Buckybird
Hoist the Lombardi Trophy
Wow!!!
Werhli ...a HOF'er
- Thread starter Buckybird
- Start date
Diamondback Jay
Psalms 23:1
Monk gets shafted again..
The Class is Irvin, Thurman, Bruce Matthews and Charlie Sanders along with Roger Wherli.
The Class is Irvin, Thurman, Bruce Matthews and Charlie Sanders along with Roger Wherli.
OP
OP
Buckybird
Hoist the Lombardi Trophy
as much as I hate the Cryboys, tell me that Irvin should be in before Bob
Hayes and Drew Pearson. The voters have it all wrong. Hayes changed the
game(zone defense) and Pearson was second to only Swann in big time
playoff games.
Hayes and Drew Pearson. The voters have it all wrong. Hayes changed the
game(zone defense) and Pearson was second to only Swann in big time
playoff games.
cardfaninfl
Demographically significant
They let Michael Irvin in but shut out Art Monk...
Twist18
Registered
Long time overdue for Roger. I remember that fake FG for a TD against the Giants as one of my all time fav plays.
Cbus cardsfan
Back to Back ASFN FFL Champion
- Joined
- May 14, 2002
- Posts
- 21,311
- Reaction score
- 7,109
Charlie Sanders ??????????????????
. He must've hired a good PR guys to sell his case. The NFL HOF has the worst formula for induction. It's basically a PR spiel to a commitee and i guess you get in if you bring donuts.
. He must've hired a good PR guys to sell his case. The NFL HOF has the worst formula for induction. It's basically a PR spiel to a commitee and i guess you get in if you bring donuts.
red desert
ASFN Addict
Fantastic.
Codeofhammurabi
Cards Fan Since 1971
- Joined
- Jun 19, 2004
- Posts
- 641
- Reaction score
- 0
Congrats Roger, I watched Wehrli as I grew up. Now I have to see if I am going to follow my word, and go to Canton when a Cardinal gets inducted. Shouldn't be too far from Missouri.
how does a guy like merriman get in the pro bowl and art monk cant get in the HoF?
Ed Burmila
Registered
- Joined
- Jan 4, 2006
- Posts
- 2,364
- Reaction score
- 1
Sanders and Werhli are in the same boat. A pair of guys who were consistently good but never great. Both made 7 Pro Bowls, both are on the all-decade team of the 1970s.
Sometimes the Hall makes guys like that wait in purgatory for a few years, and this year I guess they decided to reward them both.
Since Sanders made 7 Pro Bowls in only 9 seasons (whereas Werhli played 14) if anything he deserved it more. And I can guarantee you that every other team's message board is saying "Roger Werhli?????" right now.
Sometimes the Hall makes guys like that wait in purgatory for a few years, and this year I guess they decided to reward them both.
Since Sanders made 7 Pro Bowls in only 9 seasons (whereas Werhli played 14) if anything he deserved it more. And I can guarantee you that every other team's message board is saying "Roger Werhli?????" right now.
BigRedArk
ASFN Lifer
Ooooh man that was awesome!!!! IIRC that was his last game as a Card. I remember in 1974 he intercepted a pass from Sonny Juregenson at St Lou against the Redskins and I think he returned it for a TD. The 'skins were toast after that play!!!!!
DaCards
I Heart the Cardinals!!
Irvin!!.....Irvin!! Im so angry, I'm pretty much speechless. Voting for the HOF has become a joke.
Renz
An Army of One
Wehrli should have been in long ago. Congrats to him!
Wow. Never thought he would get it. I'm thrilled he did. Monk should be in. I don't know what the problem is. It's almost like a conspiracy to keep him out. I wonder if he pissed somebody off, or what?
TruColor
Trombonist in Roger Goodell's Wedding Rcpt.
Add #22 to the Cardinals Hall of Famers wall:
You must be registered for see images
PJ1
ASFN Icon
Wehrli absolutely deserves it. He was a great corner. QB's just wouldn't throw his way.
Renz
An Army of One
Art Monk was a good WR, but he is no HOF'r, IMO. The only reason Monk's career stats are up there is because he played for so long. He basically had 4-5 good years. He NEVER scored double digit TD's in a season. He only had 100+ receptions once.
The best stat Monk has going for him is that he is in the top 5 in receptions all time, but that is simply because he played for so long, not because he was great.
BigRedArk
ASFN Lifer
All right. Another guy for the Rams to add to their ring of honor.
Congrats to Mr. Werhli.
Second Deck
Registered
- Joined
- Jul 1, 2002
- Posts
- 938
- Reaction score
- 0
Just another HOF from the U University of Missouri that is. Great to see Roger make it.
BigRedArk
ASFN Lifer
Of course the other side of the coin is that Wehrli was signifigantly smaller than Sanders and took more punishment in routinely beiing required to tackle RB's at full throttle. Not to mention covering speed burning WR's like Bob Hayes at the same time. I would argue that Wehrli took much more of a pounding than Sanders did and yet held up for 14 years. Also Werhli played 14 yrs on the worst artificial fields in the NFL and held up. Sanders was a really good TE but Wehrli is much more deserving than he is.
We locals don't discuss it much but there is a huge disconnect between us and the Cards ring of honor. None of those guys except Pat Tillman hold any interest for us. And Pat should not be in the ring of honor because he wasn't anything special as a football player, in my opinion.
The Cards current ring of honor is just another item of proof that ownership lives in the past and has not fully embraced Arizona as "home."
The Cards current ring of honor is just another item of proof that ownership lives in the past and has not fully embraced Arizona as "home."
BigRedArk
ASFN Lifer
I can definitely understand that Jim. It is past time for the Cards to get with it and start winning some games and begin to build a tradition in Arizona.
I understand the sentiment, but who else from the AZ-era should be on the ring? Anneas? Centers? Plummer?
Most of the greats were from the Chicago or St. Louis eras. That's why most of the players on the ring are from them. I don't see it as ownership living in the past, but rather just being reasonable as to who's on it.
