All-time Cardinals team?

PACardsFan

ASFN Icon
Joined
May 15, 2002
Posts
10,266
Reaction score
12,290
Location
York, PA
Let an old guy put in his 2 cents

Offense

Linemen - Dan Dierdorf, Ernie McMillian, Ken Gray, Bob Young, Tom Banks. Notables - Joe Bostic, Roger Finnie, Bob Reynolds, Conrad Dobler, Luis Sharpe, Tootie Robbins, Earnest Dye

Tight Ends - Jackie Smith, JV Cain (died in training camp)

WR's - Roy Green, Mel Gray, Anquan Boldin. Notables - Fitz, John Gilliam, Ahmad Rashad, Pat Tilley, JT Smith, Ricky Proehl, Frank Sanders, David Boston, Sonny Randle.

RB's - O J Anderson. Other studs - Ollie Matson, Joh David Crow, Johnny Roland, MacArthur Lane, Jim Otis, Terry Metcalf, Bobbie Joe Conrad, Charlie Trippi, Stump Mitchell, Larry Centers, Garrison Hearst.

QB's - 1. Jim Hart, 2. Neil Lomax, 3. Charley Johnson

K - Jim Bakken. Others - Al DelGreco, Greg Davis, Chokee-alias Neil Rackers

P - Jeff Feagles, Rich Camarillo, Chuck Latourette (60's)


Defense

Linemen - Eric Swann is by far the best (very weak position in Cardinal History), Al "Bubba" Baker, Simeon Rice, Bob Rowe, Curtis Greer, David Galloway.

LB's - E J Junior, Ken Harvey, Larry Stallings. Others- Freddie Joe Nunn, Eric Hill, Jamir Miller, Carlos Dansby.

CB's - Aeneas Williams, Roger Wehrli. Others - Pat Fischer, Dick "Night Train" Lane, Miller Farr, Norm Thompson.

Safeties - Larry Wilson, Tim McDonald. Others- Jerry Stovall, Adrian Wilson, Leonard Smith.

KR - Vai Sikahema

ST - Ron Wolfley

I'm sure I've left out a bunch, but these names should bring back some fond memories.
 

Russ Smith

The Original Whizzinator
Supporting Member
Joined
May 14, 2002
Posts
88,131
Reaction score
39,707
John "Dr. doom" Barefield.

He wasn't a very good LB but what a great nickname.

QB Lomax
RB Anderson
WR Green, Boldin, Tilley
TE ? Would have been JV Cain if he didnt' pass away so young
OL Dierdorf, Banks, Finnie, Young, Sharpe

DL Greer, Swann blanking on others.
LB Harvey, Nunn(could be DL too)
DB McDonald, Aeneas,
K Bakken
Punter Player I guess

Yeesh how in the world did I forget Jackie Smith? Before my time i guess but man we even have the same last name.
 
Last edited:

CorporalCardinal

Look! A Cards fan in Iraq
Supporting Member
Joined
Mar 7, 2005
Posts
907
Reaction score
0
Location
Somewhere in the Desert.....Iraq
QB Lomax, Hart, Johnson
FB J.D. Crow, Larry Centers
RB Otis Anderson, Charley Trippi
WR Green, J.T. Smith, Boldin, Fitz, Proehl
TE Jackie Smith
OL Sharpe, Dierdorf, Dobler, blanking

DL Swann, maybe Rice, blanking again
LB Nunn, Harvey, Hill
DB Williams, Larry Wilson, Night Train, McDonald
K Bakken (who the heck else would it be?)
P Feagles or Camarillo
KR could put Green here....but I'll go with Via
ST the wolf man Ron Wolfley
 

chicards11

Registered
Joined
Aug 24, 2007
Posts
417
Reaction score
0
Ernie Jones
Robert Massey
Marcus Dowdell
Chris Dishman
Leshon Johnson
Stoney Case
Raynoch T
Troy Hambrick
Steve Bush
J.J. McAddley
Gramatica
Clement and Shelton
Cameron Spikes
Johnny Bailey
 

Lomax to Green 84

Hall of Famer
Joined
May 15, 2002
Posts
1,426
Reaction score
657
Location
Illinois
I would say that Roy Green may have been the most talented Cardinal player ever. Sporting News did a survey of NFL coaches and players in 1983/1984 and Green was named the best and most feared offensive player in the league both years.

The guy in the league right now who most resembles Roy Green in his prime is Steve Smith. Green was awesome from 82-84. It was a short window because he started to have injury issues in 1985, but there was not a better reciever in all of football for those two seasons.

Here is an incredible Roy Green statistic from 1983: He had something like 14 touchdown receptions in 1983 and for each TD reception he averaged 47 yards per catch!!!
 

Cbus cardsfan

Back to Back ASFN FFL Champion
Joined
May 14, 2002
Posts
21,509
Reaction score
7,771
if i had to pick a starting lineup(in my lifetime) for the all-time Cards it would be:
QB-Hart
RB-OJ Anderson, Terry Metcalf
WR-Mel Gray, Roy Green(in a few years it will probably change to Boldin and Fitz)
TE-Jackie Smith
OT-Dierdorf, Ernie McMillan
OG-Bob Young, Conrad Dobler
C-Tom Banks
K-Bakken
KR-Metcalf


DE-Rice, Bubba Baker
DT-Swann,???????, Dockett may turn out be one of the best
LB- E.J. Junior, Eric Hill, Ken Harvey
CB-Aeneas Williams, Roger Wehrli
S-Larry Wilson, Adrian Wilson
P-Player,facemask gives him the nod
PR-Breaston is my projection

Head Coach-Coryell
 

Duckjake

LEGACY MEMBER
LEGACY MEMBER
Joined
Jun 10, 2002
Posts
32,190
Reaction score
317
Location
Texas
DE-Rice, Bubba Baker
DT-Swann,???????, Dockett may turn out be one of the best
LB- E.J. Junior, Eric Hill, Ken Harvey
CB-Aeneas Williams, Roger Wehrli
S-Larry Wilson, Adrian Wilson

Odd that the two best Cardinal safeties of all time are both best friends with Tom Hanks.
 

Camshaft

Registered
Joined
Jul 19, 2002
Posts
338
Reaction score
71
Location
Austin, TX
nostalgia

Best all purpose ST player: Dr. Chuck Latourette. Played three positions on ST - punter, PR, KR. His first two years indicated possible HOF. As the Cards punter, the Cards faked punted a lot, so I guess you could say that he was an RB. Unfortunately, a devasting injury in a 1969 preseason game pretty much did in his football career. In '72, he opted to follow a medical career (radiologist), which was probably more lucrative than a punters pay back then. He died at age 37 from a gunshot wound to the eye delivered by his wife of one year.

Best goal tender: David Williams also WR and backup kickoff kicker to Bakken.

Best all purpose Yds RB: Terry Metcalf
 
Last edited:

Russ Smith

The Original Whizzinator
Supporting Member
Joined
May 14, 2002
Posts
88,131
Reaction score
39,707
Tillman?
No Doubt about it...

Hey what about Timm Rosenbach?
And Conrad Dobler?

I actually intentionally left Dobler off, he was part of the best OL in team history but I always felt like he wasn't as good as his rep. I just think the whole OL was great and he was such a dirty player he got a rep for being better than he really was?
 

Staff online

Forum statistics

Threads
556,073
Posts
5,431,386
Members
6,329
Latest member
cardinals2025
Top