Chaplin
Better off silent
Valid criticisms, but he's the best option up front still. Agudelo looks to be another option there, but we need two. If we get Davies back, we could have three, and then maybe we can think about making Altidore a reserve striker.
Arguments aside, I think you hit the nail in the head. I'm cautious about Davies, but if he returns to his previous form, I'm definitely in the camp of having Agudelo and Davies be our everyday starting strikers (in a MUST HAVE 4-4-2), with Jozy as a reserve (I guess--I still don't think he's any good).