here is an article I found that best describes how I felt about the film......there are some spoilers
Star Wars: Episode III -- Revenge of the Sith (2005)
Jonathan L. Bowen
With the Clone Wars finally nearing an end as Republic forces throughout the galaxy engage the Separatist armies led by Count Dooku (Christopher Lee) and General Grievous (voiced by Matthew Wood), the promised peace at the end of the war comes at a great price. The Jedi Council, led by Master Windu (Samuel L. Jackson) and Master Yoda (voiced by Frank Oz), suspects that Supreme Chancellor Palpatine (Ian McDiarmid) has sinister plans because of his continuing growth of power, through emergency resolutions pushed through the Galactic Senate during war time. Ambitious and powerful young Jedi Anakin Skywalker (Hayden Christensen), the student of Obi-Wan Kenobi (Ewan McGregor), yearns for more power and grows increasingly frustrated with the mistrust of the Jedi Council. Worse yet, he begins having nightmares about his secret wife, Padme Amidala (Natalie Portman), dying during childbirth, which drives his journey towards the dark side that ultimately leads to the revenge of the Sith.
Revenge of the Sith is a devastating film that makes The Empire Strikes Back look like a comedy. In the darkest film of the Original Trilogy (or “The Holy Trilogy” to Star Wars fans), Luke learns Darth Vader is his father, loses an arm, Han is frozen in carbonite, and the Rebel Alliance loses a battle. Compared to Revenge of the Sith, the events in The Empire Strikes Back seem about as tragic as losing opening day tickets to Gigli. After all, no major characters die, the Rebel Alliance is not completely wiped out, and by now everyone knows that all is well at the end of Return of the Jedi. Unfortunately, for many characters viewers have come to know and admire throughout the prequels, Revenge of the Sith is their tragic ending.
Since 1977, viewers have known the Jedi all die, except for Yoda and Obi-Wan Kenobi, but watching the tragedy unfold is devastating, sad, and depressing. Fortunately, it also leads to a few of the most powerful moments in any Star Wars film, and thus cinema as a whole. The facial expressions that Yoda has at a few key moments in the film are incredible. The animators at ILM, George Lucas’s effects company, have done such a remarkable job on the digital Yoda that his facial expressions alone are enough to make any hardcore fan want to cry. As the events unfold and the Republic he has protected for hundreds of years begins to crumble, Yoda expresses his sadness without speaking, which is a real strength of the film; much of the film’s emotional depth is expressed through expressions and actions, not through dialogue.
Star Wars movies have always taken a lot of criticisms for their dialogue, which I admit to being completely unable to understand. I review several hundred films per year and am quite aware of bad dialogue when I hear it, but the supposedly “awful” dialogue present in all of the Star Wars films certainly is not present when I see them, at least. Nonetheless, Attack of the Clones contained some intentionally awkward lines from Anakin that were meant to convey his lack of maturity and experience with relationships, none of which is present in Revenge of the Sith. The first thirty minutes of the film in fact may be the funniest segment of the entire prequel trilogy. The dialogue, which deserves a detailed examination, really comes together well in the final prequel. The rest of the review will contain detailed spoilers of the film’s plot, so readers looking to go into the final movie unspoiled should stop reading now.
When Obi-Wan kills General Grievous with a blaster, he quickly remarks to himself how the blaster is such an uncivilized weapon, which is funny because it ties in well with his line in A New Hope when he calls a lightsaber “an elegant weapon for a more civilized age” and remarks how lightsabers are not as “clumsy or as random as a blaster.” An exchange of dialogue early in the film has Obi-Wan recommending that he and Anakin take Count Dooku together, to which Anakin agrees, which is of course a reference to Attack of the Clones and the arm that Anakin lost trying to defeat Dooku alone. Dooku has his own comeback line for Anakin after the young Jedi starts boasting of his powers. Dooku tells him, “Twice the pride, double the fall. I have looked forward to this, Skywalker.”
