Sorry, I was not clearer. Nash has gotten progressively worse over the course of his career in Phoenix in 2 areas. Turnovers and Defense at the PG position. If you look at his last 5 seasons here in those two categories and his previous 6 as a Mav, there is no doubt he is worse when look at his averages. However, the point was that Amare has improved areas of his game every single year. The point is that there is no upside to Nash and he will continue to get worse as he gets older. At least it’s debatable if Amare has.
Since Nash's turnovers this season are lower than they were last season, and that year was lower than the one before that, there's plenty of doubt. You were clear enough in your first post. It's just.. not true. Nash's defense is the same as it ever was, bad. It's not any worse than it was in 06-07 when we were a contender. Point guards tear us apart more now because we have Shaq and he can't defend pick and roll or do anything against penetrating guards.
Are you kidding with Amare improving every year? His stats are down in every area from last year. He has improved zero in defense and rebounding since he came here. And his FG% right now is the lowest it's been since 2004.
February TO
Nash (6,2,0,3,1,3,2,5,5,3 = 30) = 3 per game
Phoenix was worst in the NBA at the PG position for this month (63)
Nash = 31% of the teams total TO
Phoenix overall rank 3rd worst in the NBA
Interesting that you take Nash's TOs from the entire month in February as a way to criticize his play under Gentry, even though the first Gentry game was on the 17th. Weird. You have to be aware that the coaching change didn't take place on Feb 1st, so I'm not sure why you would do that.
Anyway, (6, 2, 0, 3, 1 = 12) = 2.4 per game, as I said before.
March TO
Nash (5,2,3,3,0,0,2,2,7,2,4,3,1,3, 7= 44) = 2.9
Phoenix was 5th worst in the NBA at the PG position for this month (62)
Nash = 19% of the teams total TO
Phoenix overall rank #3rd worst in the NBA
Nash was top 5 behind Chris Paul, Deron Williams, and Tony Parker. Man, those are some horrible point guards... He was also #3 in assists for March. He was #4 in points. He was #2 in FG% among point guards who play more than 20 minutes a game. He was #2 in efficiency. The fact that he was able to have less TOs than Paul, Williams, and Parker despite staying in the same class as them in other areas and despite clearly not being as good as them is a VERY good thing.
Sounds like a horrible outing even under Gentry to me.
Then you're crazy.
Steve Nash played his fewest minutes per game out of any month, 6 out of the final 8 he played less than 35 minutes while Dragic was getting more minutes than at any point in the season (18 minutes per game).
This is ideal. It should be the goal for next season.
I just don’t see how keeping this system in place or keeping Steve for that matter gets us any closer. So, why not trade him why he has value or before he completely falls off the cliff? If you have to trade either Nash or Amare, I would trade Nash. Personally, I would ship all 3 out of here (Nash, Amare & Shaq) to rebuild. If I had to pick 2 it would be Nash and Shaq (only because of age and current value). If I had it my way...all 3 would be gone before the next season starts.
If that happened, then we would instantly be one of the bottom lottery teams in the NBA, without a draft pick to show for it. I'd much rather be where Denver and Dallas is right now than be where the Kings or the Wolves or the Bucks are. (Especially without a draft pick!) Your rebuilding plan turns us into the Kings, Wolves, and Bucks. I don't want that and I don't think most Suns fans want that.
This system along with Nash had us being a contender 2 years ago. Since Nash is still one of the top point guards and doesn't look to have declined at all, I think all we need is to trade Shaq and JRich and get some better defenders in their place, make a wise draft selection, have a full season with a healthy Amare under Gentry and we'd be good again. We'd have to be extremely lucky to make the right moves and our GM would have to make smarter decisions than he has made thus far, but so is the case with any team that wants to contend.
Probably my last reply because I don't have the energy or desire for these long time consuming posts where I have to keep opening up stat sites to check and argue stats. It's really boring and tedious. Your posts are always too long.