he's been able to overcome the velocity loss. Can Palmer overcome that?

 

[BigRedRage]

Warner