One surprise of Revenge of the Sith is the abilities of R2-D2, who is even more resourceful and able than usual. R2 is particularly feisty, but he also has a keen sense of what is happening around him, which might make viewers wonder if his unusual behavior throughout the Original Trilogy is partially because he, unlike C-3PO who has his memory wiped at the end of Episode III, knows the history of all of the events in the Skywalker family. Unlike in Attack of the Clones, where he provided quite a bit of comic relief, C-3PO really does not have much of a role in Revenge of the Sith.
For me, one of the most devastating, sad scenes of Revenge of the Sith comes at the end of the duel between Anakin and Obi-Wan, where Obi-Wan tells Anakin he loved him like a brother. Watching the two Jedi, who were such close friends throughout the Prequel Trilogy, fight until Anakin is horribly disfigured is very sad and disturbing. The impact is increased by the fact that Anakin followed the path to the Dark Side to save Padme, because he thought she would die during childbirth, but by the end of the film she has forsaken him and Obi-Wan, who Anakin says was like a father to him (in Attack of the Clones), has defeated him in combat and left him a hideous monster.
Lucas has accomplished quite an amazing task in Revenge of the Sith because Darth Vader becomes such a horrible villain that sympathy for him would seem to be difficult to elicit. Even in the course of the film, he commits terrible acts, yet somehow I felt sorry for him nonetheless. Instead of rooting against him in the fight with Obi-Wan, I felt tragically torn and wished that the movie did not have to end in such a sad fashion. Although everyone knows how the story ends, Lucas makes audiences wish that somehow Yoda could just kill Palpatine, Anakin and Obi-Wan could shake hands, and the galaxy could be saved. But the story is set.
Revenge of the Sith, and the Star Wars mythos as a whole, has a lot to say about life and the actions that people take. The Jedi way is one of serenity and calmness in the face of inevitable tragedies, but the Sith way wants to intervene, control, and possess. The Jedi are a mix between stoic sages and Taoist philosophers. They understand that death comes to everyone, and sometimes at inconvenient, tragic times. Anakin cannot accept death. Attack of the Clones proves extremely important in Anakin’s turn towards the Dark Side because of the feelings he has about losing his mother. Anakin is powerful beyond imagination, and beyond his maturity to handle such power, so when he loses his mother, he feels a complete lack of control that he finds intolerable. When he thinks that Padme is going to die, too, he will not accept her fate, but must intervene to stop it because he never wants to feel out of control again.
Anakin actually falls prey to a self-fulfilling prophecy. By becoming obsessed with a vision he has, which is a vision that does not necessarily have to come to fruition, he makes his nightmare occur. His lust for power and control decides his fate, not some pre-determined vision. The message Lucas delivers is clear: Yearning for too much power and control, beyond the realm that any person can reasonably possess, leads to grave tragedy. The Jedi way is not one of passiveness or laziness, but rather decisive action based on the realm of present controllable factors. In The Empire Strikes Back, for instance, Yoda tells Luke not to leave Dagobah because the fate of his friends is not decided, but instead of focusing on the moment, which is the Jedi way, Luke jumps to conclusions and rushes into action. Now we see why Yoda is concerned about Luke’s departure; he has seen a promising young Jedi try to prevent the future from happening already and the results were disastrous. The little connections between Revenge of the Sith and the other Star Wars films are numerous and rich, which makes the final prequel fit into the Saga like a beautiful missing puzzle piece.
Readers will want some sort of bottom line about Revenge of the Sith, which I am prepared to deliver. For any Star Wars fan who has followed the movies for many years, the third prequel will be tragically sad, but powerfully emotional and brilliant. Watching as Lucas ties the film together with not only the Original Trilogy but the first two prequels is an absolute delight. Revenge of the Sith is nothing short of a masterpiece. Looking at the entire six part story, what Lucas has accomplished is forever going to be remembered as one of the greatest epics ever conceived for cinema screens. Watching the credits roll on the final Star Wars film brings mixed emotions. I am excited that Lucas has created such an unbelievably powerful, moving film to end the Saga, but I am sad that I cannot begin counting down the days until the next Star Wars film. As long as the movies continue to entertain and delight audiences worldwide, which I suspect will be indefinitely, the Force will be with us all… always.